That’s not true at all. He says prior to the report being published a group of professionals 3,500 strong raised the same concerns. If you look at his other articles he details what he experienced.
The article is about the report validating already existing concerns within the organization.
I should add, the APA sucks and has always sucked. It wouldn’t even say torturing suspected terrorists was wrong until well after that ship had sailed, and was one of the last organizations to acknowledge being gay is not a mental illness. This sort of cluelessness is on brand for them.
So from that we know that…there are 3500 MAGAts in the APA?
What I can personally testify to is that my very Jewish wife is a long-time APA member, has never experienced any antisemitism within the organization, and thinks this is all a crock of bullshit.
I appreciate it. My lived experience is that this is not a thing, any more than other things MAGAts whine about are a thing. Perhaps I am wrong, but I do not have the energy to dive down the rabbit hole and form a truly informed opinion. So I have no belief, but I will assume what I want to assume.
If these folks can persuade the next Congress to have hearings on this issue, I will take that committee’s report seriously.
It seems that what McKay is primarily opposed to here is “exclud[ing] anti-Zionism from the definition of antisemitism”. As I just noted, it is certainly true that anti-Zionism can very often be accompanied by antisemitism. But that doesn’t mean they’re the same thing or that antisemitism should be defined as automatically inherent in anti-Zionism.
Maybe I’m just too reflexively quick to mistrust allegations of entire professions or professional bodies being irresponsibly “captured” by “misguided” “ideologies”. I have read sooooo many hand-wringing denunciations of climate science being “in thrall” to “global leftism”, and academia as a whole “embracing” “dangerous woke ideology”, etc. etc. etc. Because, you know, these thousands of educated trained professionals have all just simultaneously lost their collective mind and renounced rational thinking and ethical principles on these issues. Happens all the time.
Eh. I’m not saying that professional organizations can never be wrong, or even significantly wrong, about something sometimes. But I really need to see what the organization is actually saying before I take the word of one of the hand-wringers that it’s “fallen prey” to “dangerous ideology”.
I had never heard of “decolonization therapy” before this, and I notice none of these articles make any claim about how many therapists are actually doing that in the real world.
I didn’t read enough to come to a firm conclusion, but there definitely seemed to be a strong “antizionism is antisemitism and if you don’t agree you’re an antisemite” vibe there.
It does seem that you didn’t quite follow it, because while the removal of anti-Zionism from the list of forms of anti-semitism was one of his complaints, there were a number of others that you seem to have missed, or otherwise failed to follow:
Also, with the caveat that we are talking specifically about American Jews, we are absolutely not underrepresented, marginalized or disadvantaged. We are living our best lives in the Land of Promise.
We are wealthier and better educated than the average American, and overrepresented in basically every well-paying profession. We* differ from regular white people only in that we have a small but nonzero risk of being targeted for bullying or violence by antisemites, which sucks but does not make our experience comparable to that of actual disadvantaged minority groups.
*Speaking of the Ashkenazi majority. Obviously there are a lot of Jews of color and intersectionality is real.
And Jews are certainly not underrepresented in most elite and high-status professions and socioeconomic groups in the US. [ETA: or what @Thing.Fish said.]
Does that mean that US Jews don’t face any prejudice, discrimination or bigotry? Of course not. But we’ve spent decades building a collective identity of not being “ethnic” and “marginal” and “disadvantaged”, because back in the day those were considered very suspect things to be.
Our grandparents worked their asses off, often very effectively, to blend in with the image of secure white middle class in America. And we (like Swedes and Italians and Irish) to a large extent succeeded in shaking off “disadvantaged marginalized group” status, mostly due to racial-phenotype similarities to the dominant group.
I think it’s still extremely debatable, to say the least, to consider Jews as definitively not a “marginalized and disadvantaged” minority. But I certainly wouldn’t call it incomprehensible.
Here’s a website describing it from the point of view of people doing it:
Pretty much I’ve found nothing critical about this from a web search. There are a lot of concerns here. 1. I think it’s extremely unethical to insert political views into a therapeutic framework, especially if they are untested. 2. The idea that traditional modes of evidence-based therapy can’t adapt to different cultures is a lie. There have been so many studies on diverse populations and aside from that, CBT therapists are not robots who implement one-size-fits all therapy without cultural context and individual consideration. They are fully capable of educating themselves and adapting therapy to fit individual needs. That they are incapable of doing this is a lie psychodynamic therapists have been peddling for years. 3. Where does this leave you if you are seeking therapy and you, according to your own therapist, belong to the so-called privileged oppressor class? Even if this is voluntary, I can see it causing harm, especially for people with PTSD. I gave some examples upthread of people who believe it did bring them harm. 4. These people are ready to throw out the whole existing model of mental illness. If they have a better idea than the DSM we can talk, but nebulous, untested, undefined concepts with no testing or even consistency of implementation? No.
As for the APA, I think the central point of debate is whether it’s acceptable to discriminate against Jews who identify as Zionist or supportive of Israel as long as you also accept anti-Zionist Jews. I don’t think so. I don’t think it’s as simple as a political difference or that it should be treated like other political differences.
When I worked in the continued care retirement facility, it was the wealthiest and most privileged place a person could spend their later years, from my point of view. But we also had a fair number of Holocaust survivors, so we had to cover our tattoos. A lot of them had dementia, and in what seems like the cruelest twist of old age, a lot of people go out terrified and disoriented, reliving the worst experiences of their past. And some of those people were reliving their experiences in the Holocaust. They thought their nurses were the gestapo.
I think that’s when I first really understood the concept of intersectionality.
I mean, if by “discrimination” you mean that they shouldn’t be able to get jobs or hold offices in the APA, no, they shouldn’t discriminate against Zionists. Zionists can be excellent and ethical therapists. But if not discriminating against them means “not pointing out that their political opinions are just obvious rationalizations for apartheid and ethnic cleansing”, they don’t have the right to demand that.
I think there’s a difference, though, between generally supporting the concept of Israel’s existence and actively supporting the actions of Netenyahu. Assuming what’s been said is true, these two things are being increasingly conflated by the left and those who don’t pass the purity test are treated badly. Including people just looking for therapy.
As a non-Jew, I want to be very careful about dismissing concerns about antisemitism. I don’t see it with AES, but I recognize that I might have a blind spot. It’s much the same as how I try not to dismiss concerns about misogyny: I’m not keyed into it in the same way that women tend to be.
That said, there’s also a temptation for folks to minimize foibles and prejudices in their own group. It seems self-evident to me that Jewish Americans won’t be immune from Islamophobia, and especially that Jewish Americans with strong ties to Israel might be susceptible to anti-Arab sentiment, for much the same reasons that Ukranians might be susceptible to anti-Russian sentiment.
There’s absolutely antisemitism among the left. I struggle with that with a young extended family member, who spends way too much time on leftist Tiktok and repeats, at triple-speed, talking points about Israeli opinion polls that sound real antisemitic. It’s not good at all. But what I hear from her, and from Piker, and from some others, is very different from what I hear from AES.
Yes, AES has ties to Piker. But guilt-by-association is a flimsy sort of guilt. I’m much more interested in what people actually say, and actually do, than who they hang out with.
Sure, if you sit at a table with ten Nazis, that’s eleven Nazis. But Nazis are a special case. it’s not true that if you sit at a table with ten leftists there’s eleven leftists, or 10 Christians=11 Christians, or 10 moderately antisemitic trolls=11 MATs. I’m not willing to condemn him for his rare bedfellows.
IMO if he’s antisemitic (I don’t think he is), he’s managed to absolutely bury it behind some incredible decency and insight (as well as top notch communications skills).
Sorry, wrong target zone. And, of course, the congregation in Michigan had nothing to do with that but people who are prepared to do what this guy tried to do aren’t known for rational thinking.
I’ve seen a lot of that. A whole bunch over my lifetime. It bugs me. Seems like there is a lot of antisemitism, too. Which quite bugs me as well.
But to the people who behave as if the slightest slight of Israel equals Naziism… Fuck off.
There seem to be a good number of those people on the SDMB. It’s oh so tiring.
ETA: Yes, I rang the bell… so salivate. (IOW, call me a dirty anti-semite. It’s instinctive, I know, so I can’t really get too cranky about anyone doing it. Again.)
I don’t think individual accusations of anti-Semitism are really going to win over hearts and minds in a discussion like this. I think we can talk about the issues without assuming bad faith. I can anyway. (Except that one guy advocating Israeli genocide in Great Debates recently. I’m assuming bad faith there.)
I’ve learned a lot from this thread, though.
I’d like to circle back to this. In your opinion, do you think American Jews (in any substantive amount) have gone out of their way try to appear like they aren’t a marginalized identity, or that many of them don’t believe they are? Is there a separate internal cultural conversation happening that is different than what’s expressed in front of a general audience? Is it a survivalist mentality or something else?
What you’re describing reminds me of how many East Asian American immigrants don’t want to be viewed as marginalized. But I’ve always wondered if they themselves believe that they are not marginalized. And maybe there’s some cognitive dissonance in there, because immigration is hard. In my opinion anyone who immigrates for any reason is automatically part of a vulnerable population, and I believed that long before the recent horror of ICE. But I could understand that it would be hard to admit that you were vulnerable, to yourself.