[QUOTE=elucidator]
I do know many good and thoughtful people who, like myself, are troubled by Israels actions, who urge restraint upon a friend with the motives of a friend.
[/quote]
Even in the cases where we’re not going to debate motive, the effect is to argue that Israel should allow itself to be attacked, time and time again.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Awww, c’mon, Finn, you know you’re supposed to avoid the “t” word. Where are your manners?
[/quote]
My manners? We’re not supposed to avoid any ‘t’ word’.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
You make a lot out of this whole “state” thing, like a legal pedant seizing upon a technicality.
[/quote]
What word/phrase would you prefer as less ‘pedantic’? Country? Sovereign-nation? And it isn’t a technicality, it’s part of the meat of the issue. When a country starts a war with you, that entire country is at war with you.
Or if America invaded Canada tomorrow, would only red states be able to be hit in retaliation?
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Eye of the beholder. Isn’t any determination to instill fear in others “terrorism”?
[/quote]
No, I reject that as a useless definition and one that’s far too broad. And I’ve pointed out, for some time now, it’s too vague as to have any real meaning.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Are you suggesting that Israel’s record is pure and angelic, unsullied by the blood of the innocent?
[/quote]
Not at all. I know full well, for instance, about Sabra and Shatilla. But the fact remains that there are people who will, in any instance where Israel defends itself, declare that it’s an act of terrorism.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Sure there are. But the extremity of your rhetoric doesn’t permit honest criticism, you aren’t painting with a broad brush, you’re painting with a fire hose.
[/quote]
Not at all, which is why I’ve been asking the people who are calling for a more ‘proportionate’ and ‘restrained’ response if invading southern Lebanon and conducting brutal house-to-house fighting would lead them to praise Israel for its proportionate and restrained response.
If they can’t answer yes, then they have to admit they’re being intellectually dishonest. They don’t want a proportionate response that only attacks Hezbollah and not its state sponsor. They want -no- response, but they use words like ‘proportionate’ and ‘restrained’.
A response that doesn’t exist can hardly have an adjective applied to it, eh?
I’ve also asked what other means of protecting themselves Israel would be allowed, most of the time the answer is “they’re not allowed to protect themselves.”.
Neither intellectually dishonest formulations nor claims that Israel should simply do nothing are honest criticism. If you want honest criticism, come up with a valid military response you’d get behind. Saying that they should just let their citizens be murdered isn’t a plan, it’s suicide.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Ooops, you did it again. “You and the rest of the people against Israel…” No matter how many times I say it ain’t so, you go blithely on.
[/quote]
You can say it aint so as many times as you want, but this semantic tomfoolery is just silly. you are against, not for, condemning, (insert semantic quibble), Israel’s actions. What term would you prefer?
And although you want to cast this in terms of helping out a friend, your previous analogy was just silly. Instead of someone pouring lighter fluid in his lap, you’ve got a friend who has someone trying to knife him and you’re counseling him to let himself get stabbed until his murderer gets tired.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
No, I don’t want Israel to invade, not because I crave to see them crushed beneath the jackboot, but because I think it’s a really, really bad idea.
[/quote]
Name a better way for them to protect themselves and show Lebanon that it can’t attack Israel with impunity any more? Well, name a better way than your previous suggestion of letting themselves be attacked, which, as should be obvious, isn’t a solution. It’s the problem.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
So I’m not ignoring the question, I’m trying not to embarrass you by pointing out what a dumb question it is!
[/quote]
It’s not a dumb question, at all. Nor would intellectual dishonesty on your part embarass me. The question, asked time and again both explictly and implictly is “how can Israel protect itself”. The answer that, erm… those who are against-Israel’s-actions (:rolleyes: ) is “they aren’t allowed to protect themselves.” As should be obvious, -that- is a ‘dumb’ answer to the question of how Israel should protect itself.
And, as my specific question points out, those who claim that Israel should limit its attacks to Hezbollah are full of it. If Israel actually did that, not one of them would say it was a good thing, they’d just think up new objections.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Of course I’m not going to praise Israel for such an invasion, I’m agin it! Ain’t made that clear yet?
[/quote]
Yes, and I’ve been trying, and failing, to get you to address how you can cast suicide as the council of a friend (with any intellectual honesty). Can you provide -any- solution which allows Israel to protect itself? Or is your only concil that they should just let their citizens be murdered again, and again, and again?
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Nah. I urge restraint as a principle, I don’t pretend to offer a menu of acceptable and unacceptable actions.
[/quote]
And yet, you’ve said that Israel responding to an act of war as if they’re at war is ‘unacceptable’, no?
If you’re claiming that you haven’t disallowed Israel from defending itself, please list the one single military action you’d be okay with Israel taking to defend itself. Otherwise, then yes, you have indeed said that self defense is unacceptable and that there are no acceptable measures that Israel can take to secure its defense.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
No, they didn’t bring the end of the world. But note your following construction: if it did, it would be the fault of others.
[/quote]
Correct, and a fact that’s often glossed over by, erm… those who are, um… not-for Israel being allowed to defend itself.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Who do you imagine will be comforted to know this?
[/quote]
I can tell you who should be discomforted by it; the nations which have allowed it, encouraged it, turned a blind eye to it, and said that Israel can’t respond to attacks on it. If people were -really- worried about a Middle East war, then they’d be demanding that sanctions be imposed on Iran, Syria, and Lebanon without delay, at the very least. But they’re not concerned about that, only with Israel protecting itself.
Or is there any reason that Israel defending itself is a ‘crisis’, but hundreds of rocket attacks against Israeli civilians are just business as usual?
[QUOTE=elucidator]
So long as you didn’t start it, you have no responsibility for how you conduct yourself.
[/quote]
Not true, at all. I would condemn Israel (and thus, be anti-Israel on that issue) if Israel, say, nuked Lebanon. Or firebombed their cities. Or conquered the country and salted the earth.
But showing the Lebanese government that it cannot launch a war and then remain in the clear is not beyond the pale. Not even close.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Stop that. Its annoying as a cat sharpening its nails on a blackboard.
[/quote]
Then stop playing the semantic games that disallow people who are against Israel’s actions (and against Israel’s right to self defense) from being labeled as such.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
No, really. Such annoying rhetorical devices are beneath us both.
[/quote]
Again, I’d be happy to simply say ‘pro-Israel’ and ‘anti-Israel’ in this debate, but you view that as somehow wrong. You’ve gone as far as to say that advising Israel to allow its civilians to be murdered is a friendly position.
What term would you prefer I use?
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Well, whoopty fuck a doo! Is this some form of progress? It will somehow eradicate public posturing and state-sponsored bullshit? Well, halleluja and hosanna!
[/quote]
Why, yes, that is progress. Stopping state sponsorship of terrorism is a much better thing than allowing state sponsorship of terrorism. Again, what term exactly should be used to describe those who think that stopping state sponsorship of civilian targeted attacks on Israel is -not- a good thing?
[QUOTE=elucidator]
(groan)
[/quote]
Hey, give me a term that accurately describes the position that Israel has no right to self defense, and should let its citizens be murdered. “Friend” is not that term.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Pretty much zero. I could probably find it if I went looking for it. But why would want my beautiful mind sullied by such crapola?
[/quote]
It’s been used in this thread. But okay, at least we agree that it’s crap.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Its not the motivation I question, but the actions. Still haven’t managed to make that clear? Sure tried.
[/quote]
And evidently I haven’t made it clear that it’s intellectually dishonest to claim that you don’t have a problem with Israel defending itself, as long as Israel doesn’t actually do anything to defend itself.
I’ve been pointing this out for several posts now. There are -no- actions that the people opposed to Israel’s actions in this situation would be okay with. None. Except allowing their civilians to be murdered.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Agony. I’ll sign anything, I confess. Take pity.
[/quote]
Give me the term that can be used to honestly describe the position that Israel should allow its civilians to be murdered and not take action to protect them, and I’ll use that instead.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
No, it doesn’t, it means what it means. Restraint. You could look it up.
[/quote]
:rolleyes:
Then name a ‘restrained’ Israel action taken in self-defense that isn’t doing nothing?
But if you’re really interested in more semantic games of obfuscation, okay. If you’re using definition 1A, then you are indeed saying that Israel should take no defensive reactions (eg. do nothing). If 1B, then you’d be saying that Israel should limit its actions. But, as nobody has (or will) suggest another defensive action Israel can take, we’re back to doing nothing. You, yourself, suggested just that, saying that a restrained reaction of just dealing with Hezbollah in the south of Lebanon was off the table. Likewise, the second use, to moderate, falls foul of the objection to 1B. None of the people opposed to Israel defending itself have suggested a moderated action, they have suggested, yet again, no action.
If people are going to use restraint to mean ‘take no action’, then they shouldn’t be pretending to talk about ‘restrained action’. As you can’t have a ‘restrained’ action if no action is taken.
[QUOTE=elucidator]
Anyone dumb enough to believe that is too stupid to make their own oatmeal. Israel, the cringing victim? No sale.
[/quote]
Really? Too stupid? Please, then, define the ‘smart’ way it would be taken if Israel never responded to those attacking it? You honestly think that letting their civilians be murdered till the cows come home, and doing not one thing to stop the murderers, would be a show of strength?
[QUOTE=elucidator]
That ripped it. I’m gonna get drunk now, and its all your fault.
[/QUOTE]
Hey, if saying that people who are opposed to Israel’s actions are opposed to Israel’s actions is cause for you to get drunk, I fear for your liver.