More specifically, why is there any vocalization at all? When I breathe heavily while working out I don’t vocalize. When I cough I don’t vocalize. What is it about a sneeze that activates the vocal cords?
Note: prior threads asked why we say “achoo” instead of some other sound; I am asking why we make a sound at all.
At the start of a sneeze you have a sharp intake of breath. This makes the “AH” sound.
Then the air is expelled and, for some reason, we close our mouth (mostly) on the exhale (thinking about it now I cannot imagine sneezing with my mouth wide open). That action makes a “CHOO” sound.
My father would swear when he sneezed…“AH…Shit” so…¯_(ツ)_/¯
Sneezes involve reflex spasmic forcing of air out of the lungs and through the vocal cords which are also affected by the spasm. That’s gonna make a sound regardless. One can modulate the shape of the cords a bit as it’s happening but the end result is usually a vocalization that can be stereotyped into a few typical categories of sound.
A sneeze is a comparatively violent respiratory action. Such sudden and massive air movements within the respiratory tract are unavoidably going to make a lot of noise even if you leave the vocal cords out of it.
Coughs are more organized, semi-voluntary responses of muscles. Even so, coughs tend to make noise also. The sound can just be stifled/modulated a bit easier.
Thanks for the vote of confidence, but I’ve been wrong before, and will be again. Sometimes I discover my ‘knowledge’ is outdated. Or was wrong in the first place. Live and learn. Which beats live and don’t learn.
Ah-choo seems one of the better onomatopoeia words in the English language, as it fits the sounds produced by the actions so well. Not always the case.
Sometimes, when I feel like being obnoxious, I engage my vocal cords during the “choo” portion of the sneeze. It’s like a hella loud shout on top of the normal plosive noise.
I discovered long ago that you could actually vocalize when you sneeze. Somehow, I have no idea exactly how, I trained myself to exclaim, “Malahunga!” I only do it in private although I have slipped a time or two. No, I’m not joking.
I have to be very careful not to holler “HORSESHIT!” during a sneeze should I ever find myself in polite company. Luckily, the dogs do not speak English and think it’s me asking if they want to play. Cuz Doge.