2027 Baseball Hall of Fame Nominees

Earlier this week, the National Baseball Hall of Fame announced the ballot for next year’s Hall of Fame class.

There are fourteen first-time nominees, all of whom last played in the 2021 season:

  • Jake Arrietta (P, Orioles/Cubs/Phillies/Padres)
  • Jay Bruce (OF/1B, Reds/Mets/Phillies/Mariners/Indians/Yankees)
  • Asdrubel Cabrera (IF, Indians/Mets/Nationals/Rays/Rangers/Diamondbacks/Phillies/Reds)
  • Starlin Castro (IF, Cubs/Marlins/Yankees/Nationals)
  • Wade Davis (P, Rays/Royals/Cubs/Rockies)
  • Brett Gardner (OF, Yankees)
  • Jon Lester (P, Red Sox/Cubs/A’s/Nationals/Cardinals)
  • Andrew Miller (P, Tigers/Marlins/Red Sox/Orioles/Yankees/Indians/Cardinals)
  • Buster Posey (C/1B, Giants)
  • Pablo Sandoval (3B/1B, Giants/Red Sox/Braves)
  • Ervin Santana (P, Angels/Royals/Braves/Twins/White Sox)
  • Kyle Seager (3B, Mariners)
  • Joakim Soria (P, Royals/Rangers/Tigers/Pirates/White Sox/Brewers/A’s/Diamondbacks/Blue Jays
  • Ryan Zimmerman (3B/1B, Nationals)

There are also 13 returning nominees; I list them with the percentage of the vote they got last year, and the number of years that they have been on the ballot (including this year):

  • Chase Utley, 2B, 59.1%, 4th
  • Andy Pettitte, P, 48.5%, 9th
  • Felix Hernandez, P, 46.1%, 3rd
  • Alex Rodriguez, SS/3B, 40.0%, 6th
  • Bobby Abreu, OF, 30.8%, 8th
  • Jimmy Rollins, SS, 25.4%, 6th
  • Cole Hamels, P, 23.8%, 2nd
  • Dustin Pedroia, 2B, 20.7%, 3rd
  • Mark Buehrle, P, 20.0%, 7th
  • Omar Vizquel, SS, 18.4%, 10th
  • David Wright, 3B, 14.8%, 4th
  • Francisco Rodriguez, P, 11.8%, 5th
  • Torii Hunter, OF, 8.7%, 7th

(Notes to follow in a subsequent post)

What a weak first-year ballot. Posey is the only one, I guess.

For the returners, I’d vote for Utley, Rollins, A-Rod, King Felix, and Pettite. I could maybe be talked into Hamels and Buehrle.

First approximation Posey and Utley. Maybe Pettitte, maybe Hernandez? Beyond that, not the strongest list we’ve had lately, but I’d have to look more closely at qualifications for others.

Thanks for posting.

My thoughts on the new guys. Posey and maybe Lester are the only ones I think have a shot.

Jake Arrieta: had a good three-year stretch for the Cubs, including an awesome 2015, when he won the Cy Young, and a World Series ring in '16. That stretch was in the middle of an otherwise-unremarkable 12-year career: outside of those three seasons, his career bWAR was 3.8. Nope.

Jay Bruce: two Silver Sluggers, three All-Star Games, .244 BA, .314 OBP, 19.7 career bWAR, only two seasons with a bWAR over 3. Nope.

Asdrubal Cabrera: one Silver Slugger, two All-Star Games, .266 BA, .329 OPB. Had a bit of pop (195 HRs), and a decent career, but with a career bWAR of 30.0, not Hall material. Nope.

Starlin Castro: four-time All-Star, mostly in the first half of his career with the Cubs. Good hitter (.280 career BA), rarely walked, 18.2 career bWAR. Nope.

Wade Davis: starter for five of the first six years of his career, then exclusively a reliever. Three-time All-Star. Led the league in saves in 2018. 3.94 ERA, 1.297 WHIP, 10.2 career bWAR. Nope.

Brett Gardner: one All-Star Game, one Silver Slugger; good speed and defense. 44.3 career bWAR. Good, but not nearly good enough.

Jon Lester: five All-Star Games, top-four in Cy Young voting three times, three World Series rings. He was clutch in the playoffs, and a clubhouse leader. 200 wins, 3.66 ERA, 1.278 WHIP, 43.4 bWAR. If voters consider his playoff performances and intangibles, maybe he has a shot.

Andrew Miller: two All-Star Games. A starter early in his career, but became a reliever (mostly a middle reliever). 4.03 ERA, 1.345 WHIP, 8.5 career bWAR. Nope.

Buster Posey:: Rookie of the Year, MVP winner, 5-time Silver Slugger, 1-time Gold Glove, a batting title, and three World Series rings. Retired at age 34, .302 career BA, .372 OBP, six straight seasons of 4+ bWAR, career bWAR of 45.0. Should make it in, but probably not on the first ballot, unless voters take into account the weak class this year.

Pablo Sandoval: 2 All-Star Games, three World Series, and a World Series MVP award. Was only a full-time player for the first half of his career. .278 career BA, .330 OBP, .433 SLG, 19.0 career bWAR. Nope.

Ervin Santana: 2 All-Star Games, got Cy Young votes in those same two seasons. Consistently in the starting rotation, but other than a couple of good seasons, not a great pitcher: 4.68 ERA, 1.332 WHIP, 27.1 bWAR. Nope.

Joakim Soria: 2 All-Star Games; got Cy Young and MVP votes in 2010. Purely a reliever, and often a closer. 3.11 career ERA, 1.132 career WHIP, 18.6 career bWAR. Good reliever, but the bar for relievers for the Hall is very high. Nope.

Ryan Zimmerman: 2 All-Star Games, 2 Silver Sluggers, one Gold Glove, one World Series ring. Was the face of the Nats during their early years in Washington. Very good early in his career, but injuries took their toll, and by his late 20s, he wasn’t the same player. .277 BA, .341 OBP, 284 HRs, 40.1 career bWAR. Not good enough for long enough.

Of the returning guys:

  • Utley and Felix very likely have a shot: their vote percentages have gone up considerably each year. Maybe this year, maybe in another year or two, for both.
  • Pettitte made a big jump in votes last year, but he’s still a long way away from 75%, and only has two more bites at the apple.
  • ARod’s vote totals are going up a tiny bit every year, but unless there is a major reassessment of him, and the steroids era in general, I don’t see him getting in.
  • Hamels and Pedroia might see their vote totals increase enough over their eligibility to eventually get in.

Everyone seems to think Buster Posey is a slam dunk, and if that’s the case, Thurman Munson should be enshrined as well.