OK, now I’ve seen that “New Voyages” ep (“In Harm’s Way”) and I’d give it six, maybe seven out of ten without making any allowances at all, and a solid 9 at least figuring what they must have had to work with. It goes like this.
[spoiler]Teaser: The Pike-era Enterprise is being pursued by a Doomsday Machine, and is destroyed with all hands.
In a damaged timeline fourteen years later, Kirk is the captain of the Farragut (mentioned in the TOS episode “Obsession”) and is summoned to the Guardian of Forever. There he is interviewed by the commander of the Federation research base which has been established there, and Mr Spock, who in this timeline is not a member of Kirk’s crew. They discuss the “Doomsday War” which has seen the Federation getting cut to pieces by a lot of Doomsday Machines, and explain that they have found antiproton anomalies spiking in the late 20th century on Earth, and evidence that the timeline isn’t the way it should have been. Kirk, Spock and McCoy go through the Guardian, arriving in 2006 in a quiet USA suburb.
There they meet a late middle-aged woman who has been expecting them. She plays them a videotape recording of Commodore Matt Decker, last seen flying one of the Enterprise’s shuttlecraft on a kamikaze attack on the DM. In the recording, he is an old man. He explains that at the climax of his attack a chroniton pulse time-shifted him out of the DM and into the past, where he was barely able to make his way to Earth. There he was nursed back to health but had no way to return to his own time. He knows he is about to die of old age and tells the trio that the information they want is in the shuttlecraft (which is stowed away in the garage). Armed with the necessary data, Kirk, Spock and McCoy are returned to the Guardian.
They deduce that when the Constellation exploded, the DM was shifted several years into the past by another chroniton surge. There it destroyed several planets and built copies of itself, which is why in the current timeline the Federation is getting taken to the cleaners. Accordingly, it’s necessary to travel into the recent past to find Pike’s Enterprise before the first DM destroys it. This they do with the Guardian’s big brother, a much larger Guardian big enough to pass a starship. The Farragut flies through as Spock opens the Guardian.
Pike is initially suspicious of Kirk, as of course Kirk should not be commanding the Farragut in his timeline, and Kirk manages to convince him only with a hint Spock gave him concerning the events on Talos IV (“The Cage”). The two starships proceed to fight the Doomsday Machine (with the temporary aid of a Klingon ship that is soon destroyed by it) and eventually beat it using the obligatory “modify the deflector array” tactic, whereupon Kirk expects that the Guardian will bring the Farragut back to the present. However, after some time sitting around looking embarrassed, Kirk and crew deduce that the timeline has still not been repaired. They establish that yet another chroniton pulse moved the DM away into the future and they will need to pursue it. Unfortunately they have to use the sun-slingshot method for this and the Enterprise is several years too primitive to make the attempt, leaving the Farragut to go it alone.
On arriving in the future the Farragut is hailed by Fleet Captain Pike aboard the Daedalus, having travelled to the future by the conventional method available to all. The two ships fight the Doomsday Machine again and it appears that Kirk will have to sacrifice the Farragut to defeat it. But just as he is beginning the destruct sequence, Admiral Kirk (post ST:VI by the look of it) appears from the future and orders him out of there. The three ships then succeed in defeating the DM with the modified deflector arrays.
Future-Spock (the only Spock present at the time) is alarmed when the Enterprise detects delta radiation aboard the Daedalus, and despite present-Kirk’s objections (he knows what is about to happen to Pike but is forced to accept it as a necessary part of the restored timeline) he beams aboard and tries to prevent Pike effecting the rescue that will see him crippled. But Pike is lent strength by his desperation to rescue trapped men and Spock is unable to save him.
The future-Enterprise returns to its proper timeline, while the Farragut vanishes and the present-Enterprise reappears through the Guardian, which delivers its usual valedictory speech. The timeline has been restored and Spock is now science officer aboard the Enterprise.
A few months later, future-Spock visits the crippled Pike and advises him that present-Spock has a plan to improve his quality of life…[/spoiler]
The story is complex but good, the FX are astonishingly good, but the viewer has to get used to the idea of the TOS regulars being played by actors who look nothing like the originals (and look very young to me). The tie-ins with TOS episodes are such as to draw smiles and nods of recognition from the typical Trek geek, assuming that I am one.
Go download it now!