Abdul El-Sayed vs Haley Stevens - Progressives vs Centrists, gloves-off discussion

How would “Palestinians” do this? I know you realize Hamas and “Palestinians” are not synonyms. Please walk me through this process. Who makes this announcement, how do they make it, etc.?

The other paragraph sounds good to me (as a start), by the way.

Yes. And reasonably as a unilateral process Hamas would not. Which is why the reasonable approach has to be Israeli first steps. But then the cohesive international pressure has to be brought to bear on Hamas to accept next steps. If the Israeli public is not convinced that Hamas will both agree and follow through on no longer aiming to attack Israel the process collapses.

Okay, thanks.

And can we get those settlers out of those West Bank territories, while we’re at it? All West Bank settlements are a manifestation of “Greater Israel” expansionism, which as an ideology is fundamentally flipping the bird at Palestinian rights and sovereignty in their ancestral lands.

I can totally see there being some horse-trading in future negotiations where some Israeli West Bank settlements get to stay in exchange for some Palestinian repatriation in family properties in various places like Haifa. But the baseline recognition needs to be that the settlements as they stand aren’t legitimate in the first place, even when settlers aren’t terrorizing and assaulting their Palestinian neighbors.

…you are so full of shit.

There is no “fast and loose” with my terms here. Israel has restricted access to 65% of Gaza and they are doing this:

https://gisha.org/en/between-the-yellow-and-orange-lines/

https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org/investigations/2026/07/01/israels-campaign-erasure-demolition-eastern-gaza

Israel expanded by more than 10% the amount of land originally articulated in the “ceasefire” agreement. They are cleaning up the crime scene.

And most of the nearly 2 million displaced Palestinians in Gaza (out of a population of 2.1 million) will never ever be able to return to their homes, especially if those homes were on the other side of the line. Because those homes are gone. Flattened. Demolished.

And there is zero sign of reconstruction. This isn’t a case of “the Marshall Plan” where there are plans to rebuild Gaza so that Palestinians can lead better lives. Far from it.

The only “reconstruction plans” we’ve seen are the ones bandied about by the President of the United States’ son-in-law, and even in that case, it isn’t about giving Palestinians autonomy and agency, but it’s about taking that away.

And in the meantime people like you are entirely happy for 2 million Palestinians to be shoved into only 35% of the land, 2 million people displaced, living in flooded tents and ruins, living in shit and mud, living off scraps.

And you can only do that because you view Palestinians as subhuman. You don’t believe they deserve the same as everyone else. It’s why there will never be an atrocity against Palestinians you will not happily defend. You even blamed the killing of Hind Rajab on the driver and the killing of the ambulance workers sent to rescue her on the lack of coordination. (Both were lies).

There is a very very straightforward way we can improve the lives of Palestinians living in Gaza. We treat them like human beings. That’s it. That’s the secret. We live up to our obligations under the Geneva Conventions and international humanitarian law. We flood the strip with food and water and aid and medical equipment. Palestinians are given the resources so they can start reconstruction.

…Hamas has agreed to step down and hand over power to the National Committee for the Administration of Gaza.

What’s stopping that process is that Israel are not letting the NCAG into Gaza, effectively stalling the process.

This isn’t an accident. Its deliberate. Israel needs the “Hamas boogeyman” so that useful idiots like you can pretend that the only thing preventing Palestinians living in a warm dry home is Hamas.

This simply isn’t true. Hamas stopped being a threat on October the 7th, 2023. In fact, if Israel didn’t have a spectacular failure of security on that day, then they wouldn’t have been a threat on October the 7th either.

There were two ceasefire agreements: there was the one that Hamas actually signed, and there was the one that President Trump produced to the world stage. The one that Hamas signed didn’t require them to disarm. It said that Hamas members who did disarm would be given amnesty. But requiring them to disarm was never a thing they agreed to.

But since the ceasefire, Hamas has (apart from a handful of disputed incidents) kept to the agreement while Israel has broken it multiple times almost every single day. That includes only letting in about half of the amount of aid that they agreed to.

You keep acting like these are two equal parties when it should be the National Committee for the Administration of Gaza in charge of Gaza right now, not Hamas, and the only thing stopping that from happening is Israel.

We are still in this bizarro world that iiandyiiii and Kimstu are talking about where people’s positions are not shaped by the reality on the ground but by propaganda and talking points.

This shouldn’t be controversial, but Palestinians should be allowed to control their own borders. They should be allowed to defend themselves from ethnic cleansing and genocide. Ethnic cleansing and genocide are bad things. Countries like Israel that are committing these absolutely dispicable acts should be sanctioned, and the international community should be preventing these acts and punishing the perpetrators.

This shouldn’t be controversial, but Israel should end the illegal occupation of Palestine. It should stop attacking hospitals. It should give detainees a fair trial, and combatants should be afforded the protections of the Geneva Conventions. This shouldn’t be controversial, but Israel should stop torturing detainees.

This shouldn’t be controversial, but if any other country acted the way Israel has done, sabotaging supply chains to commit terrorist acts, murdering scientists in their sleep with their families, disguising themselves as doctors and nurses to commit extrajudicial assassinations, having a stockpile of nuclear weapons and lying about it, killing much of the leadership of two different countries, having networks of torture camps up and down the country-we wouldn’t consider them allies. We wouldn’t be defending them here on the dope.

But yet: here we are.

I thought this thread was about Abdul El-Sayed. Don’t we have a lot of other places to compare how awful the Israelis and the Palestinians are?

Yeah, I think the AES discussion has more or less run its course, at least until he says something else someone objects to.

I’m pretty sure hamas is effectively sanctioned by most of the world given that almost everyone designates them as a terrorist org. Tge only real pressure on Israel is patchwork sanctions on some settlers and affiliated orgs.

I obviously don’t think it’s bad for the most pressure to be on Hamas as they’re the worst actor in I-P.

I am hoping someone does the tell all story about exactly what happened in the final days.

It’s impossible to have a discussion on this board even tangentially related to Israel/Palestine without it getting completely hijacked by Banquet_Bear, Babale, et al. arguing with each other.

…for clarity: I now will only ever jump into a thread to discuss this only after a group of other people have decided that this is what they want to talk about. That goes double outside of the pit where I have restrictions on what I’m allowed to post. But inside the pit? If other people are going to be discussing it and then Babale decides to vomit his genocidal agenda, damn right I’m going to speak up about his blatant disinformation.

On review, that was probably me back in post #260 who inadvertently tossed the match into the gas can, sorry all. It is admittedly hard to keep a conversation focused on the distinctions between antisemitism and criticism of Israel without kicking the hornet’s nest (to vary the metaphor) of which particular criticisms of Israel are deemed antisemitic and by whom and why, and which are deemed legitimate and by whom and why.

…I can speak on this one from experience.

I’ve been publicly accused of antisemitism here on these boards, both in the pit and outside of the pit.

And I can tell you: it sucks.

Because the first thing you do is check your behaviour. I’m human after all. Perhaps I said something I didn’t intend. Perhaps I had said or implied something that was antisemetic, and if I did, then I absolutely would have withdrawn and apologised.

But I don’t think I had anything to apologise for. If you can find anything I’ve said that you think I should apologize for, please feel free to point it out.

But now: whenever someone accuses someone like Al-Sayed of antisemitism, I just roll my eyes now. I’m immune to it now. I’m sure he is as well.

Because it fucking hurts. The accusation hurt me deeply. The person that made it nearly drove me off the boards.

That’s what false accusations do. They are all about silencing people. And it used to work. Not so much any more. If El-Sayed actually has said something antisemitic, then absolutely he should be called out for it. Absolutely nobody has an issue with that.

The problem is it’s hard to spot anti-Semitism sometimes, especially for me, a person who is not Jewish and not attuned to those things. There’s also a point at which criticism of Israel becomes anti-Semitic, but it’s hard for me to spot the line myself.

To use the example of all the Jewish businesses boycotted in Philadelphia, I think one line that gets crossed is trying to punish “Jews who support Israel” as opposed to punishing “people who support Israel.” I find both unproductive, but the former rings as anti-Semitic to me. This boycott AIUI targeted Jewish-owned businesses.

Is association with a raging anti-Semite authoritarian lunatic like Hasan Piker sufficient to call El-Sayed an anti-Semite? I don’t think we’d be making exceptions if the Senator’s buddy was Tucker Carlson or any other kind of extremist. We tend to judge people by the company they keep. That had to be something El-Sayed understood and took a calculated risk to do anyway. It bothers me that he made that choice. It bothers a lot of people.

El-Sayed winning both elections was the best possible outcome for everyone given the absolute insanity of Haley Stevens and with Mike Rogers representing the white supremacist Republican party. I didn’t vote for her for a reason. One thing I don’t understand is how Republicans can by any stretch of the imagination be considered a better choice than Democrats on the subject of anti-Semitism. While I believe anti-Semitism is on the rise in the Democratic party, it’s already entrenched in the Republican party. No contest there.

Freddie DeBoer precisely sums up my political perspective:

I grew up around tweedy academic Marxists who read the holy texts all day and remained pure and never influenced anything. And that wasn’t good because the point is to change the world. Now socialism is full of people who adopted their politics from Twitter and YouTube and who know nothing about their own professed ideology. And that’s not good because politics has to be grounded in values to have any meaning.

By a funny coincidence, the perfect synthesis turns out to be me and my own approach.

I’m not sure you UI correctly on the Philadelphia “Bike on Your Left” boycott. As I pointed out in another thread discussing it, the boycott was apparently targeting specific businesses known in that area for their enthusiastic and well-publicized support for Israel.

A lot of media seem to have followed counterprotestors’ practice of describing the Philadelphia businesses in question simply as “Jewish-owned”, as though the boycotters were targeting Jews qua Jews, and not specifically calling out their Israel support. But I don’t think that claim has been convincingly established. (And it’s rather undermined by video of numerous counterprotestors waving Israeli flags.)

Protests of the Philadelphia CookNSolo restaurants using their staff and locations for pro-Israel activism have been happening for years. From December 2023:

Sweeping all of those ideological and political issues under the rug by describing the boycotted businesses merely as “Jewish-owned” looks to me somewhat contrary to the spirit of fighting ignorance.

I agree that there’s no identifiable bright line between anti-Zionism and antisemitism, and a lot of people who claim to be only protesting Israeli actions have got a lot of plain old-fashioned Jew-hatred sloshing around in their antagonism. But there is also a hell of a lot of propaganda on the other side trying to smear principled protest as nothing but mere Jew-hatred. It behooves the wary anti-antisemite to dig around underneath superficial reporting to get a more comprehensive picture.

Your quote doesn’t contradict @Spice_Weasel ’s characterization at all:

Yes, I think my cite quite clearly indicates that the protests against CookNSolo have been inspired by the owners’ intense pro-Israel activism, not specifically by their being Jews engaged in intense pro-Israel activism.

Describing the protested businesses solely as “Jewish-owned” without foregrounding a crucially relevant descriptor like “Israel-supporting”, which is what the vast majority of reporting on the recent Philly protest seems to be doing, is a propaganda move.

But i think you are missing a point. It’s different saying, “these Jewish-owned local businesses support Israel” and saying, “these local businesses support Israel”. I think the second is far less problematic. The first implies, with it’s very language, that part of the problem is their Jewish owners.