A little let down with cooking in our oven-style air fryer -- are we using it correctly?

Right off the bat: What we have is an Instant Vortex Pro 10-quart. It’s like a “mini-oven” that sits on the counter. It is not a ‘basket with a handle’ type air fryer, which seems to be what comes to mind first, second, and third for most people when discussing air fryers.

OK. The food we cook in this air fryer is tasty, and gets done quickly. It preheats fast enough. We don’t have a problem with this air fryer’s mechanical function, per se.

The issue is this: We can’t get this 10-quart air fryer to cook more food at one time than a regular ol’ 5-quart basket air fryer.

More precisely: One of the advantages that I thought an air fryer had over, say, a toaster oven or a microwave is that – I thought – every cubic centimeter of air space inside the air fryer would cook food the same way thanks to the circulation of hot air. That is, we didn’t expect it to matter where, exactly, inside the air fryer the food was placed. It was expected that the cooking was ‘omni-directional’ and that the food would all come out the same regardless of placement.

In reality, where the food is placed in the air fryer matters a great deal. Want to cook some chicken fingers? Place a layer of fingers on a grated tray and place on the halfway-up ridges. Turn halfway through (also didn’t think air fryer food needed turning if a grated tray was used - whoops).

Want to cook twice as many chicken fingers? Two trays at a time? Sure, the two trays fit easily using the topmost ridges and the bottom ridges. Plenty of room in the 10-quart air fryer. But wait! The fingers in the topmost tray are burned while the ones below it are virtually uncooked. Didn’t think that was supposed to happen in an air fryer, but now we know.

The upshot is that we’re now always cooking everything one tray at a time, which makes the 10-quart air fryer have the same effective capacity as a much smaller basket air fryer. We’re not cooking for one or two. We’re regularly cooking for four or five – and that was the whole idea behind getting the bigger air fryer. I’m flummoxed that two trays placed at different levels in an air fryer would cook that differently. Again, I thought an air fryer’s air circulation avoided that uneven-cooking issue altogether. But no.

So. Given a larger-than-usual air fryer, how can we cook larger meals quicker than we can on a stovetop (our gas oven is out of order and will be for the foreseeable future)? Can we get past the one-tray-at-a-time limitation? What have we been doing wrong?

You haven’t been doing anything wrong. The basic problem is that the air fryer, regardless of size, has a heat source coming from one direction. A fan blows that hot air so that it circulates around, but the majority of the heat transfer will still take place from one side.

Yeah, we have the same one. If you’re doing it wrong, then so are we.

Still like it well enough though.

If you are actually trying to ‘air fry’ something like french fries, the rotating basket works pretty well.

One thing that is good about it versus a basket-type is that you can put 9" (I think) and 8" (for sure) baking pans in it. Digging cookies and biscuits out of the bottom of a basket seems to be a bit of a pain (though plenty of people do it).

Really, if there’s a way to do two-trays-at-a-time cooking in the air fryer without having to switch the trays around every few minutes … that would be fantastic.

Yeah, I’ve never tried the rotisserie basket yet. Might need to take the plunge there.

I wonder of frozen items would work in the basket, as well? Or fresh-breaded items like chicken fingers/nuggets?

Should work well. stuff does get knocked around though, so hand-breaded things might get the breading knocked off.

One time we roasted a small rotisserie raw chicken using not the basket, but the little skewer thing that gets rotated by the same mechanism. (My wife made me perform the violence of skewering the chicken.) Turned out amazing though! I need to remember to do it again.

Secrets the air fryer makers don’t want you to know

I tried that, the chicken was great, but the mess from chicken grease was incredible.

French fries are helped by spritzing them with a little oil. They are entirely edible, but not up to deep fried. In my view, a compromise for cholesterol.