The top 3 were the only locks, Stringer was a semi-lock after that, and then I didn’t know what to do with #5. Considered avoiding the cliché by giving Slim Charles a nod, but ultimately that just wouldn’t have been accurate. Maybe if he’d had a few more opportunities to shoot Cheese in the head…
Bunk, Bubbles and Omar were my no-brainers. After that, I picked Slim Charles - he just had some great moments. I was going to pick Frank Sobotka for #5, but since he was only in season 2, I went with Prez for my last pick. I don’t know, if Jay Landsman had been an option, I might’ve picked him.
It is REALLY hard to choose favorites when there are so many well-written, perfectly-acted characters. When I see the actors in other roles, I still think of them as their “Wire” characters.
I think McNulty and Freamon aggressively earned negative points with the fake serial killer scam. Actually, I think that entire plot line was extremely stupid.
Only picking 5 was surprisingly hard. Ranking them was surprisingly easy.
1)Omar - by a lot.
2)Stringer - far behind Omar but far ahead of the rest
3)Lester
4)Bubbles (almost tied with Lester)
5)Prop Joe - who doesn’t get enough love for being the bad ass that he was
Honorable mentions (i.e. people who almost got the 5 spot)
McNulty
Bunk
Bunny
Agreed, and it’s why McNulty ultimately lost the 5 spot to Prop Joe for me.