MAFIA started life as a proper noun but is most often used these days as a common noun, but I wasn’t sure if that was enough to make it eligible.
[/quote]
That was my reasoning too, and why I went with what I did in my 4th guess.
THUMB → Slow start. Try the known letter in first, add A & E and two WoFcons and try MATES → Darn it, should have been MARES rather than replaying the T - or MALES, or MANES. Make sure I get it right this time, and with an O MANOR → That’s better. Is there an I in there? MALIC → There is. Getting low on letters, do I have a repeat? MAXIM → Not of the M. One guess left, the only one I see has a different repeated letter, but let’s try it MAFIA
After my followup fumble (the three variants on what I tried were 1, 3, and 5/979, respectively) my guesses were pretty acceptable by Scoredle standards - 6/77, 8/31, 1/3 and then the only valid answer for the double bogey - but I think that followup lost me a full guess. Scoredle gets it in four, with a tap-in on the clincher.
Apparently, it’s only a proper noun when it refers to the specific organization that started in Italy. But as a general noun referring to any general criminal syndicate, it’s not.
Word 4 was an unforced error (I’d already eliminated A in the fourth position), but at the same time it told me there was a second A and not a second M, which was useful information. A par wasn’t going to be in the cards anyway.
For sure! The question was really whether Josh Wardle might’ve excluded it on account of its having been a proper noun. It’s not always clear where the lines are within the universe of this game, at least for those of us who don’t choose to access Wardle’s original list of solutions.