Wouldn’t it make sense for an Iranian ship’s captain to negotiate a surrender to US forces in 2026?

Missed that, all credit to beating me to that punch.

I don’t know how friendly Sri Lanka is to the US, but I doubt the US would have any compunction about punishing them for providing too much aid and comfort to an Iranian warship.

Moderating: Keep this thread on Ships please.

After reading the Guardian report nore carefully, I think we already know what’s happening to the ship and crew.

(emphasis added)

That’s internment. The belligerent in neutral port (persons and vessels/vehicles) is taken into the custody of the neutral. They are supposed to remain in custody for the duration of the conflict.

I suppose the question remains how thoroughly Sri Lanka takes its responsibility as an interning neutral state under the 1907 Hague Convention.

What wonderful news.

That’s over 200 lives spared.

They may not be welcomed back to Iran without facing punishment.

Who says for sure they don’t find somewhere else to live after the war? :smiley:

That article must of been updated. It said Sri Lanka was considering options when I linked it.

I remember something about their small morgue being overwhelmed from the recovered bodies sunk ship.

Here’s hoping their families don’t face punishment! Some of the crew are likely to be conscripts, which makes the situation even worse in case of regime revenge.

As a supply ship (essentially a cargo ship with grey paint), I doubt it is a high-priority target for the USN, if a target at all. But i don’t blame them for seeking a neutral port as refugee.

OTOH, it only takes one shot to kill a freighter. Not a large expenditure of US munitions or money. It’s not like the Iranian Navy has a large number of combatants.

True, but IIRC there are still 4 or 5 frigates and a couple of corvettes left in the IRIN. If i was betting man, my $$ would be on that attack sub having long left the area and on the hunt for those.

Decent bet USN or NRO reconnaissance knows where they all are. Anything not tied up to an Iran-friendly dock is on the hit list.

Did you see the video upthread about the blowing up of the frigate or whatever it was? One shot and it fucking blew the ship out of the water! Those modern torpedoes pack quite a punch! No wonder the crew got the yips!

Do the Iranians have any countermeasures against an American sub, or could a single one basically handle their entire fleet?

Unlike unguided WWII-era torpedoes, they also tend to not miss.

And modern submarines are essentially undetectable without intense ASW (anti-submarine warfare) efforts. The first indication most surface vessels (i.e. “targets”) have of an enemy submarine is the big explosion.

The latter.

The Mark 48 is quite a nasty piece of munitions, and the Iranian ship was at the lower end of what anyone would consider a warship. The US Navy ship closest in displacement to that teeny weenie frigate is the Avenger class minesweeper. US frigates have been, currently are, and will be 2-5 times bigger.

A Mark 48 against the Dena was shotgunning a squirrel.

A squirrel that wasn’t expecting anything because it was just having a friendly romp.

It is a wonder to me that they were able to send a distress signal at all.

Oh, dear! That does not look good. Both sides seem indeed to be burning everybody’s good will all around at a fast pace.
Yes, it’s war and all that. But that torpedo attack does not look like it was necessary.

Hesgeth seems to be as US-centrically ignorant as the rest of the Trump administration - his claim that this was the first ship sunk by a torpedo since WW2 may be true specifically for the US Navy, but the Royal Navy and Argentine Navy would disagree (Sinking of ARA General Belgrano - Wikipedia).

The torpedo hit the stern, so the bridge was intact and radio systems probably kept working by battery until the survivors had to abandon ship.

So would the Pakistani navy

PNS Hangor (S131) - Wikipedia

The US criminal regime should not have started this stupid war.

But the nature of modern war is that once it begins, the entirety of the enemy military is a legit target. Even if all (or any) of the units on their side have not yet gotten the word that there’s a war going on.