[QUOTE=Marienee]
The other thing that troubles me is the mother’s use of the word intersex, which suggests to me that the, um, evidence presented by the child’s genitalia is not as conclusive as it might be.
[/QUOTE]
Some transsexuals are starting to identify as intersexed on the basis (supported by the studies cited above) that they have inconsistent anatomy, and thus a birth defect. This is not just a matter of nomenclature; if we are successful in gaining the label of “intersex” then the surgical reassignment procedures become “surgery to remedy a birth defect”, which not only makes the procedures “medically necessary” (rather than the current status of “elective surgery”) but may actually qualify us for special legal status which would further increase access to care.
Of course, there are many elements in society who oppose this happening, the biggest being the sexual conservatives and fiscal conservatives (who have a lot of overlap), and the radical feminists (who have very little overlap with the preceding). However, the double right-left whammy presented by that strange alliance does pose a serious problem. And then you have all penis-god worshippers who cringe at the idea of someone who wants to have her penis slit in half, eviscerated, and turned inside out, and the “think of the children” NIMBY whiners who are fine with there being transsexuals around as long as they stay on Jerry Springer and out of the local schools.
This debate is far more about politics than it is about science.