[QUOTE=twickster]
Jinx – short answer, to keep people honest. If editing were allowed, someone could say something in a post, have people respond to it, and then go back and change the post, in order to claim “that’s not what I said.”.
[/QUOTE]
*So what? * I mean that really. If you do edit your post (at least on the boards I have been that allow editing- which is just about every other board) it shows you edited at such & such a time, and often your reason for editing.
Then again, if it is really really important to you to have the exact wording of a post you are replying to, you can always QUOTE that part of the above post in your post, just like I did here.
Next- ofttimes someone types something that when read in one way is not all all what he meant to say. After being called on it, the OP will says “Well, that’s not what I meant at all, you misread it. What I meant to say was this “Xxxxxxxxx””. However, some 12yo’s here on this board will just plain not let it go, they will constantly harp back to the OP’s original words, over and over and over. :rolleyes: Perhaps, some letting go is best.
Finally, editing is seen by the Staff here as “the end of civilization as we know it”. I can tell you that on boards that do allow editing- it is 99% to correct typos and for clarification. The other 1% of the time it is for “Well, that’s not what I meant at all, you misread it. What I meant to say was this “Xxxxxxxxx””. Never have I seen it used as “That’s not what I said, you’re misquoting me” after really saying that but editing it out. The reason for that is obvious- there’s a record of the original post and if a Poster made such a complaint and was lying, the Staff could easily show him wrong*. Thus- it just plain doesn’t happen- well, I have never seen it happen in the dozen + MB I post on that allow Editing. Yeah over on one board, on rare occasion, some dude will (rarely) edit out his entire post and leave in a snit- but never have I really seen them post “you’re misquoting me, that not what I said”- when that was what they said but they edited that. Sure, I know Tuba and the other vets here claim that *once upon a time * it was allowed and it turned out bad. Well, that was very very long ago, and “that was then, this is now”. I doubt if as many as 1/10 of 1% of our current posters were around here then, and I really doubt if any of the troublemakers are still around. So, we are going to punish this current crop of *paid * subscribers for something that happened long before any of us were around? Oddly, other MB’s are not plagued with that problem, and have been allowing editing since at least as long as the SDMB has been not allowing editing.
*Yes, I know this would be “extra work” for the Staff. But how often does a poster here use the “quote function” to maliciously (and with an intent to convince dudes it’s the original words) change the OP’s post? Rarely, as it’s a bannable offense. Doing the “extra work” involved in telling dudes “yes, the QUOTE is the original wording, the OP is lying, he edited his post” is = to the “extra work” involved in telling posters that they have “used the quote function to maliciously (and with an intent to convince dudes it’s the original words) change the OP’s post.” In other words- just about no extra work.