Persons currently watching The Walking Dead, and who once watched Star Trek: Voyager, will understand the question. Persons who’ve never watched either show will not. i’m not explaining. If I were one of those people I wouldn’t bother with the thread, but you people will do whatever you feel like I don’t know why I bother complaining.
Oh, and assume that Team Grimes is present either way, because Michonne and Carol, damn.
Poll in a moment. Absurd answers preferred. Anyone who submits a logical, well-reasoned response will be forced to eat a live tortoise.
I’ll lead my own refuge, with orders to kill either one of them on sight.
We don’t need no stinking ‘I feel…hunger’ as the zombies approach, nor do we need Psycho Janeway trying in vain to lead. Hell, she’d probably send a horde of Redshirts out without deadly weapons, with orders to ‘capture and restrain’ the zombies so they can be studied. :smack:
I’m thinking Troi won’t sense anything from zombies, which makes her more useless than ever. Janeway will drag us all over the Delta Quadrant, but at least she’ll know enough to shoot for their heads.
This is my own fault. I meant Deanna from WD, played by Tovah Feldshuh. In my own defense I had blocked all memory of the Troi-beast from my memory. Except when she was wearing that flowing aqua dress that showed off her clavicles, because damn.
Must I explain why I am comparing WD!Deanna and the prettiest Trek captain?
I’m confused. I thought Kirk was the prettiest ST captain.
And I don’t watch Walking Dead, so I’ll assume Troi anyway, and in that comparison, it’s Troi in a heartbeat. She and Janeway are about equally incompetent as leaders, but the difference is that Troi knows she’s incompetent, and so would quickly step aside in favor of someone with a clue. Janeway, however, is for some reason working under the delusion that she’s worthy of being a starship captain, and so would continue to make decisions that doom her crew for no good reason week after week, even when those decisions are clearly against regulations and their disastrousness is obvious.
Which is because WalkingDead!Deanna is played by Tovah Feldshuh, who looks very like 90s! Kate Mulgrew, only Janeway looked a lot better when all sweaty from fighting giant flying space viruses.
But Janeway will always have Seven at her side, and Seven will always save her. I can prove it logically.
Deanna has thus far ensured Alexandria’s survival due to luck outside of her control.
Janeway, while sometimes making stupid decisions, can have moments of decisive leadership.
Deanna has show no ability to lead. People follow her because she used to be a politician and they don’t know how to stand in front of a group and give orders.
I’ll take my tortoise with a light bearnaise sauce
Janeway, with Seven because Seven could inject recently deceased person with Borg nanoprobes and reanimate them alive. She only used this ability on the show once, unfortunately with Neelix.
Decisive, yes. Good, no. Like when she got her ship and crew stranded on the ass end of the Galaxy as a result of her decisive decision to violate the Prime Directive for no good reason and very little even of a bad reason.
Interesting, borg nanoprobes could high jack the zombies to spread themselves throughout the swarms of WD as a reversal agent while I’m sitting poolside, my kind of plan.
On a very long submarine voyage in 1985, Tovah Feldshuh’s performance in Cheaper to Keep Her was one of my few sources of comfort.
I have no idea what The Walking Dead is supposed to be all about, but since in kaylasdad-land Star Trek begins and ends with Jim, Spock and the gang on their [del]three-hour tour[/del] five-year mission, I’m going to risk the bees and ask for Deanna.
Wait, are we repopulating the planet in this scenario?