Abdul El-Sayed vs Haley Stevens - Progressives vs Centrists, gloves-off discussion

My guess are issues referred to in this article:

I see that @Spice_Weasel is typing so I’ll let her answer your question because she has done so very well in the past; but I just wanted to drop her a quick note thanking her for her prior posts on this issue. A few months ago I started seeing a therapist and some of her posts helped come up with tactics in seeking out a therapist that helped assuage some concerns I had about this issue, especially before her information and further reading she prompted me to do helped me get some context.

Thanks; your posts about an area you are clearly very knowledgeable about had a real impact in the real world.

I’m referring to an emerging trend among progressive mental health professionals of shoving their values onto their clients, and particularly their anti-Zionist views, to the great detriment of their Jewish clients.

I hear the scuttlebutt because my husband is a clinical psychologist tied into the Jewish community (he’s not Jewish, but he got his start as a psychologist in that community.) One of the earlier incidents occurred when an APA sponsored DEI event listed, among given examples like racism and misogyny, “Zionism” as an example of bigotry.

But the real issue is decolonization therapy, a political orientation used in therapy that seeks to cast clients in the role of oppressed or oppressor. Such that even Jews who directly experienced and survived the October 7 attacks are forced, in therapy, to acknowledge their supposed role in their own victimization.

From an article (can’t vouch for the source, but it explains the issue, and when my Second Brain gets home I can get you better stuff.)

However, groups such as the Brandeis Center and Physicians Against Antisemitism highlight the fact that Decolonizing Therapy identifies Zionism as a root cause of mental illness.

Tens of posts on Decolonizing Therapy’s social media uphold this idea. One post reads “mental health liberation is Palestinian liberation,” another says “your mental health is directly impacted by the genocide in Palestine.”

I am beyond incensed. Beyond. First of all, I think it’s wildly irresponsible to make a therapy client aware of your political leanings because of the (ironically) inherent power imbalance, it’s much worse to try to influence a client with your own ideology. That this is being done to people in vulnerable situations, including people with diagnosed severe mental health disorders such as Borderline Personality Disorder and PTSD makes me want to start flipping tables.

One thing I’ve learned over the years is the amazing level of bullshit present in many therapeutic orientations. It’s typical for many therapists to use untested, pseudoscience bullshit in a therapeutic setting. Even my very good CBT therapist can’t help but use bullshit like tapping and polyvagal theory. This stuff comes up a lot in trauma interventions.

But when therapy is actively harmful, it’s on another level. Jews are currently bearing the brunt of it, but if you have any oppressive identity markers you are at risk. One white patient, when seeking treatment for her sexual assault, was required to go through a lengthy process acknowledging that as a white person she possessed privilege and greater financial resources and should really just be grateful she was getting any therapy at all.

I want all these people to lose their licenses.

I’m unimpressed. This looks like another case of the Right promoting illiberal ideas in the name of “fighting antisemitism”. This author doesn’t make this case, but some people are claiming that the entire mental health field is anti-semitic and needs to be destroyed. They don’t actually care about anti-semitism, they just know that mentally healthy people are difficult to recruit into their cult. (I am certainly not claiming that the leader of the Brandeis Institute is not sincerely concerned about antisemitism, but that concern is leading him to lie down with dogs, and he’s likely to wake up with fleas).

Someone wrote a book called “Decolonizing Therapy” which was offensive to Zionists, and now this guy calls on the government to stop funding to agencies practicing Decolonizing Therapy. Which might sound OK until you stop and think that he’s basically proposing to let the Trump Administration define what therapists can and can’t say. It’s just like “Critical Race Theory”, an obscure academic concept which can easily be redefined as “anything the right wing doesn’t like”.

This is a real thing real Jews are experiencing.

There are also many examples of Jewish patients experiencing antisemitism from therapists. Shortly after the Hamas massacre, one social media user posted that a therapist that they had been seeing for many years “denied the massacre” to their face, despite knowing that the patient had friends who were killed.

“I ended up having to shut off the Zoom call early and literally went sobbing to my sister,” the poster added.

I don’t know why it’s hard to believe that harmful progressive bullshit is a thing. I have a master’s degree in macro social work (where I had at least some coursework on actual critical race theory, by the way) and an undergraduate degree from a very liberal university (and I belonged to the far left-wing community of that university.) I identified almost overwhelmingly as a progressive until at least 2011, after which I witnessed a radical shift not in beliefs per se but messaging and tactics that I cannot condone. I still consider myself progressive but I try to distance myself from certain mindsets associated with the left.

I’ve also had I cannot tell you how many therapists over the last twenty years and I have investigated the scientific basis behind the practices of every single one. I’m something of an evidence-based clinical psychology enthusiast. I know this field and I know progressives and I know the utter mayhem that happens when mental health and progressive ideology collide. This is not hard to believe at all.

It’s a lot of cribbing from my husband, who sends me stuff his colleagues write. By the way I started Righteous Victims by the author you recommended. Going in completely blind, I intend to read as many perspectives as possible on this subject. But it’s interesting.

I’m not denying harmful progressive bullshit is a thing. All the anecdotes listed in that article are infuriating and should cost people their jobs. But I’m noting that this push is coming at a time when many people want to discredit the entire mental health care field. The author is arguing that not censoring anti-Zionist speech is bad specifically because it conflicts with the broader goal of eliminating “DEI”. That is setting off a whole May Day parade of red flags to me.

Sorry, I think we were referring to two different articles.

I just read the first linked article and yes, as someone who has had to deal with Trump’s bullshit executive orders re: DEI in my job, I agree that author seems mad for the wrong reason (or at least biased.)

It reminds me of a book I read that debunked the wildly popular book about trauma, The Body Keeps the Score. It is called, fittingly, The Body Does Not Keep the Score. It’s the first source I ever read that dismantles Van der Kolk’s outdated, unsupported ideas about PTSD and trauma, and it was written by a very knowledgeable man. But the book also featured inexplicable political rants (in which he called liberalism a “moral aberration”) and by the end you realize that even though he’s bringing the facts, he’s not motivated by a desire to help his clients, he’s motivated by some twisted ideology. So sometimes it works the other way, too.

It’s definitely Benny Morris’s most comprehensive work on the topic and probably a good place to start. I’m glad you found my recommendation helpful!

Well, thank you a ton for passing it on.

I’ve been keeping to my self discipline of not continuing to engage in back and forth that will just get frustrating and accomplishes nothing but having lurked in the thread off and on I also want to thank @Spice_Weasel for her contributions.

I know what my conclusion about El-Sayed is and I hope I can come back in a couple of years to acknowledge how wrong I am.

I appreciate your kind words, and also your support over the years. I don’t always know what I’m doing, but I promise my heart’s in the right place.

Interesting and not surprising.

I was very young at the time and recall my parents taking about it, and by the time I got old enough to understand the demographic had shifted.

I’m all for Shawarma law. And a good falafel.

Okay, I got links for the mental health stuff.

First is the full PDF of the Committee on Education and Workforce Staff Report entitled “Anti-Semitism at the American Psychological Association.”

In December 2025, under Chairman Tim Walberg’s (R-MI) leadership, the Education and Workforce Committee (the Committee) opened an investigation into antisemitism at the APA.[1]

The Committee found that over several years, radical activist-academics have successfully co-opted the APA to politicize the association and promote ideology that demonizes Israel, minimizes Hamas terrorism, and portrays Jews as white oppressors. Meanwhile, APA leaders have repeatedly failed to confront antisemitism within their own organization, alienating Jewish members and undermining confidence in an institution entrusted with setting professional standards.

APA leaders have inflamed antisemitism at the association by endorsing and promoting
decolonial psychology. Decolonial academic frameworks view Israel as a settler colonial—and therefore illegitimate—state against which violent resistance in the name of decolonization is justified.[33] The same frameworks view Jews as white and therefore part of the oppressor
class.[34] In the psychology space, decolonizing therapy links mental wellness with Palestinian “liberation” achieved through resistance and mental illness with Zionism.[35] This form of therapy has been described as one that pathologizes aspects of Jewish identity, “demand[s] activism as part of treatment,” and is “explicitly political.”[36]

After October 7th, antizionist and non-Jewish members led the charge to pass a new resolution that greenlights antisemitism.[44] The now-passed resolution contains a freestanding clause about the “weaponization of antisemitism” and cites the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism, which was created to whitewash contemporary antisemitism.[45] The APA’s Council of Representatives approved this new resolution in February
2026 by a 127–37 vote.[46]

I have not yet read the whole thing, but it’s important to understand this is happening at the American Psychological Association, and is not some fringe therapy movement. And that the APA’s response to the report was tepid at best.

Similarly, a representative for the Society of Indian Psychologists—one of the APA’s ethnic minority associations—stated that the society does not view Jews as being an “underrepresented marginalized and disadvantaged ethnic minorit[y][.]”[55] She added that if the resolution to recognize the Jewish association were to move forward on the basis of “religious persecution,” then “it would open other predominately White privileged religious groups” to also seek ethnic minority status.[56]

Meanwhile, BAPPI reported that “[t]he feedback from several groups is that many Jewish individuals (the majority of whom are white) do not face the same anti-Blackness, racism, white supremacy, coloniality, systemic or structural oppression as People of Color.”[

More soon.

That’s a bit of a simplification. The West Bloomfield shooter had relatives who died in Gaza. His pain wasn’t merely abstract. None of which, of course, excuses his actions but it makes it make more explainable. Yes, Abdul could have been more adroit in how he handled it but his sentiment isn’t without validity.

Um.

Are we sure we trust Tim Walberg’s leadership to generate scrupulously honest reporting on this (or any) issue?

Walberg is a hardline conservative (anti-abortion rights, anti-ACA, anti-marriage equality, has supported Uganda’s policies of judicial persecution including death penalty for homosexual acts, etc. etc.). Most relevantly, he is closely affiliated with the right-wing group Christians United for Israel, whose ultimate goal is to bring about the heralded “End Times” (and, according to their beliefs, the eventual damnation of most Jews for refusal to become Christians) by assiduously promoting hardline expansionist and “dominionist” (so to speak) Israeli extreme-right policies.

Mind you, I’m not saying I disbelieve any of the individual anecdotes you’ve mentioned about Jewish patients being shamed for Israeli settler-colonialism history and policies. Antisemitism is definitely a real thing, and the boundaries between it and intemperate critiques of Zionism are very far from firm.

But speaking as a Jew, I have a very hard time regarding Tim Walberg or any committee reports produced under his guidance as reliable and rational critics of antisemitism. I wouldn’t be confident about that ratfucker’s pronouncements if he were saying that the sky is blue.

After the October 7th attacks, APA members turned the association’s division listservs into hostile, political, and deeply antizionist forums.[62] Members of various divisions, which represent various psychological disciplines, described claims that Hamas is seeking to “‘exterminate’ the Jewish people” as “clearly … not based on facts” and “quite hilarious”;[63] stated that “Hamas is very far from perfect on lots of levels” but that Hamas terrorism on October 7th was and is “the only signs of life and resistance” for Palestinians;[64] defended the “humanity” of “Hamas fighters” and argued against rendering them as “one-dimensional”;[65] argued that Hamas is “protecting civilians” and therefore deserves “kudos”;[66] described Israel as a “terrorist” state;[67]urged their colleagues to donate to an antizionist Member of Congress;[68] questioned whether expressing solidarity with Israel constitutes “violating listserv etiquette because of how it affects peoples’ sense of safety”;[69] and more.[70]

I turn now to Dr. Dean McKay, an OCD researcher and clinical psychologist of some renown, who had to start a Substack about all this shit, and apparently now researches Anti-Semitism instead of OCD.

The thing I will tell you about trying to read this Substack is that he doesn’t give a lot of context and it may be difficult to follow if you’re not a clinical psychologist closely involved with the APA. I’m not and I find it difficult to follow. But he offers a ton of links so it’s a rabbit hole you can go down if you want to.

So it’s hard to quote just one thing because it might not make sense. But I’ll try.

This brings us back to the DBT community, which, in its zeal to insert political processes into treatment, has created a schism between the approach’s science and its everyday practice. In controlled trials that exclude any politicized aspects of treatment, the approach is highly efficacious. However, we cannot say this about everyday practice that incorporates political processes. Indeed, the inclusion of politics in treatment should be vigorously questioned, given that psychology has virtually no research on how to incorporate political processes into therapeutic approaches. This divide was evident to many Jewish members in the DBT specialty area, but it burst into public view when the annual conference for the organization of that specialty, the International Society for the Improvement of the Teaching of DBT (ISITDBT), had a speaker deliver a floridly antisemitic workshop in 2024. Since that workshop, there have been calls for reform that have largely gone nowhere.

DBT refers to Dialectical Behavioral Therapy, an evidence based treatment for Borderline Personality Disorder. The article takes issue, rightly so, with the insertion of political ideology into DBT therapeutic practices, particularly with Jewish clients, in a way that may essentially break the efficacy of DBT, or cause active harm. We don’t actually know because nobody has researched Decolonization therapy and DBT integration. Because therapists don’t give a shit about research. (Most don’t. I’m feeling feisty.)

In truth, I had the same thought because I don’t trust Republicans either, but I guess I assume the quoted parts of the document are accurate, but if you take McKay and his other Jewish colleagues at their word, there’s a lot of truth in there.

He responds directly to the report here.

Back in February 2025, a petition was circulated highlighting many of the problems in the organization documented in the special report. What that petition lacked was the internal emails, but there was enough public-facing evidence that one would expect would give leaders pause. The petition gathered over 3500 signatures and included many leading experts and well-known members of the profession. To this date, there has been no response from the APA to that petition.

Well, that basically says it all.

And sticking it to hypothetical white people who might ask for different treatment in the future, although they haven’t yet, is more important to her than providing proper care to Jewish patients now?

  1. No, he did not
  2. What do his dead relatives in Lebanon have to do with the Jews he tried to murder in a synagogue in Michigan?
  3. Omar Mateen’s motivation was nearly identical. The US had killed people he was deeply devoted to and has sworn his life to. Some of his surviving victims said they heard him ranting about how he wanted the US to “stop bombing his country” during the shooting.
  4. Again, what the FUCK do his dead relatives in Lebanon have to do with the congregation in Michigan he decided to murder?

I just don’t understand how anyone would come to that conclusion. But it’s not the first I’ve heard of that attitude.

Literally all this “reply” does is link to the MAGA report, takes everything it says at face value, and talks about how awful it all is. GIGO.

It’s basically this level of analysis.