“What do photographers tell people to say in other languages? Don’t ask me; I don’t get out much. If the Teeming Millions want to chime in with their experiences abroad, now’s the time.”
I asked the wife what Thais say, and she gave me a puzzled look. Said they say Yim of course, which is Thai for smile. They also copy the English word “cheese” even if they don’t know what it means, because they think that’s just what you’re supposed to say.
For giggles, I sometimes tell people to say “Mouse.” Usually, at least one of the subjects will say “MOUSE??”, which puts their face into an angry-looking scowl. Pressing the shutter button at the magic moment often yields hilariously awful portraits.
Saying “Cheese” does nothing to my mouth, smilewise. It’s the same expression as saying, for example, “Duh”. At least “Beep” makes my lips open and close a couple times, though I don’t see the point of that.
I’d go with it’s a clearly stupid thing to say at the time- intended only to spark a bit of a laugh. (And is so timeworn it no longer works.)
The day David Cameron was outed* over the pig business I got some great shots of my friend’s habitually stern 15 yr old son by saying “Pork!” “Piggies” and other variants to get a natural grin
*I realise that he has since denied it but on that day we believed it 100%, now only 99.999…
My trick is to tell them to say cheese and if there’s any hesitation I yell at them in fake aggravation “I said say cheese, goddamnit!” and it often gets a natural laugh, which is when I take the pick.
When my father-in-law was more active than he can be now, he used to tell his photo subjects to say “sex”. You can imagine.
About the funniest New Yorker cartoon I ever saw was of a photographer under an old-style cloth taking a picture of a group of people who were all screaming “CHEESE!”
A two-ton block of Swiss was about to fall on him out of the sky.
Heh. I was traveling with a bunch of fellow VISTA volunteers – so of course all of us nobly worked full-time in social services. We were in the airport and asked someone to take our picture, and he says “Say money!” Money was so not on our radar or any kind of motivator and so came totally from left field-- one woman has the most befuddled look on her face! The embodiment of HRMM?! :dubious:
As a photojournalist, I mostly say “stop posing and looking at me and pretend I’m not here.”
When doing portraits, my go-to is “pretend you’re enjoying this,” or for couples, “act like you actually like each other,” which usually gets a decent real smile.
For groups, I say “okay, everybody smile, in three …” [clickclickclick] “two … one.” Because the countdown seems to be the modern way to get people to smile, but they’re usually starting to grimace or blink by “one.”