A) Putting caramel topping on chocolate chip mint ice cream.
OR
B) Eating cereal and milk (specifically Frosted Mini-Wheats) with a fork.
Choice A is infinitely weirder.
I think A is odd, and perhaps unwise, but B is more inexplicable.
B is weirder. Caramel topping is acceptable on any kind of ice cream. Eating cereal with a fork defeats the purpose of including all that delicious, calcium-rich milk.
Why the hell would you put milk on perfectly good cereal?
What’s odd with either?
A… that’s nasty.
B doesn’t matter because you can drink the milk directly from the bowl.
Option B seems very odd to be while option A seems like a good time to me .
Exactly.
A man(?) after my own heart! 
I vote B. Not because it’s very weird, but because A sounds delicious.
B has a certain amount of peculiar wastefulness (especially seeing as how most Frosted Mini-Wheats I have handled break apart fairly easily) that makes it far odder than A.
Another vote for B…
A sounds wonderful. So I’ll go with B by default.
B is rather odd. I don’t see anything wrong at all with A.
A isn’t at all weird, maybe not everyone’s cup of tea but it’s not like you’re using shoe polish or ketchup here, you’re putting ice cream topping on, gasp, ice cream.
B is weird.
B is definitely weirder.
B is weirder.
Caramel on anything is always acceptable.
Yo, B.
B. I’d have to taste A to see if it was weird. It sounds like it might taste odd, but then I said that about ketchup on scrambled eggs, and then I liked it when I tried it.
B just sounds . . . unstable. I can picture me dropping things down my front.