[QUOTE=Chronos]
Of course, another factor is simple luck. Even if all parts of the world were on an equal footing (which, of course, they’re not), someone would end up on the top of the tech race. It just so happens that, the way history actually played out, it happened to be the European societies.
[/quote]
And this, in fact, is in large measure dumb luck. For most of historical civilization the Far East has been significantly more technologically advanced than Europe; it was the result of internal political pressures that resulted in technological and literary stagnation during or soon thereafter European expansion.
As for Africa: I’ll reinforce the claim that Jared covers this in exhausting detail, but it was a variety of factors–the lack of large work animals, no long-standing transcontinental trade routes (especially natural waterways), the lack of development and maintenance of literacy, poor agricultural resources, the lack of semi-defensible geography of Europe and Asia, et cetera–which prevented aub-Saharan Africa from developing industrial civilization. (The nations of North Africa, on the other hand–particularly Egypt and Carthage–were as developed technologically and politically as contemporary nations in the Mediterranean and more advanced in their time that the nations of Northern Europe.)
The Americas serve as kind of a convenient baseline for this; populated by a genetically constrained group of people (who presumably had about the same level of innate intellectual capabilities), those who settled in areas rich in resources developed more advanced civilizations with high population densities (witness the Aztecs), and others remained less developed; the almost complete lack of indigenous work animals left the American aboriginal people at a disadvantage when it came to competing with the Europeans in dense agriculture and military prowess, but when given the opportunity to obtain domestic species the Americans demonstrated a comperable aptitude for their use.
As for Africans being intellectually inferior as demonstrated by evaluation of IQ: it’s not that this is non-PC that makes this misguided; it’s the fact that IQ tests are by nature biased toward the group they’ve been developed to test, i.e. literate peoples of developed nations. Nutrition may play some impact in the development of intelligence (as measured by an IQ test), but more influential is early childhood development, cultural and intellectual literacy, and an educational basis similiar to that anticipated by the test-makers. If one were to develop an IQ test based upon the applied intellectual talents required by semi-nomadic tribal existance it would probably involve things like being able to identify local herbs and wildlife, reading weather patterns, navigation across featureless savanahs, ability to locate water, et cetera, and your average or even intellectually extraordinary resident of a developed nation would flunk it badly. The people of Polynesia used to navigate thousands of miles in dugout canoes using the stars and ocean currents, a feat so intellectually complex that authorities in the field are still trying to figure out how they did it, and yet there are no notworthy Polynesian cartographers or mathematicians.
There is no indication of significant innate intellectual differences between people of different ethnic backgrounds when seperated from sociological influences. That’s not Politically Correct, it’s just correct.
Stranger