I’m referring to an emerging trend among progressive mental health professionals of shoving their values onto their clients, and particularly their anti-Zionist views, to the great detriment of their Jewish clients.
I hear the scuttlebutt because my husband is a clinical psychologist tied into the Jewish community (he’s not Jewish, but he got his start as a psychologist in that community.) One of the earlier incidents occurred when an APA sponsored DEI event listed, among given examples like racism and misogyny, “Zionism” as an example of bigotry.
But the real issue is decolonization therapy, a political orientation used in therapy that seeks to cast clients in the role of oppressed or oppressor. Such that even Jews who directly experienced and survived the October 7 attacks are forced, in therapy, to acknowledge their supposed role in their own victimization.
From an article (can’t vouch for the source, but it explains the issue, and when my Second Brain gets home I can get you better stuff.)
However, groups such as the Brandeis Center and Physicians Against Antisemitism highlight the fact that Decolonizing Therapy identifies Zionism as a root cause of mental illness.
Tens of posts on Decolonizing Therapy’s social media uphold this idea. One post reads “mental health liberation is Palestinian liberation,” another says “your mental health is directly impacted by the genocide in Palestine.”
I am beyond incensed. Beyond. First of all, I think it’s wildly irresponsible to make a therapy client aware of your political leanings because of the (ironically) inherent power imbalance, it’s much worse to try to influence a client with your own ideology. That this is being done to people in vulnerable situations, including people with diagnosed severe mental health disorders such as Borderline Personality Disorder and PTSD makes me want to start flipping tables.
One thing I’ve learned over the years is the amazing level of bullshit present in many therapeutic orientations. It’s typical for many therapists to use untested, pseudoscience bullshit in a therapeutic setting. Even my very good CBT therapist can’t help but use bullshit like tapping and polyvagal theory. This stuff comes up a lot in trauma interventions.
But when therapy is actively harmful, it’s on another level. Jews are currently bearing the brunt of it, but if you have any oppressive identity markers you are at risk. One white patient, when seeking treatment for her sexual assault, was required to go through a lengthy process acknowledging that as a white person she possessed privilege and greater financial resources and should really just be grateful she was getting any therapy at all.
I want all these people to lose their licenses.