The 70 PVP gear sucks.
I mean, it’s not terrible, but it’s in no way worth what it costs.
I was really happy when they switched the honor system from a relative ranking system to a currency system. I figured it gave an alternative path to getting good gear - you didn’t have to necesarily raid all the time, at specific times, and coordinate with 39 other people. You could work at your own pace, PVP, and work your way up to getting good gear.
And the gear was awesome! Sure, you had to work for it - the old PVP dagger would take about 75-100 AB matches to get, but it kicked the hell out of anything you could buy, and was competitive with what you could get on raids. So it seemed worth it, if you liked to PVP.
But the level 70 gear isn’t that much better than the level 60 gear. And more importantly, it’s not much better than that you could easily acquire by buying or questing. The PVP dagger has almost the exact same stats as a world drop BOE dagger I could buy right now for around 400g. And in BC, 400g is nothing. I’ve made somewhere around, I dunno, 3000-4500g since BC came out. There’s another, more rare and expensive, BOE dagger that you can buy that is significantly better than the PVP dagger.
And the armor is garbage. An example: Pants I got from a quest at level 66: +30 agi +45 sta +62 AP. The rogue PVP pants: +28 agi +42 sta +14 crit +28 resilience +28 AP. My current pants, which I acquired from a relatively easy quest, at level 66, are equal to or better than the level 70 PVP pants which would require 23625 honor, which is about 60-75 runs of AB or WSG even on their battleground weekend
So we’re talking about dozens of hours to get something that’s arguably worse than what I already have.
I don’t know how other classes compare really, so maybe their gear isn’t as sad as that of rogues, but most of the PVP armor isn’t all that much an improvement over the common green armor available to me at level 67, and yet you have to work for dozens of hours for every piece.
So, they made a good feature - honor as currency - and then made it useless by making it so that nothing you can buy is remotely worth the effort.