A Poll for The Walking Dead fans (fans only, please)

Walking Dead fans, I need to pick your braaaiiiiins :smiley:

I tried to watch the pilot, but got so bored I bailed half-way through. Since then I’ve been surprised by the amount of love poured on the show. I’ve been burned by that before (rewatching Lost and Firefly after hearing aclaim didn’t make me like them better) but I thought I’d poll fans before giving up on it entirely.
The basic question I have is this: how did you think the pilot compared to the rest of the first season episodes?
You’ll note that this poll is only asking for fan imput, and I ask that you only vote if you enjoyed the show. However, if you didn’t like it, you’re more than welcome to complain about what you didn’t like in the thread too.

I thought the pilot was awesome, and it sets the tone for the rest of the season. If you didn’t like it then chances are you probably won’t really be blown away by the rest of the series either.

The pilot was incredibly dull… but I expected that, most pilots aren’t the best episodes. So I stuck with it for 3 or 4 more episodes.

I gave up. It just didn’t do it for me. I was so looking forward to the series too…

The pilot started slow, in order to establish the mythos of the walking deadiverse, the show gets much better and more gripping as it goes along, the zombie attack on the camp was a nice unexpected twist, and needed to shake the survivors out of their complacency

I thought the pilot was ok, and then it just went downhill after that. Yeah, if you didn’t like the pilot I wouldn’t waste your time on the rest of the show.

The pilot episode wasn’t my favourite, but it wasn’t my least favourite either. I didn’t watch the pilot episode first, however, so my view might be a bit skewed.

I hate zombie flicks, so I was expecting to not like this. But I was pleasantly surprised, and I thought the pilot was quite good. Overall, I thought the series actually got a little better as time went on. I’m looking forward to the next season.

I love the comic, so I was really looking forward to the show. I enjoyed it, but I kept getting distracted by the fact that the plot follows the books less and less closely each episode. By the end of the season, it was almost entirely different, and I was able to stop picking it apart and just appreciated it for itself.

So, I found the pilot the least interesting (although still enjoyable), but that was because it was most like the books, and I knew what would happen. Otherwise, I think the quality was pretty even. Maybe try one more episode, but if it doesn’t grab you, it’s probably fair to assume it won’t ever.

Loved the show, didn’t read the comics until after seeing the show, liked the show better, bought the show on Bluray and watched it again.

If you didn’t like the pilot, it’s probably not the show for you. I thought and voted for “as interesting blah blah (loved from start)” but on other boards I come across lots of people who loved the pilot then thought it went downhill. It would be strange if you didn’t like the pilot for you to like the rest (not impossible, but improbable)

Ah. I’ve been reading Carrie Ryan’s YA zombie novels (I’ve read “The Forest of Hands and Teeth” and “The Dead-Tossed Waves” so far) and that made me wonder if I should give The Walking Dead another shot…

I am a wholly-uncritical zombie lover (not that way, you pervs), so my answer will throw off your results. I am perfectly aware of the plot holes, the contrivances, the galaxy-sized amount of suspension of disbelief required.

And I do not care.

That having been said, there were a couple of issues I had. First, it did seem to heavily rely on stereotypes - the noble father/husband, the uneducated and woman-hated/beating redneck, the racist drug addict gun-toting redneck and his slightly less menacing younger brother, the Hispanic “gang leader” with the heart of gold and his slightly befuddled abuela…the characters were not, shall we say, finely drawn.

But in a world (cue Movie Trailer Guy voice) where zombies can exist, I can overlook a LOT.

I received a compilation of the graphic novels for Christmas, and am finding them slow going, simply because I don’t read graphic novels at all, so I’m reading it like a book and just reading the words, which is annoying me that there are, like, four words on every page. I guess I need to learn how to read graphic novels.

I watched the whole first season, and I voted for the pilot being more interesting than most of the episodes.

IMO:

TWD started pretty strong with the pilot. It sagged a lot in the middle episodes. Near the end, it started picking up again.

It’s not a perfect show. I’m cautiously optimistic about season two. Near the middle of season one I was about ready to give up on it, but it did get better. Someone more in the know can speak more about this, but was it a case of different directors for different episodes?

I would offer as the obvious contrast “The Killing”, which started really strong and went downhill, steadily, every episode. I started loving it, but by the end I hated that show so much for how lazy, sloppy and dishonest it was. I nearly broke my remote in two after seeing the season one finale. I’m still disgusted that it was renewed while “Rubicon” was cancelled.

what gamehat sed: pilot good, show sagged in middle, last couple of eps outstanding. yes, they do need to improve characterization,and yes i hated the way the killing fell apart. very disappointing.

I didn’t vote because I liked the pilot of The Walking Dead, but eventually grew to dislike the show pretty intensely. The characters are so cartoonish that I just stopped caring and started cheering for the zombies.

I voted pilot a bit better than the rest. That’s roughly speaking. The exit from the hospital was really memorable and well done.

I agree it would be nice to see more complicated characters. If they could manage someone who was likable despite having flaws, that would be refreshing.

I also hope the writers depart from the comic a lot more (judging by what I’ve read about the direction the graphic novels go in), and realize that you can have drama, danger, and even pathos, without unrelenting hopelessness. I don’t mind dark - I kind of wish Battlestar Galactica had ended with them finding the burnt-out remnants of Earth, for instance. But TWD got so wrist-slittingly bitter at the end of the season it was off-putting.

Yeah, I love the comic, but you should definitely not read it. It can pretty much be summed up as “unrelenting hopelessness”. The hopelessness does in fact relent now and then, but when it’s inevitably snatched away again, it’s that much worse.

I really enjoyed the first series, think that the pilot was as good as the rest.

What worries me is that in the future when the writers start getting stale we get a glorified soap, with much of the time being taken up with tensions, or sexual attraction between the characters.

If I wanted this I’d tune into Eastenders every night.

What I want is the cold chill of fear and uncertainty running down my spine, hope raised, hope dashed down, sudden surprises and unexpected plot twists, or characters that you KNOW are integral to the programme suddenly dying.

If I were in a world that was suffering a zombie apocalyse I doubt very much if people would pepretuate petty feuds with fellow survivors, my experience of people in life or death situations is that those things that would rile them in normal life become petty and irrelevant in the situation confronting them.

Even quite bitter enemies do more then just help each other out.

So I find it unrealistic when the central characters are squabbling with each other over trivialities when faced with a good chance of a horrible death in the near future.

Also I hope that the writers show the people having a good appreciation of the danger that surrounds them and not having them wander off alone “to think about things”, or have a bath or what ever, and to post some bloody SENTRIES !

As to when a character does something stupid or careless, as in leaving a door ajar or suchlike, apart from finding it slightly unbelievable in such a situation (Continuous fear over a prolonged time tends to make the even the biggest idiot self diciplined where staying alive is concerned),

I lose all sympathy for them and consider it their own fault if they get zombied.

Because I no longer care about what happens to them this seriously lessens the tension for me, and this in turn reduces my enjoyment of the programme.

Can’t wait to see the new series.

A friend of mine just send me the link to the trailer for Season 2. Thought I’d bump this thread in case anyone’s interested.

My GOD, I cannot wait.

Okay…unless I get dragged over someone’s house to watch it, I don’t think I’ll be giving the show another chance. Not with less than 13% of people thinking it improves after the pilot.

Thanks for the help, everyone :slight_smile: