Abdul El-Sayed vs Haley Stevens - Progressives vs Centrists, gloves-off discussion

But, again, AFAICT it’s not the boycotters/protestors who are saying the former.

It’s the counterprotestors, and the journalistic narrative they’re promoting, that are leaning so hard on the “Jewish-owned” qualifier regarding these local businesses, while glossing over the protestors’ explicit messages about “stop the genocide” and similar.

That’s the side that is trying to make this narrative specifically about the Jewish identity of the businesses’ owners (and “the eve of the anniversary of Kristallnacht”? really?), rather than what the businesses are doing to support and promote Israel’s actions.

Not all the businesses that the bike guys tried to intimidate were owned by CookNSolo. This is a bullshit nonsense argument.

I don’t know what the intentions were of whoever started the protest. What i do know is that antisemitism is on display, loud and clear, in the messaging about it. Is the source the people who started the protest? Is the source the media? Did it pop up somewhere in between? I’m not sure. But I’m sure it’s there.

Are there other, non-Jewish-owned businesses in Philadelphia that have as enthusiastically supported Israel, and that were not subject to the boycott? Or, hell, are there other Philadelphia businesses that have supported another nation that’s engaged in similar genocidal atrocities and that are not boycotted?

Apart from the US itself, of course…

Oof. Heard.

No one asks Chinese restaurants if they support China and its treatment of the Uyghurs.

They have a website:

IMO, it’s pretty clearly anti-Israeli. The only mention of Jewishness is in the FAQ, and those pretty clearly point to CookNSolo’s (and supporters’) assumption/expectation that Pro-Jew is equivalent to Pro-Israel.

Then why did they do their little intimidation routine in front of Jewish owned restaurants that have nothing to do with CookNSolo?

Which restaurants were those?

I don’t see any ownership connection between CookNSolo and Mac Mart, Huda, or Schlesinger’s. So literally half the businesses they tried to intimidate. I don’t know how the CookNSolo narrative took hold when it’s so obviously false.

The owner of Huda worked for the owner of CookNSolo years ago as a chef but the new business has nothing to do with that. The other two are totally unrelated.

Well, beyond the fact that all three are owned by Jews.

True. On the other hand, how much does the US government (and the taxpayers) contribute to that treatment?

What does that have to do with trying to intimidate Jewish business owners out of town?

I had assumed the link was more “Overtly supported Israel (and/or the Israeli government)”. Was that not the case?

That was the claim made about CookNSolo, but as I’ve demonstrated, that claim was false; half the businesses have nothing to do with CookNSolo.

The fact that they have nothing to do with CookNSolo doesn’t mean they don’t overtly support Israel. Which is why I asked.

“Support for Isreal” in the US typically means supporting US military aid to Isreal. If we want that to stop (or if we want meaningful strings attached) then it’s fair to have a discussion about that issue, including calling out and even boycotting people who take a view we disagree with. I haven’t been following this particular story closely enough to know if this business and its owners have done anything that I would personally find objectionable. If they have been targeted merely for being Jewish, then it’s wrong (but not illegal). If they have been outspoken supporters of the current regime in Isreal, then it’s all fair activism on both sides.

The Chinese restaurant analogy is really quite different.

Have the protest organizers explained why the other non-CookNSolo establishments were protested?

Since all the Krystallnacht Bike Ride crew did was rant about CookNSolo, I haven’t seen any evidence that they “overtly support Israel”.

And even if they did, the idea that you would react by trying to drive them out of town is fucking nuts. There are pro-Palestinian Muslim owned businesses in my town; because I’m not a disgusting racist psychopath, I would never go and try to drive them out of town. It’s interesting that you’re bending over backwards to defend these guys.

This reminds me of that scene in The Big Sick where Kumail’s Pakistani American character is casually asked how he feels about 9/11.

My issue with trying to understand this situation is there are complex narratives and propaganda on both sides and it’s really hard to sort through it all. Is there any reasonably objective news source reporting on all this? I subscribe to NYT and I don’t know if it’s objective on this issue.