I think the two of us have come to the conclusion that the problem really was a series of misunderstandings. For example, when I told him I would marry him, it was more an off-hand remark that I never in a million years would have expected him to consider than an actual request so, when he started asking “What about…?” and “What if…?” questions, I thought he was pointing out all the ways it was impossible and just not a good idea* when what he was really doing was trying to work out the practicalities of it.
It sounds so stupid now I know but that’s what I thought I knew, that he was definitely opposed to the idea of being with anybody because, you know, commitment and a whole other person minimizes freedom and it’s nice to know that he could pack up and live in a yurt in the wilderness if he wanted without having to worry about anybody else (even though I TOLD HIM I would live in a damn yurt to be with him).
Anyway, to answer your questions: in my mind he had a good three, four years to think things through. I thought I had been pretty clear re: my feelings but, again with the misunderstandings, he says he never realized how very serious it was (despite the fact that I told him more than once over a period of time way prior to this that I didn’t think he was taking my feelings as seriously as he maybe should) until I told him I would be his wife. From the point that he finally did get it? Not long enough, apparently.
And you’re right, there is a chance that daily contact would have been disastrous but I doubt that very much. Even so, I think even if it had failed miserably it would have been worth a shot.
*We’ve problem-solved this way before so it’s not as unreasonable and stupid an assumption as it maybe looks on paper. Imagine if I said “I’m going to drop out of school because I will make more money cooking meth and, hey! More free time!” Rather than telling me I shouldn’t or that it’s a dumb idea, he would ask “What about…?” and “What if…?” type questions to make me look at the big picture so that I would eventually see how crazy it was all on my own. I’m a little impulsive, so that’s kind of how he’s always talked me out of doing things that seemed like a neat idea but would never work for whatever reason.