Abdul El-Sayed vs Haley Stevens - Progressives vs Centrists, gloves-off discussion

It’s certainly curious how much of what I literally just wrote you’d have to ignore to come to that conclusion. But it’s not at all curious that you’d do so anyway.

I’ve never beaten my wife, whereas you have repeatedly lied (here and elsewhere) to excuse the genocide being committed by Israel. Including by claiming well-documented occurrences weren’t happening.

It’s curious that I have to ignore none of what you wrote? Interesting.

It’s well documented that you have.

Oh, wait, repeating that something is well documented doesn’t make it so.

It’s amusing how much you lie while claiming that I am lying.

So ethnic cleansing is acceptable in these circumstances? You just said the settlements should be bulldozed… Now you say they should continue until “the other side” does something? What do they need to do for you to be in favor of stopping the ethnic cleansing? And if they don’t, you think the settlements should keep going until all the Palestinians are gone?

Well there’s three lies right there, although only tangentially in support of Israel’s actions.

Perhaps he believes that Israel has no agency of its own?

Lol. Lmao even. Thanks for demonstrating my point you dishonest piece of shit:

Is dishonestly editing a quote against the rules even in the Pit?

The fact he cited is actually factual. Immaterial but factual. Not a lie.

My driveby perspective between the regular standard back and forth sniping is that I believe we are far from the point of getting to a mutually beneficial coexistence in the region but that we can get there from here. A new set of leaders in Israel is a good and necessary first step, if it happens. Palestinian nationalism explicitly renouncing the destruction of Israel as its goal and instead aiming for that mutually beneficial mutual coexistence as the target, requiring much trust building from all sides to get there, is another.

Anyone who believes such is impossible, and believes that each side will in control do their best to eliminate the other is implicitly endorsing each side trying to destroy the other as self defense. First strike mentality.

And I agree, that mutual hatred serves some actors individual self interests, while the process in the direction of mutual coexistence deals them as individuals out.

Why would Palestinian nationalism as a movement ever do that when they get overwhelming support from useful idiots like the Green Party and the River to the Sea protestors? If making maximalist demands never penalizes you, why would you ever do anything except for make maximalist demands?

The only way that this change in Palestinian nationalism will ever come about is through international pressure, and I don’t see that happening any time soon.

Maybe Israel should stop committing massacres, brutalizing and killing Palestinian civilians on their own land, raping Palestinian prisoners, etc., and international pressure might change course? Maybe killing tens of thousands of Palestinian civilians is the kind of thing that invites international condemnation for the perpetrators, and sympathy for the victims?

@Babale openly admits Israel is doing terrible things (if not nearly as bad as the critics in this thread detail). But he still isn’t even willing to consider that maybe international sympathy for Palestinians could be related to those terrible things Israel is doing to Palestinians.

The same answer as to the question of why Israeli leadership would ever renounce their current horrific policies when they get support from useful idiots regardless.

Ideally because both sides live their children and grandchildren and see that as in their best interests.

Wow, that’s a pretty inequitable set of “first steps” you seem to have there. All we’re expecting of Israeli nationalism is “a new set of leaders” to qualify as progress, while for Palestinian nationalism we’re specifically requiring that it must “explicitly renounc[e] the destruction of Israel” and “aim[] for that mutually beneficial mutual coexistence”?

I call bullshit. I don’t think we ought to be setting any expectations or requirements on the Palestinian side that we’re not also mandating for the Israeli side. Let’s demand right up front that Israeli nationalism must explicitly renounce the appropriation of Palestinian territories and suppression of Palestinian statehood as its goal, and instead aim for mutually beneficial mutual coexistence. (And since they’re the ones with the greatly disproportionate amount of power in this conflict, how about they do that before they demand similar concessions from “Palestinian natiionalism”.)

And what could Palestinians even do now? There are no Palestinian leaders. No significant civilian Palestinian organizations with any power. The violence and oppression and violations of rights need to stop first, before any discussion of “both sides”. Stop the killing, then maybe talk.

Is this about the definition of genocide, or something else? Because I certainly haven’t denied the agency of Palestinians.

Why would Israel ever

when they get overwhelming support from useful idiots like US evangelicals, the Trump administration, the religious right in Israel, etc etc… The answer, of course, is as you say:

And the first step is acknowledging what Israel is doing, that it is doing so under its own agency, and that opposition to it isn’t inherently antisemitic.

*except possibly in some form of competition, I suppose.

There’s tons and tons of international pressure on Israel to change course in regards to Palestinians policy. That’s the difference I’m talking about. There’s zero international pressure on Palestinian leadership to accept a two state solution.

That’s a pretty uncharitable read from you (so, you know, par for the course).

The difference is that there are already Israeli leaders with those exact goals, and @DSeid is clearly referring to them coming into power when he talks about a new set of leaders in Israel. Who is the equivalent on the Palestinian side?

Palestinians aren’t committing ongoing massacres and murders and violations of rights of civilians at the moment.

And if the new Israeli leaders haven’t committed to ending the settlements and stopping the killings of Palestinian civilians, then maybe international pressure on those issues wouldn’t be appropriate to cease?

I can definitely sign on to that: both publicly sides commit to the target of mutually beneficial coexistence, neither by rhetoric or by action working contrary to that process. International actors, including the United States work towards holding both sides to that commitment with consequences, such as funding being withheld or offered.

He stated an immaterial fact about the ethnic cleansing of Jews from Arab countries. It was not false; it was a rhetorical lead balloon.

The international pressure that matters would be from the United States and that pressure is notably deficient.

That can be spun as a point FOR Israeli policies: it is working to keep Hamas from doing it again. It is an awful argument that discounts the human suffering of others to achieve it, but … mutual trust building requires all involved do the work.

Antisemitism assuredly is responsible some of the world’s anger at Israel. But Israel is doing tons and tons of terrible things. As long as they’re doing those terrible things, cries of antisemitism are not likely to change any minds.

Maybe Israel should stop doing these terrible things?

What could Palestinians possibly do right now? What power do they have to do anything while they’re subject to so much ongoing brutality and murderous violence?

That’s true today, thanks in part to the Genocide Joe voters (or rather, non-voters). It wasn’t true two years ago when Biden imposed sanctions on settlers. Mission accomplished?

My point isn’t that there should be no pressure on Israel to move towards a two state solution. Of course there should be, internal and external. But that pressure has to one, drive towards a two state solution, not some river to the sea fantasy; and two, has to be applied to both sides.

Could? Agree to Hamas disarmament and the acceptance of Israel’s right to exist as a state of Jewish cultural character if do chooses to do so.

More reasonable process in my fantasy? Israel under a new ruling coalition cracks down on West Bank settler terrorism hard. The new government ceases additional military action in Gaza and facilitates rebuilding. First steps taken unilaterally with the understanding that additional steps need steps that reassure the Israeli people that Hamas will not use rebuilding of Gaza as a means to rebuild its offensive capacity. Then work on further small trust building steps. The exact steps? Above my grade but I believe they are possible. I believe they must be possible because the alternative is continued cycles of some attack on Israel resulting in some massively disproportionate response and suffering for the Palestinians as a certainty.

More than I intended in a drive by …