Abdul El-Sayed vs Haley Stevens - Progressives vs Centrists, gloves-off discussion

I truly admire your patience, @DSeid, but posts like this one make it pretty clear that good faith discussion is not possible with this group of people. You’ll note how no one on that side is bothering to defend you from ASL’s ridiculous accusations of Islamophobia or even to disavow it, but the idea that you would find the Green Party pronouncement to be anti-Semitic is beyond the pale.

Let’s just make sure never to ask the leaders of Palestinian nationalism what they want to do with the Jewish people who live there.

And here is where my self discipline needs to apply and I will refrain from repeating arguments made in previous threads as serving no function. My concerns relevant to the issues of this thread have been made, were made before this thread really, which is why I stayed out for a while; they are either understood or they are dismissed as Islamophobic or whatever. That is out of my hands and not served by further repetition.

It continues to be interesting seeing (and being a part of) the schism in American Jews in real-time. What will it be like in 5 years, or 10?

Groups like the Palestinian National Liberation Movement go on about eradicating the Zionist state, but they do not mention Jews all that much, except, tellingly, stating that they are against Jewish immigration to Palestine (nobody is going to complain if they say they are against colonialism, imperialism, and violent illegal settlers, though). Anyway, before the left (or anyone) can condemn them as being corrupt and in fact oppressing Palestinians (and Jews!) themselves, the problem is that they are in no real position of power.

Do have any guesses of your own?

As someone whose fairly liberal real world has equal numbers on each side of me I see several possible futures.

The one I am thinking is more likely than the others is that MAGA loses control of the GOP, and that the antisemites end up feeling increasingly comfortable among progressives as strange bedfellows, and a large chunk of American Jews break with a Democratic Party they feel is not taking their concerns seriously. The schism gets larger between two groups that are both left of center but with very different perceptions of reality and of where the greatest current threats are.

Happy if I am right about the decline of MAGA as the face of the GOP. Sad if I right am about the rest.

It’s just a guess, but I think the schism will focus almost entirely on Israel. I expect the Jews who no longer feel welcome in the Democratic party will become Republicans or Republican-leaning independents. I think Jews will remain majority Democratic but it will be a smaller majority than before. I think this will be a durable change, and the pro and anti-Israel Jews will be increasingly angry and vitriolic at each other.

But it’s just a guess.

I think the Democrats will eventually toss out the entryists, and I hope that’s not just wishful thinking. But I really do think that the Democrats will be more resistant to a takeover than the Republicans were.

I don’t see MAGA just fading away, though. If the Democrats do suffer a MAGA style takeover, I think it’s more likely that we’ll just have two insane parties, at which point the fascists will almost certainly fully come out in the open (under the cover of “we have to stop them”), and the public will side with them. And American democracy will be lost.

Who are the entryists? I don’t think I’ve ever heard that term (for politics).

EDIT: Googled it, it just means newcomers to a political movement. But Jews like me absolutely enraged by the Israeli government are not remotely “entryists” to US politics. And the politics of AES and Mamdani strongly seem to be on the rise in the party. Not sure how the party could ever throw them/us out without destroying any chance of future victories.

The threat to jews or any other underprivileged group is not just about the numbers of people who hate them, it’s also about shared commitment to democracy and pluralism.

America has always been filled with people on the spectrum of ignorance to distrust to open hate for them both from dominant to underprivileged groups and between underprivileged groups.

Since the civil rights era we’ve had a large, bipartisan, multicultural segment that realized that equal rights, universal participation in democracy, and institutional impartiality prottect everyone. Trumpism is a relatively unique threat to that and any member of a minority group who doesn’t recognize that and vote to get Trumpism out of power is an idiot.

This has already been happening, at least since 2015, especially among American Orthodox Jews:

Funny thing is that I am pretty sure if the same reality occurs your read will be that, that it is almost entirely about Israel, and mine will be seeing it as not about Israel much at all, but rather a perception that a welcome mat to antisemites was laid out while denying it is there, and that concern over that is dismissed, or labeled as being Islamophobic or delusional or similar … :grinning_face:

Yeah, this is a “chickens coming home to roost” political moment. There has long been a leftist critique of the so-called “PEP phenomenon”, i.e. “Progressive Except for Palestine”, among Jewish and non-Jewish leftists alike:

For a long time it had been somewhat taboo among liberals to strongly denounce Israel for human rights violations, even among liberals who were pretty outspoken against other human rights violations. Partly, of course, this was due to the fact that numerous Israelis themselves had their human rights violated by Palestinian terrorism and militant resistance, which made the pro-Palestinian narrative a lot more murky. And partly it was because Israel had a carefully maintained image as a US ally, “the only democracy in the Middle East”, etc., which carried a very strong presumption-of-good-guys. Liberals might not like Israel constantly expanding settlements in the occupied territories and endorsing “mowing the grass” attacks, etc., but they mostly weren’t going to make an issue of it.

Now that Israel’s image is deteriorating, “PEP etiquette” is losing influence in the Democratic Party. Is some of this effect motivated by antisemitism that is now finding more niches even outside of traditional fascist bigotry where it’s socially and politically tolerated? Undoubtedly, and that’s a problem. But I think a lot of it’s due just to the liberating effect of people realizing it’s no longer taboo in mainstream discourse to call Israel out for injustices.

More than this - I feel like I was lied to my entire life. Just an incredible betrayal of the truth and of human decency. Yes, the changing sentiment has exposed and been influenced by antisemitism (some of it apparently newly revealed), and that’s always bad, on the left or the right. But this “new” antisemitism is monumentally dwarfed by the Islamophobia and anti-Palestinian lies and bigotry of the past several decades by American media and politicians, as well as Jewish and gentile allies of Israel (and, of course, most Israeli leaders). And these lies and bigotry continue, occasionally vaguely condemned by “progressive” allies of Israel, but rarely anything more from them. Such incredibly massive bigotry, and decades of lies, is still less important, and less evil to them, then rhetorical threats to their perception of Israel.

I feel ya. I really, really work not to let this resentment make me unjust toward the vast, vast majority of people who weren’t trying to lie to me about anything.

But yeah, you know that tang of bitter disgusted queasiness you get as a US liberal when you think about your schoolbooks back in the day talking about the “heroic Pilgrims” and the “brave pioneers” “taming the wilderness” or even “facing the savages”, and never bothering to tell you about the stuff that European settlers actually did to Native Americans?

Same feeling as a US Jew when you think back to being told about all the “idealistic kibbutzniks” and war heroes and refugees “making the desert bloom” (with whose water, btw?), and being the brave underdog David and building a modern economy while restoring all the ancient archaeology and making the Bible history live again and all. And never a word about all the displacement and ongoing dispossession of Palestinians (never mind actual massacres etc.) and appropriation and/or destruction of their material history on the land. Etc. etc. etc.

This is nothing new, of course. I know straight people similarly enraged about having been brought up in the “family values” homophobia movement, and even some older white women still bitter about having been fed a line about how segregation was for their protection.

In general, it’s just emotionally irritating and shaming to look back on sanitized history that told only one side of a story that you used to believe and feel uncomplicated pride in, because you didn’t know any better.

Some people, of course, just can’t handle the cognitive dissonance and double down on the sanitized narrative (see, e.g.,1776 Project vs 1619 Project).

The thing is, the GOP is pro-Israel, but rather antisemitic. So if they are willing to join that party and said party doesn’t change, it would heavily suggest that antisemitism was not the issue.

Furthermore, said party is rather Islamophobic and bigoted in general. They would clearly not see that as disqualifying.

If there are barely any Republican gains, but we still see Jewish voters leave, then I’d say that’s more likely to be due to antisemitism in the Democratic party. (Assuming, of course, that said antisemitism doesn’t get better.) Still, I’d want to hear what they have to say, as I hear both legitimate cries against antisemitism and conflation of antisemitism with being anti-Zionist.

Just as I hear legitimate anti-Zionist stuff (from different people) that’s just mad at Israel, as well as stuff that attacks Jews or Israelis as a whole. Some stuff that I can chalk up to ignorance, and some stuff that I very much can’t.

Another thing to bear in mind is that US Jews are not actually the major constituency for the Republicans’ pro-Israel positions. That would be evangelical/fundamentalist Christians.

Christians United for Israel (CUfI) has around ten million members, which is like one and a half times the number of all US Jews. And that’s just counting the Christians who are passionate enough about supporting Israel to sign up for membership in an organization about it. There are probably at least three to five times that many who are sufficiently receptive to that position to vote the way a CUfI member encourages them to. That’s going to have way more of a political impact than changes in how some subset of Jews themselves vote.

We know. It’s what the leaders of Israel are already doing to the Palestinian people who live there.

Perfect example of “we have to get rid of those people before they get the power to get rid of us!”

There may actually be parallels. I cited the PLO as being against Jewish immigration to Israel/Palestine, which is absolutely beyond the pale IMO, but I personally know someone who took a job in Israel and was not exactly welcomed with open arms, I specifically mean by the immigration bureaucracy, because, let us be blunt, he was not Jewish. (What was he? Of that rare ethnicity: someone with valuable technical and creative skills.)

Because, if you take away my foundational myth… Spain reconquering itself for Christianity then bringing the Gospel to the Americas; the US Founding Fathers creating liberty and justice in the open frontier; the children of Israel arising mighty and proud after near extermination… etc. then what am I but myself just… just the same as… as THOSE OTHERS .