Abdul El-Sayed vs Haley Stevens - Progressives vs Centrists, gloves-off discussion

Really that’s not my attitude, or thought.

My thought is based on the likely impact of each individual.

Rogers is, to my read, a transactional MAGAist. A follower. A foot soldier at most. The impact he has or would have on the direction of the Republican Party is zero. He is no change agent. Not of the party nor of any minds.

El-Sayed is different. In this view of him he has potential to be of influence in how the Democratic Party behaves. That potential to be a thought leader within the party is of course what excites those who like him. An effective change agent. And I see his impact of change inclusive of increasing antisemitism. (And specifically increasing it in my political home, where I have generally comfortably lived.)

Directionality matters too. That is perhaps the part you react to. Antisemitism is not increasing within the GOP. If anything people like Rogers are, relative to their party, less bad than the party mean.

But antisemitism (and other forms of bigotry) are increasing in the country. MAGA is contributing to this much, much more than the Democratic party. Supporting MAGA over a Democrat, like it or not, helps MAGA. How is helping MAGA remotely justified, in this or any other instance?

ISTM you’re excusing being a “MAGAist follower”. That seems awful to me. Going along with MAGA, even if you don’t believe it deeply yourself, is about as bad as anything any politician can be doing at present. Certainly worse than anything AES has done or is likely to do.

Well I’d love to always have thought leaders within the party that had no problematix qualities for ne but it does no good to have a perfect party in the minority.

Stevens didn’t remotely even make a case like @DSeid did. She didn’t even mention the bigotry, fascism, authoritarianism, etc., of MAGA, in her explanation or justification.

Among many other indicators, this shows she just is not a serious thinker, not serious about opposing bigotry, or even antisemitism - she’s not serious about anything aside from her own personal grievances.

Honestly I am not so sure of that. There are more overt antisemites in the MAGA movement definitely, but I am not convinced that antisemitism has increased there. I do however fear the increase I am seeing on the Left.

I agree. Which why I am less upset over an El-Sayed win than I would have been with a Rogers one; why I would have voted for him if I lived in Michigan. But a conclusion that it is fucking delusional to think that anyone can honestly be doing other than I’d do motivated by their same or similar concerns about antisemitism is fucking stupid.

Other than? That’s fine (as long as you’re not voting MAGA). Voting MAGA? Fucking delusional.

Rogers is MAGA through and through. He’s not Liz Cheney. He’s not even Susan Collins.

I think it’s increased on both sides. The Rs are FAR more open about their antisemitism, if nothing else. And that moves the Overton window and empowers random people to express antisemitism. Like the gas station near me where my sister saw a star of David in the intentional “don’t do this” sign. (The circle with a slash.)

I agree that antisemitism is also growing on the left. I don’t personally think that El-Sayed is going to push in that direction. But i don’t think you are crazy. I just hope you are wrong and I’m right.

@DSeid isn’t crazy - he doesn’t support MAGA. But Stevens is crazy (or dishonest/malicious) for supporting MAGA - don’t you agree?

And how do you know that the sign was put up by a right wing anti-Semite and not a left wing anti-“Zionist”? The only place I’ve seen signs like that is at pro-Palestine protests.

I hope so too.

I do however see overtly antisemitic signs like that at “antizionism” protests and nothing being said about them. (“Jews control media” sort.) The Overton window is I perceive moving more on the Left.

I agree with @Babale here - that sign might be by a MAGA supporter or may be by someone who claims to be an “antizionist” of the Left.

Here’s where I admit I am not sure I am being rational more than emotional: I am less afraid of the neonazi cosplayers who are easy to identify, than I am of the folk who mouth how against antisemitism they are while they enable it and appeal to it in their ranks. That goes for Trump’s alleged crackdown against antisemitism (which isn’t that at all), and no less for El-Sayed.

@iiandyiiii I am against MAGAism for many many reasons. And if all I was looking through was the lens of antisemitism, and ignoring every other issue, I see El-Sayed as a potentially bigger impact on it than MAGA is.

And again I hope @puzzlegal is right and I am wrong. The other issues are so existential for the nature of our country, for, without exaggeration, the nature of human civilization, that I have no choice.

At least while MAGA remains the face of the GOP.

Dude you literally called me “fucking delusional.”

Stevens is fucking delusional (or dishonest or malevolent), along with anyone else who thinks voting Rogers is better for fighting antisemitism. You’ve stated you understand that position, but don’t hold it yourself (IIRC). So you’re not fucking delusional, you’re just defending the ones who are.

I don’t think you’re being rational there. One important difference, ISTM, is that antisemitism on the left is decreased when principled Jews declare our support for Palestinian rights, while AFAICT in MAGA it’s increased, if anything.

The main reason that MAGA is not even more aggressively antisemitic than it is already is because they feel that at least they can count on Israeli Jews and their supporters to hate and kill Muslims. Personally, I find that way more frightening than antisemitism among Palestinian-rights supporters.

Although the latter is definitely a real phenomenon and needs to be pushed back against, ISTM that even contemplating MAGA as a possibly preferable alternative is a textbook instance of reaching for a “cure” WAY worse than the disease.

Moreover, MAGA are not merely cosplaying as neonazis. Actually, it’s quite the opposite. They are neonazis cosplaying as politicians.

This is easily among the most infuriating threads I have followed from a distance in the last several months. I think I might be ready to tap out. I just cannot parse how endorsing, voting for, or actually being (as Rogers himself is) a member of the fascist party of antisemites is worse than voting for, endorsing, or actually being an antifascist that some antisemites might also like.

ETA: You know what? Fuck it. I’m just going to say it. DSeid, I think you’re being islamophobic, in the most literal sense of the word. Shame on you.

Well I have already copped to that possibility of less rational than emotional. And this goes back to late teen years with neonazis wanting to march in Skokie - I then argued for treating them as clowns and having a circus as a counter protest. But I do not see any evidence of your second part. Actually the evidence is against. Just look at the Greens in Britain. Led by a Jewish man taking strong pro Palestinian rights positions and a hard line on Israel. And which passed resolutions that were pretty clearly past pro Palestinian rights and antisemitic.

Jewish Americans criticism of Israeli actions and support for Palestinian rights has increased over the last few years, substantially. And antisemitism on the left has? Dropped as you claim? No. It is continuing to increase.

It’s The Pit. Feel free to say it if that’s what you think.

I think that’s your lazy thinking, but you do you.

You’re missing a “not” somewhere in this sentence, I think.

Emphasis added for semantics check: you meant the other way around, right?

I am going to state that anti-Semitism is not a left-wing position, not a theoretically acceptable left-wing position, and that anything like that needs to be thoroughly and publicly nipped in the bud. It is not even a legitimate right-wing position. You can’t have people like that attempting to glom onto one’s legitimate movement, you definitely do not let them stir shit up at your protests, unless we are talking about neo-Naziism or the various forms of far-right populism and nationalism where it is, of course, standard doctrine.

@iiandyiiii and @Kimstu, yes, thank you.

To be clear: voting for, endorsing, or being MAGA (which is our nation’s fascist antisemite party) is objectively worse than voting for, endorsing, or being an antifascist who some antisemites may also happen to be attracted to.

I cannot fathom how anyone who isn’t operating under the influence of at least some kind of bigotry (here, I suspect islamophobia) could think otherwise. And I don’t think it serves any of us—even DSeid—well to overlook that. It’s the elephant in the room.

? What do you mean “pretty clearly”? ISTM that on the contrary, it turns exactly on the highly disputed issue of whether the view that modern Jews do not have an inherent right to maintain a Jewish ethnostate in the territory of ancient Israel is or is not antisemitic. That doesn’t have a single “pretty clear” answer, much as we might wish it did.

If Zionism cannot coexist with full support for Palestinian rights and sovereignty (and remember, leaders of the Israeli state just recently affirmed that Zionist principles would never permit the establishment of a Palestinian state, though personally I don’t agree with them), then I don’t see how principled supporters of Palestinian rights can be expected not to denounce Zionism.

Now, we can argue over who gets to decide what “Zionism” really means, and whether and which particular definitions of “Zionism” are even antisemitic in and of themselves, etc. But if the actual leaders of Zionism as a national enterprise are explicitly saying that it’s fundamentally inconsistent with Palestinian rights, then you can’t really blame supporters of Palestinian rights for taking them at their word.