No argument there, but I don’t think that self-perception necessarily persists over multiple generations of native-born white people.
This is kind of a hot take so don’t attach too much importance to it, but I perceive the self-image of comfortably assimilated socioeconomically secure white American Jews as being somewhat akin to that of wealthy elite-class women: ”I think of myself as an acknowledged and respected person fully entitled to the status and influence I have in my society, except I get the occasional consciousness jolt reminding me that on some level I am always vulnerable and assumed to be fundamentally suspect in ways that [non-Jews/men] are not.”
Women and Jews always have an underlying internalized conviction that to some extent we still exist on sufferance, so it behooves us to keep a weather eye open. I think for very many people this is not a consciously articulated feeling, though.
As someone with a “Jewish” name, people think I’m Jewish. (and in some respects I am) I recall when my father was told he didn’t get an academic position at a big university because they had met their quota of Jews. This was in the late 1960s. I also know there is anti semitism in modern American society. Despite that, I don’t think American Jews are a “marginalized and disadvantaged” minority. A few bigots here and there don’t make us marginialized or disadvantaged. The disadvantages faced by other groups in the U.S. far exceed what American Jews are going through.
I’m getting a sense just from community events I’ve participated in professionally that a lot of young Jewish people are rather shocked because maybe this is the first time they’ve really worried about anti-Semitic violence against themselves. And to stretch your analogy further I was raised in the 80s and 90s by a mother with a degree in mechanical engineering, and I don’t recall a conscious perception of myself as oppressed per se. Like I always got some shit for being a smart woman who refused to hide it, but it was low level. It never occurred to me that my gender would ever stand in the way of my freedom. And then Trump happened, the end of Roe v. Wade, and we have elected officials who want to take the vote from women. So I find the shock that Jewish kids are feeling somewhat relatable. You just take it for granted that the battle was already won, someone else fought it and you’d benefit from that forever.
I can only speak for myself but no I see myself much much more as privileged than marginalized. And at the same time I see that position in this society as historically very fragile.
And I have personally been called a kike Jew boy back in college. Met a girl who was surprised I didn’t have horns. Really. My Dad went on sales leads pretending to be Italian. So I also appreciate the reality of Jew hate.
My privilege is at the pleasure of the majority culture. Some of whom really do believe many of the antisemitic tropes.
Indeed. Borrowed privilege, largely aided by not looking or sounding like “the other” to a casual observer, but as soon as someone decides to bother actually looking things up…
I believe you. When Campus Crusade for Christ invaded UCLA, in the early 70s, a friend of mine said one girl (from somewhere in the deep South) asked to see his horns when she found out he was Jewish. I was pretty shocked because it was STUPid. My high school was 60% or so Jewish when I attended, and it was what I was used to.
FWIW she wasn’t a hater. Very sweet. Small town church going girl. Just thought that. Was happy to be educated otherwise. Was a bit embarrassed.
Me too.
And -
I completely understand your complete inability to understand why someone would, and your inability to recognize that not everyone believes the same things you do.
But despite your incredulity there are those of us who think she is very wrong but who very seriously believe that she believes she is acting consistently with her principles. Along with being butthurt.
My apologies - it is indeed possible to hold such delusional beliefs sincerely. I shouldn’t have left out that possibility.
EDIT: Let me clarify the principle I was referring to. Stevens claims it was about antisemitism. That’s delusional. There’s no reasonable mind that would conclude AES is more dangerous for Jews than MAGA Mike Rogers. Israel (or at least supporting this Israeli government)? Not delusional. Maybe that’s the principle she was sticking to.
Campus Crusade was still around when I went to school. The ones I met weren’t as weird about Jewish people, though.
I did think their name was super weird. Oh, sure, name your student club after one of the lowest points in your religion’s history! What’s next, The Campus Inquisition? Campus Jihad?
Really there are very reasonable minds that conclude that. You are engaging in a true Scotsman fallacy, because you personally don’t come to that conclusion.
I believe I am of reasonable mind and non-delusional. I am less unhappy with AES as Senator from Michigan than I would be if Rogers won. And I am of the belief that AES in office is more dangerous for Jews than Rogers.
To my read, delusional as you consider it, Rogers’ blind eye to hate on the right and hiring those in the MAGAsphere with Nazi love is the current baseline, bad and less bad than the Tucker Carlson version, but not increasing it.
I read El-Sayed as minimally enabling the increase of more demonization of Jews within the Democratic Party. He normalizes a tactic that appealing to antisemites is more effective for votes than condemning it. That potential to make a change from the current already not great baseline makes it a bigger danger. To my delusional read.
He may end up causing more harm to the Democratic Party than good. Or not. I don’t know.
ETA - not gonna relitigate my conclusion. Made my points before.
Yes, you’re delusional if you believe this. MAGA are Nazis. They want fascism, authoritarianism, white supremacism. That’s Rogers. They’ve shown it again and again.
Even if AES bears some bias or bigotry against Jews (I remain unconvinced), that’s still nothing compared to MAGA, as far as danger to Jews. Electing Rogers empowers MAGA (and thus fascism, authoritarianism, and white supremacism) – electing AES disempowers MAGA (both in small but real ways).
That was sarcasm, obviously. I think we all understand that even if someone says the magic words “I condemn X form of racism” it does not mean that they aren’t unintentionally enabling racism or are even racist themselves.
You’re barely dressing up the (completely unreasonable) attitude that permeates American political discourse which is that Republicans can be viewed as a force of nature but Democrats are viewed as being active agents.
Excellent point. Endorsing MAGA is not a passive thing, it means actively endorsing fascism, authoritarianism, corruption, white supremacism. That’s what Haley Stevens did. No reasonable mind endorses fascism, authoritarianism, corruption, and white supremacism.