You can't show me HDTV on my TV, so stop trying.

Samsung, LG, Mitsubishi, Dell, and all the rest of you thick-skulled assrags: listen up, and listen good. I may be typing this in plain text, but my marketing manager has assured me that through the magic of THE INTERNETS, you will be getting this pitting in HIGH DEFINITION. You may want to put earplugs in, because I hear Comcast High-Speed Internet delivers my ASCII posts in Dolby fucking surround sound seven-point-three-point-two and then some. Put on some oven mitts and welder’s goggles, because your keyboard and monitor are going to shoot actual flames at you as I, your humble Pitter, let loose my True Digital SharpRant[sup]TM[/sup] technology.

I have a regular definition television. You know I do, because you’re showing me and millions of other football-watching Americans advertisements to entice us to buy an HDTV this Christmas. Your marketing departments have really hit a goddamn home run this time. “We’ll show them what HDTV can do!” they must have said. “We’ll put a little girl and an elephant and a box with little mirrors, and they’ll have to buy it!” Well, I hope the elephant grabs the box with mirrors and jams it up your ass, and I hope the little girl gives him a handful of high-definition peanuts for the deal. I’m watching football in regular old low-def, and no matter what crazy tricks you do with parallax, Hitchcock zooms, saturated colors, or any other fancy Hollywood shit, the picture you send me – even if it is brighter and sharper than Obi-Wan-fucking-Kenobi’s-goddamned-lightsaber – is going to come through the same copper cable, into the back of the same television I’ve had for five years now, and I’m going to see your amazing, super-ducking-fooper advertisement in plain old low-def teevee.

“Holy shit!” your ad execs must be saying, “he might as well be using rabbit ears! He’s probably running the television off of a coal-fired steam generator!” Nope - my picture looks like the same picture most of my buddies have. In fact, it might even look a little better. However, the fact remains: while I’ve got a pretty nice television, it ain’t HD*, and so I can’t see your HD content. Would you advertise a closed-captioning device for deaf people on the radio? Would you put up a billboard with the hotline for illiterates? Would you hire a man whose entire cranial cavity was filled with delicious chocolate pudding, and put him in charge of your advertising budget? YES! Most of us wouldn’t, but apparently, this sounds to you like a peach of an idea!

So, HDTV manufacturers, you can go ahead and show me your HDTV standing on a bright background, so its frame looks extra sharp and black and the picture inside looks artificially bright; I won’t see it, but I hope you bled from the eye sockets checking the dailies on an HD monitor. You can stick your “genuine digital reality” and cram it up your piehole sideways so that each of the 1,080 lines of crystal-sharp resolution lacerates your colon. You, and the little girl, and the box of tiny mirrors, and the eidetic high-resolution pachyderm can all go re-enact a version of The Aristocrats that would make Bob Saget nauseous, and film the whole thing with a supercomputer cluster, attached with Monster Cables that would bankrupt Bill Gates, plugged straight into God’s Own All-Seeing Eyeballs, and still, I tell you, still: I will only see the commercials in regular definition.

Please stop wasting your money. Make way for a commercial that at least makes a modicum of goddamn sense. Get off of my teevee screen with your “simulated picture” bullshit, please! It may be low-definition, but it’s my teevee, and when I want to see John Madden’s pores, I’ll let you know.

    • it’s HD-ready, so I could get an HD tuner, but I watch maybe two hours of television a week on my own TV. I mainly use my TV as a monitor for my Gamecube.

What a bizarre rant.

That’s all right, I can remember watching commercials for color TV in black & white.

Wow. An actual honest to goodness old school Pit rant. Well done.

Then Pudding-For-Brains must be a senior VP by now.

They actually do this.

I don’t know why I’m still giggling helplessly over this one, but I am. :slight_smile:

Apparently the answer is yes they would

Oh HELL yes. applause I’m so grateful for this rant. I don’t watch TV these days, but I remember distinctly thinking in my youth “Why the hell are you trying to show me how great DVDs look, on an ad on a VHS tape?” If those ads are anything to go by, the image and sound quality are the same but it causes you react like a cretin whenever anything happens on screen.

deep breath But yes, good rant. Bonus points from me for having a TV for the exact same reason I do.

While I can’t imagine caring enough to rant, I’ve had the same thoughts when high-def commercials come on. ‘I have a plain old crappy TV, one with really, really bad cable, such that most my channels come in fuzzy - even when you’re pretending to show me HD content, it’s still fuzzy.’

Monster cables are for morons.

Nice rant.

I’ve often thought about this issue when they have ads for HD, but i’ve never managed to work up quite your level of vitriol or the energy required to make a post about it.

Please consider me a supporter, and sign me up for all future High Definition Pit Threads.

My favorite was:

I’m going to use that at my next faculty meeting, when we discuss the district budget cuts.

Seems like a strange rant. I suppose by the same logic, there’s no point in advertising food on TV because I can’t taste food on my TV?

Not really.

They tell you that the food tastes good, and they show you pictures of it. But they don’t claim that you can taste the food by watching the ad. Ads for HD imply that you can see the quality of HD in the commercial itself, but if you haven’t got an HDTV, it’s a pointless exercise.

I have absolutely no fucking idea why you’re saying what you’re saying, but I love the way you said it.

I really haven’t noticed this recently. I don’t watch all that much TV, but I recall watching a bit within the past week or so, and seeing a number of abstract, colorful ads for HDTV and thinking “at least they’ve stopped trying to show us how good HDTV looks in regular resolution.” Seriously, the last time I watched a decent amount of TV, I noticed a distinct lack of what the OP is talking about. All the HDTV ads (and they’re getting pretty numerous now that the technology has finally become affordable for a sizable market) were abstracted depictions of bright colors dancing around, combining, whatever, as long as it looked bright and impressive.

Yeah, you really can’t show HDTV resolution on my TV, but you can find ways to suggest the difference, and that seems to be what all the HDTV commercials I’ve seen recently are doing.

I don’t think I’ve ever said this specifically about a rant before, but dude, that was awesome. Truly a work of art.
::: bows before greatness :::

Ha! I can remember listening to commercials for crystal radio sets on wax cylinders!

Sorry, I have to call this an unjustified pitting. It’s a commercial, they have to show you a picture of the product, and it’s just flat out dumb to advertise a television with the set turned off. The “simulated picture” thing is used all the time, whenever they are showing a display of any kind or even a photograph in an advertisement. This isn’t even close to being an HDTV thing.

Standard Definition broadcasts of football games are the perfect place to advertise HDTV, you can pretty much guarantee that your advertisement is reaching people who watch TV, and who would benefit from HDTV.

Football fans are also more likely to be enthusiastic about their games, and getting the most from their viewing experience. Football looks much better in HD, and guys will be willing to fork over the dough for an upgrade just to get their Sunday games in HD.