Abdul El-Sayed vs Haley Stevens - Progressives vs Centrists, gloves-off discussion

If that were true, there wouldn’t be any Palestinians living there anymore. You know, the same way that the surrounding Arab countries successfully ethnically cleansed 99.6% of their Jewish population.

It is both true and well-documented, as is your persistent denial of it.

It’s true and well documented that 99.6% of Palestinians have been removed from Palestine? Incredible!

Your habit of claiming people said things they didn’t is also well-documented. And now a little moreso.

I’m not the one who claimed that Israel wants to do to Palestinians what every Arab country has done to Jews, which is evict 99.6% of them. That would have been you.

Which one did I say - that they want to do it (which is well-supported by years of evidence) or that they already did it (which you made up)?

Oh look - once again I’m right and you’re a lying sack of shit.

If Israel wanted to do it, there would be nothing stopping them. Israel could easily have done that to the Palestinians at any time since the Arab nations abandoned them in 1973. Israel has not done that because it has no desire to.

As we swiftly move past you lying about what I said…

Do you think “If Israel were committing genocide, they’d be better at it” is an actual argument a normal human being would make?

Given Israel’s reliance on international support and the heat they’re already getting for what they are doing right now to the Palestinians, do you think maybe they decided long ago that incrementalism is a more effective approach? It certainly seems to be working for them.

The rates of settlement growth, in both area and population, are publicly available data. Israel is steadily pushing Palestinians off their own land, and brutalizing/killing them when they resist (and sometimes when they don’t!).

If you’re doing something so “incrementally” that you’re actually working away from your supposed end goal, it’s possible that you’ve decided that making negative progress for long enough will somehow pay off in the long run, but I think it’s far more likely that it’s not actually your goal.

…Palestinians in Gaza are restricted to only 35% of the land in Gaza. Israel controls the rest.

Cite.

It isn’t a question of if they take the rest but simply when. The only thing that will stop it is international action.

And when that doesn’t happen, will you admit you were wrong?

So your response to the fact that Israel is pushing Palestinians off their own land is “maybe they’ll stop”?

It is so entertaining that any thread even peripherally related to Israel and Palestine will find its way from the OP to the usual people repeating their same things again.

Anyway my small drive by comments.

Given that your clear position is that the leaders of Israel are engaged in genocide, is it supposed to be a comforting point that you feel we “know” that Palestinian nationalists want to commit genocide against Jews there?

I get the point you are trying to make but it doesn’t land. Yes, there was massive ethnic cleansing of long time Jewish communities across Arab countries from the ‘40s to the ‘70s, and some self-deportation, to the scale of 800 to 850K people, almost all of the long standing Jewish populations of those countries.

But using that historical fact to discount the current Israeli leadership ethnic cleansing and at best disregard for the lives of Palestinians, and the racism of Israeli leadership targeting its own Arab citizens, is a rhetorical fail.

Anyway the two of you agree that Palestinian nationalists desire to implement at best ethnic cleansing if not genocide of Jews in the region. So not sure why you are beating each other up over it?

For the very little it is worth my belief is that there is leadership on both sides that would love to have all of the other side removed AND it is a reasonable goal shared by some Palestinian nationalists (not Hamas to be sure) that Palestinian nationalism can be served with a two state solution and without cleansing the region of Jews.

And now back to the rinse and repeat talking points!

…they have already taken 65% of the fucking land in Gaza.

That already more than fits my threshold for ethnic cleansing. It’s done already. It doesn’t have to be 99.6%. Even a small percentage would have been enough.

What exactly is your threshold here?

…so you don’t think its genocide?

Not current for long.

And I have more than plenty of criticism for Netanyahu and his ilk, and even more for the sorts of Ben Gvir. My clear position on the settlements, which I’ve repeated over and over again, is that they should be bulldozed to make way for a two state solution.

But that has to be accompanied by some movement towards peace from the other side. So if I’m talking to people like @Gyrate who completely deny any agency from the Palestinian side, that’s what I will focus on.

You’re playing very fast and loose with terms there. Israel “took” 65% of the land in Gaza in the same sense that America “took” land in Germany in 1945. Israel has “taken” exactly 0% of the land in Gaza in the sense you imply.

I don’t know why you would think I would consider that “comforting”. Why would you think that?

There are Palestinians who want to exterminate all the Jews in Israel. There are Israeli Jews who want to exterminate all the Palestinians in Israel. Often the people driving the extermination and accompanying rhetoric on both sides are those who benefit personally and/or and politically from doing so. Usually the victims of the resultant violence on both sides are innocent people just trying to go about their daily lives in peace. None of that ought to be a surprise to anyone, and at this point “X started it” is so utterly pointless an approach that only people making excuses for what their preferred side is doing even bother with it anymore.

But we’ve had a long, long time to see what “I need to kill people like you because people like you want to kill people like me” gets us. It gets us a lot of dead people.

So once again you’re “focusing” on something you made up about me. As usual. At no point have I ever “completely denied any agency from the Palestinian side”. You really are incapable of making an honest argument about anything.

And if this is a repeated talking point, I will stop pointing out that @Babale is lying to excuse genocide committed by Israel when he stops doing it. Which may be never.

And yet you keep describing the situation as a “genocide” perpetrated by Israel out of a desire to ethnically cleanse Palestinians, rather than grappling with the reality of how Hamas’ behavior has shaped this war. Curious.

Have you stopped beating your wife?