Abdul El-Sayed vs Haley Stevens - Progressives vs Centrists, gloves-off discussion

It’s really not. People assume that American Jews are somehow tied to Israel in a way they don’t assume of any other ethnic group. When Israel does something bad, American Jews get targeted, whether or not they have any relationship with Israel.

Yes, i take it back, there are other ethnic groups that get similar treatment. But y’all recognize that as bigotry when it happens.

Yehuda Sichel may be a case of “guilty by association”, but he has made pro-Israeli statements in the past.

Allan Domb, current owner of Schlesinger’s, has in the past donated 100% of sales to Israel-related causes.

Marti Lieberman (Mac Mart) seems politically neutral genuinely caught in the fray. Her sister though is pro-Israeli, which is what probably landed mac mart on the list.

There are quite a few Jewish-owned restaurants in Philly who weren’t on the boycott list.

Were there any on the boycott list that weren’t Jewish owned?

What the fuck does that mean? He made “pro-Israeli” statements in the past so it’s acceptable to try and drive him out of town?

There’s a deli owner who made pro-Palestinian statements in the past in my town, should I get a wannabe lynch mob to parade in front of his business screeching that this town has no room for people like him?

What the fuck is wrong with you?

You mean when he organized a 1 day fundraiser for victims of Oct 7?

Again, what the fuck is wrong with you?

There are Muslim business owners in my town who are currently donating to Palestine, do you think it would be appropriate for a mob to try to drive them out of here?

Are you listening to yourself? "Oh, it’s OK that a mob tried to drive him own of town, his sister made pro-Israel comments once.

What the fuck is wrong with you?

Of course not.

Maybe. However, I have a Jewish last name. The only people who have voiced an assumption that I support Isreal are other Jews. Obviously, I don’t know what most people are thinking when they think about me.

ISTM pretty clear that the CookNSolo protest was not based on antisemitism. But AFAICT the protests of the other businesses haven’t offered any real justification as to why they were targeted. Was this organized at the time? Was it a protest that blew up in the moment, and antisemitic elements targeted nearby Jewish businesses? What have the original organizers said about the other businesses targeted?

Also, this is a very silly objection. Yes, there are also CookNSolo businesses elsewhere in the city that weren’t on the Krystallnacht list. That’s because the protest wasn’t all across Philadelphia, it was specifically in Rittenhouse Square, where all of the targeted businesses were.

It’s interesting that you’re fucking doing that thing again.

I am not “trying to drive them out of town” (indeed, I’m not involved in this boycott at all). And I am not “bending over backwards to defend these guys”. These are things that are not happening.

What I was doing was asking the same reasonable questions as others were, to determine the facts of the matter and separate correlation and causation. It’s not surprising that businesses that overtly support Israel would be Jewish owned. But “opposing a business because it supports Israel” and “opposing a business because it’s Jewish-owned” are very different things, as has already been pointed out. And I wanted to know which one the actual evidence pointed to before I jumped to a conclusion.

I imagine most MAGA-supporting businesses are Christian-owned. If I boycott them, is it because I hate Christians?

The question ought to be “Were there any businesses on the list that didn’t overtly support Israel?”

(N.B Asking this question doesn’t mean I am approving of the specific actions of the boycotters or other anti-Israel protesters. Is that so hard to understand?)

FWIW, I do think it’s bigotry when it happens to Jews.

It also reminds me of the running gag in The Good Fight where white characters unfailingly mention to Black characters that they voted for Obama. Seeing a person through the lens of a single issue based only on ethnic identity is stereotyping. Asking them questions about it is something else.

Here’s the thing. Whether you have the purest of pure motives to end the Palestinian genocide, if your organization’s boycott list is all Jewish owned businesses, you should ask yourself, “Is this approach maybe going to fuel the flames of anti-Semitism?” and take as many steps as possible to ensure that it doesn’t. If the end result of your thing is people arguing about whether it was anti-Semitic or not, you dropped the ball. And not to mention, obscured the actual message.

It’s also like, with Charlottesville, people claim there were good people on both sides. My thing is, if I’m at a protest, and Nazi flags start showing up, I’m done. If I’m the organizer, I’m shutting it down. If I can’t shut it down, I’m immediately making a public statement about how this imagery and messaging are not welcome.

I’m making zero assumptions about motive for anyone posting here. I am assuming good faith of everyone present.

Understood and accepted, but the comment wasn’t specifically directed at you.

For the record I’m not comfortable with the results of the boycott, which is why I’m asking the questions in the first place. Jumping to conclusions is counterproductive.

I am calling out your bullshit again, yes.

Except that the question had been answered, multiple times. No, there’s been absolutely nothing shown by the boycotters to support the idea that these businesses were “pro-Israel”. You can see the straws Dorjan grasped at - “he had a fundraiser for Oct 7 victims” or “his sister said something positive about Israel once”.

But the point is that the bike group didn’t even bother to do that; they just lied and said these were CookNSolo businesses.

The question ought to be “did the boycotting group provide any evidence whatsoever that these businesses overtly supported Israel, or did they just lie and claim that these businesses were associated with CookNSolo?”.

Yes, it is, because I can’t imagine you asking these kinds of questions if this group targeted anybody other than Jews. If a right-wing group did this kind of thing to any other minority group, you wouldn’t be asking a hundred different questions to try and find a way to justify it. You would just condemn it.

And i completely believe that about you. But like @Babale , i feel that there are some in this conversation who aren’t so cognizant.

It’s funny how every time you claim to be “calling me out on my bullshit” it involves you making up stuff about me. Project much?

And did they? Or is this just your misrepresenting things again? I mean, what they said was

That in itself seems like a pretty clear statement of motive. I don’t know what they used as evidence of “supporting Israel” which is why I was asking the questions I asked.

The specific CookNSolo boycott was a separate thing, although with a predictable overlap.

You seem to be conflating the two. See why it’s useful to actually check the facts first??

  1. No it hadn’t, and
  2. This:

is answering a different question.

Except that they didn’t, as already noted. You just mixed up two related things.

Your inability to conceive of an honest line of enquiry comes as no surprise to anyone. And if you didn’t always jump in feet-first with your bullshit disingenuously conflating any opposition to Israel with antisemitism every single time, I wouldn’t be here calling you out for it and everyone else would be much happier. Indeed, it would be a lot easier to call out antisemitism if you’d knock this off.

That’s why I ask these questions - not to justify antisemitism but because you remain a lying sack of shit.

I haven’t made anything up.

But they provided exactly zero evidence that these businesses “support Israel” in some kind of nefarious way.

You see how that’s antisemitic, right?

If someone says that he dislikes Obama because he shoplifts and is on welfare, while providing exactly zero evidence that Obama does either of those things, I think it’s pretty safe to assume that this person is a racist.

Wasn’t the organization “Boycott CookNSolo” one of the organizers of the bike ride protest?

Yeah, you probably should have checked to see whether Boycott CookNSolo were among the organizers of the bike protest before spouting off.

Now who’s lying?

I don’t conflate all criticism of Israel with antisemitism. In fact, I have plenty of criticism for Israel myself.

What I do point out as antisemitic is the delegitimization of Israel’s right to exist. Or random attacks against Jews by people who have done exactly nothing to establish that those Jews are actually inappropriately pro-Israel.

How is it a different question? If you (the general you, referring here to the organizers of the protest, I am aware that you aren’t Philly Bike On Your Left or Boycott CookNSolo) want to drive a Jewish owned business out of town because it’s pro Israel, shouldn’t the burden of proof be on you (the general you, referring here to the organizers of the protest, I am aware that you aren’t Philly Bike On Your Left or Boycott CookNSolo)? If you (the general you, referring here to the organizers of the protest, I am aware that you aren’t Philly Bike On Your Left or Boycott CookNSolo) didn’t bother to provide any of that evidence beyond the business owner being a Jew, why do you (the general you, referring here to the organizers of the protest, I am aware that you aren’t Philly Bike On Your Left or Boycott CookNSolo) expect me to give you (the general you, referring here to the organizers of the protest, I am aware that you aren’t Philly Bike On Your Left or Boycott CookNSolo) any benefit of the doubt?

Assuming this is correct, this is pretty damning.

Cook’n’Solo or whatever? The evidence here is that they were throwing big dinners for folks that were getting ready to go fight for IDF. For someone who believes, as I do, that IDF is perpetrating genocide and other atrocities, that’s fucked up. I don’t want to give my money to a business that materially supports members of a genocidal military force explicitly for their membership in that force.

But that’s super different from making pro-Israel statements, which is also different from donating sales to non-military Israel-related causes. And both of those are very different from being related to someone with pro-Israel opinions.

Boycott the first. Boycotting those others is fucked up.

Look. I go to a local Chinese restaurant sometimes. If the owners of that restaurant hold special fancy dinners for officers of the Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps, I’d support a boycott of that restaurant, and I’d want to be told about that activity. But I would no more support a boycott of a Chinese restauranteur with pro-PRC opinions than I would support a boycott of a pro-Israel restauranteur.

Thank you for your intellectual honesty.

Too many people make the leap from “criticism of Israel is not always antisemitic” - which is true - to “criticism of Israel can never be antisemitic”. I genuinely appreciate the fact that you are not doing that.

I was thinking about that with regard to the notorious case of Hobby Lobby boycotts. Hobby Lobby is an arts-and-crafts store chain owned by evangelical Protestants, who use their store policies and revenues to promote many of what they identify as their Christian principles, e.g.:

  • not including contraception in their employee healthcare coverage
  • barring transgender employees from using restrooms designated for their identified gender
  • supporting anti-LGBTQ legislation and other initiatives
    etc.

Would it be fair and accurate to describe those boycotts simply as protesting “a Christian-owned business”? I don’t think so. It’s specifically about their policy and activism choices.

Right - very much UNlike the bike boycott, which was not about “specific policy and activism choices”. This is why you were easily able to provide four examples of specific objectionable HobbyLobby policies but the boycotters in the case we are talking about were not able to provide such examples for the non-CookNSolo businesses.

To say that this is disappointing would be an understatement.

There were Chinese owned business who were very vocal about Falun Gong, both for and against. There was backlash in both directions.

Do you have examples of Chinese owned businesses that are out in their support of the Chinese government’s actions in Xinjiang?

A better comparison might be the Russian School of Mathematics. The owners came out in favor of the Russian invasion (or at the very least, tried to blame Ukraine for it). There was lots of blowback, and no one tried to defend them (except some social media accounts that were probably Russian) on the basis that this represented some kind of hatred of them as Russians.

This is just a dumb and disingenuous argument.