[QUOTE=BrainGlutton (underline mine)]
OTOH, I don’t read it as the minister claiming “Hezbollah is one of [Lebanon’s] tools against Israel.”
[/quote]
I don’t think your gloss is fair.
[QUOTE=BrainGlutton]
The Lebanese government (except for its Hezbollah element) has absolutely no interest in making war on Israel and no reason to feel hostile to Israel.
[/quote]
How would you describe President Lahoud? I’m asking honestly, do you describe him as part of the Hezbollah element?
[
](BBC NEWS | Middle East | Hezbollah urged to hand over arms)
[QUOTE=BrainGlutton]
Their problem is, they had to comply with this UN resolution to disband all the religious-partisan militias, and WRT to the military arm of Hezbollah they couldn’t – it’s too strong, and too popular, and they can’t even rely on their own army to follow orders to disband it.
[/quote]
To a degree, true. But, as well, various politicians and members have publically stated that Hezbollah is not a militia, and is a valid ‘resistance organization’. Now, I see no reason to assume that they were anything less than serious, as not only did they act on this rhetoric, but there are those in Lebanon who have opposed Hezbollah. Pr’aps this boils down to interpretation, but I find it hard to believe that this is ‘just’ rhetoric.
[QUOTE=BrainGlutton]
They might find themselves between a rock and a hard place if they even tried to stop the arms shipments (though this new war may well change that particular political circumstance).
[/quote]
Perhaps… but the international community was firmly against Syrian meddling. Couldn’t the Lebanse governemnt, instead of sending those weapons to Hezbollah, give them to their own soldiers instead after confiscating them? Or destroy them? Or bring it to the UN’s attention?
[QUOTE=BrainGlutton]
So all they can do is fall back on weasel-words. “It’s not a militia, its a . . . erm . . . it’s a resistance group! Nothing to see here, no sir!” [tugs collar]
[/quote]
I think we disagree on the interpretation. The way I see it, Hezbollah’s function of threatening Israel factored into the Lebanese calculus of statecraft.
[QUOTE=BrainGlutton]
If you have to have any particular feeling towards the Lebanese government right now, it should be pity, not anger.
[/QUOTE]
Depends on which part of the Lebanese government we’re talking about. Sovereign nations are responsible for their actions. Even thoug, for instance, the war in Iraq is largely in the hands of Bush and a Republican dominated Congress, that doesn’t mean we can say that America isn’t occupying Iraq, the Republicans are.
So I guess my answer would be something like ‘yes, and no’. The Christian, Druze, and moderate members of the government certainly got the short end of the stick. But at the same time, a nation is responsible for the choices its government makes. And if it can’t be, then it’s essentially a rogue state, and needs to be cracked down on, hard.
Perhaps the UN should’ve been more proactive. Perhaps instead of sipping tea with Hezbollah, they should’ve been trying to disarm them. There are many possibilities involved, and at the end of the day it sucks to be a non-supporter of Hezbollah if you’re Lebanese, or part of the Lebanese government…
But if Bush, backed up by Congress, authorized an invasion of Canada tomorrow, it would fall at the feet of all America. The only other option, as I see it, is to forcibly dismantle the parts of a sovereign government that you don’t like. I’m not sure that can even be accmoplished when dealing with sovereign states.