Which Editing Oscar-nominee would you vote for?

A couple vets (Sally Menke was last nominated for another Tarantino film, and nominee Cameron won in this category for Titanic), but mostly newcomers here. Which would get your vote?

I thought the editing in Hurt Locker was amazing. It was a tough choice between it and Inglourious Basterds.

I went with The Hurt Locker, hands-down – it’s been many, many months since I’ve seen it, but I still remember how effective the editing was in that movie.

bump

Looks like I’m in the majority.

Hurt Locker – just saw it a couple hours ago – is the only one that left me thinking, Whoa, great editing. That’s my pick.

Hurt Locker – just saw it a couple hours ago – is the only one that left me thinking, Whoa, great editing. That’s my pick.