Who's ____? X or Y

[QUOTE=Zeldar]
Keyword being dynasty: Barrymore.

Whose mouth does weirder stuff, Drew or Julia Roberts?
[/QUOTE]

Julia Roberts.

Who do more people think resembles a horse, Julia or Sarah Jessica Parker?

[QUOTE=NAF1138]
Julia Roberts.

Who do more people think resembles a horse, Julia or Sarah Jessica Parker?
[/QUOTE]

Sarah Jessica “Seabiscuit” Parker.
After being child stars and adult stars, who’s going to get the first old lady starring role, Sarah or Jodie Foster?

Depp was in A Nightmare on Elm Street (it was his first movie) and Bacon was in Friday the 13th.

Foster

Who will win a directing Oscar first: Jodie Foster or Sofia Coppola?

[QUOTE=Little Nemo]
Depp was in A Nightmare on Elm Street (it was his first movie) and Bacon was in Friday the 13th.
[/QUOTE]

Thanks. I’ll try to remember to watch those two next time they’re on cable.

[QUOTE=Little Nemo]
Depp was in A Nightmare on Elm Street (it was his first movie) and Bacon was in Friday the 13th.Foster

Who will win a directing Oscar first: Jodie Foster or Sofia Coppola?
[/QUOTE]

Good one. I figure the politics favor Sofia.

Whose performance has been more roundly chastised, Sofia’s or Pauly Shore’s? (pick any Shore movie – I have never watched one!)

[QUOTE=Zeldar]
Good one. I figure the politics favor Sofia.

Whose performance has been more roundly chastised, Sofia’s or Pauly Shore’s? (pick any Shore movie – I have never watched one!)
[/QUOTE]

Sofia – the suckitude that was Godfather III was laid squarely (albeit unfairly) at her feet.

Who’s going to have the longer career, Sofia or her cousin Nic?

[QUOTE=twickster]
Sofia – the suckitude that was Godfather III was laid squarely (albeit unfairly) at her feet.

Who’s going to have the longer career, Sofia or her cousin Nic?
[/QUOTE]

Trick question, perhaps? Nic’s got about 10 years head start, so Sofia’s got to match that assuming Nic bails anytime soon.

I go with Nic.

Who’s mannerisms are easier to imitate, Nic’s or Walken’s?

Walken.

Who’s a better SNL host: Christopher Walken or Steve Martin?

[QUOTE=Little Nemo]
Walken.

Who’s a better SNL host: Christopher Walken or Steve Martin?
[/QUOTE]

Gotta go with Walken again.

What otherwise great actor gets roped into more crappy movies: Walken or De Niro?

Ooooo. Toughie. Gotta go with DeNiro - the Rocky and Bullwinkle movie, and the one about the evil cloned kid, put him over the top.

Who was the greater actor of the 1970s, DeNiro or Pacino?

[QUOTE=Diomedes]
Gotta go with Walken again.

What otherwise great actor gets roped into more crappy movies: Walken or De Niro?
[/QUOTE]

easily De Niro

who has had more GREAT performances in crappy movies De Niro or Al Pachino?

[QUOTE=Diomedes]
Gotta go with Walken again.

What otherwise great actor gets roped into more crappy movies: Walken or De Niro?
[/QUOTE]

I’m going to say De Niro
Who more often than not plays the same type of character - Robert De Niro or Michael Caine?

Simulpost - and not so far apart in subject, either! I’ll defer to NAF1138.

[QUOTE=Elendil’s Heir]
Ooooo. Toughie. Gotta go with DeNiro - the Rocky and Bullwinkle movie, and the one about the evil cloned kid, put him over the top.

Who was the greater actor of the 1970s, DeNiro or Pacino?
[/QUOTE]

Since there’s a bit of a logjam here, and since I believe all these questions can be answered “DeNiro,” I’ll just add another:

Whose facial mole is more distracting, DeNiro’s or Cindy Crawford’s?

[QUOTE=Zeldar]
Whose facial mole is more distracting, DeNiro’s or Cindy Crawford’s?
[/QUOTE]

Cindy’s
Who had the longer lasting celebrity marriage/LTR - Crawford/Gere or Brinkley/Joel?

Brinkley/Joel, I think.

Who’s sung or written more Top 40 songs, Billy Joel or Elton John?

[QUOTE=Elendil’s Heir]
Brinkley/Joel, I think.

Who’s sung or written more Top 40 songs, Billy Joel or Elton John?
[/QUOTE]

I’m going on pure guesswork, but I’d bet it’s Billy, but not by a lot (I’m curious enough to want to know the right answer.)

Anyway,

Who’s more a “homer” for New York, Billy Joel or Frank Sinatra?

[QUOTE=Zeldar]
I’m going on pure guesswork, but I’d bet it’s Billy, but not by a lot (I’m curious enough to want to know the right answer.)

Anyway,

Who’s more a “homer” for New York, Billy Joel or Frank Sinatra?
[/QUOTE]

Sinatra in a walk.

Who was the better ratpack actor Sinatra or Sammy Davis Jr?

[QUOTE=NAF1138]
Sinatra in a walk.

Who was the better ratpack actor Sinatra or Sammy Davis Jr?
[/QUOTE]

Well, neither is a Brando or a DeNiro; or a Sam Jackson or a Don Cheadle, but I’ll lean in Frank’s direction on this one.

Who’s the better model for an Italian American, Sinatra or James Gandolfini?

[QUOTE=Zeldar]
Who’s more a “homer” for New York, Billy Joel or Frank Sinatra?
[/QUOTE]
See, now I would have pegged Sinatra as a “Joisey Boy”, not New York at all

I’m going to say Gandolfini - because he only acted like that guy, while Sinatra’s ties in real life were mor ethan mere speculation.

Who’s a more sympathetic anti-hero - Gandolfini’s Tony Soprano or Johnny Depp’s Capt Jack Sparrow?