Sean Connery.
This blog will tell you all you need to know.
Oh come on, no love for Tom Selleck?
I think we can agree that Newman aged muuuch better than Redford.
Alain Delon?
Straight guy here.
Cary Grant came to mind, of course. I support Paul Newman on his eyes alone. And surprised that Peter O’Toole hasn’t been mentioned. Almost impossibly gorgeous. So pretty he shoulda been a girl.
Robert Mitchum
John Barrowman. 'Nuff said.
Straight guy. I’ve always thought of Pierce Brosnan as good looking, but my opinion on men’s looks is rarely(never?) shared by straight women. I’ve never discussed the topic with a gay guy. Hmm. That might be interesting.
Charlie Chaplin
Yep!
Redford should let his hair go white. He looks ridiculous with colored hair.
How can you possibly choose just one? Or five?
Anson Mount
Goran Visnjic
And of course, the man whose beauty is so extreme it can only be described as cartoonish, Shemar Moore…
Completely off topic, I know, but I have experienced the same. Guys that I think women might think good-looking are met with universal scorn by the women I mention them to.
Straight guy here (not that there’s anything wrong with that), but I’ve always thought of Richard Gere as being simply irresistible to wimmen.
Older Richard
mmm
Yum, forgot about him.
Of the same generation - Alan Bates.
FWIW that was my first thought too, though as a straight guy my opinion’s purely academic.
Came in to say Pierce Brosnan. Rrowr.
And young Marlon Brando could melt the celluloid right off the film. Good lord.
Jon Hamm
Peter O’Toole
Zachary Quinto