Which Over-40 Actress Is Prettier Than Michelle Pfeiffer?

Cafe Society
61

Does your Top 25 include all the ones in the list at the top of this page? If not, please share names that aren’t already here.

62

Going back a little further…

Jan Smithers is 58 years old now.

Dawn Wells will be 70 next year… I wouldn’t call her ‘hot’ any more, but ten years ago she was still smokin’ at age 60.

Barbara Eden (on the left) is now 74.

Lindsay Wagner is 58 years old.

Heather Thomas is 50.

Marilu Henner still looks fantastic at 55.

63

Oh, and Michelle Phillips is still looking fantastic at age 58.

64

Marlo Thomas. I found photos of her on the web, but I have no idea how recent they are.

65

I think Courteney Cox is prettier. Too skinny, but still prettier.

66

No nod to 43 year old daughter of Jayne Mansfield, Mariska Hargitay?

67

Jennifer Beals still looks pretty good to me.

68

Jodie Foster

69

They checked her ID at the door and turned her back. She’s only 39.

70

My Top Five :

  1. Lynda Carter

  2. Salma Hayek

  3. Halle Berry

  4. Monica Bellucci

  5. Tia Carrere

71

Not an actress, but since Sheryl Crowe was mentioned…

In her youth she was the most photographed woman in England, until Princess Diana came on the scene. Stunningly beautiful then, stunningly beautiful now:

Kate Bush - 48

72

Wow, that’s mine as well.

73

Only 58? She must have been a teeny tiny baby when she was in the Mamas and the Papas!

74

Helen Mirren is currently, not used-to-be, scorching hot.

Sigourney Weaver is also an excellent choice.

75

Emma Thompson Beauty, brains, talent all in mass quantities. Le sigh.

76

So far, I think Halle Berry wins, and it’s not even particularly close. That said, I also appreciate the most delectable nominations of Salma Hayek, Monica Bellucci, Jennifer Tilly, and Li Gong. Hmmmm, brunettes across the board, go figure.

77

Joely Richardson has just recently slipped past the 40 mark.

78

Oh, and Bonnie Hunt is totally hot.

79

Two from Memoirs of a Geisha
Michelle Yeoh - 45
Kaori Momoi - 55

80

Salma Hayek; how does anyone even question this? OK, there are other hotties (Halle Berry, Diane Lane, etc.) but seriously? Salma is queen and probably will be on everyone’s list of most beautiful 50 year-olds as well.