Another factor in this analogy is the degree to which the US government is involved in the controversial actions in question. In the Xinjiang case, for one thing, the US has already established its position as forcibly opposed to the Chinese government’s oppression of the Uyghurs, and for another thing, China basically needn’t give a shit about US approval or opposition.
So even if US Chinese-American-owned restaurants were advocating for Uyghur oppression, it would be irrelevant to the US position or political influence on the issue. Which is quite different from the deep entanglement of US policy and society with the actions of Israel.
That said, if anybody knows of an actively pro-Uyghur-oppression US Chinese restaurant establishment, of course they’re free to boycott it, and it’s not anti-Asian bigotry to do so.
But yeah, I think the biggest difference is just that there aren’t US Chinese restaurants actively and publicly promoting CCP oppression of the Uyghurs.
Did anyone march against “Chinese owned businesses” and include some that generically support China, but didn’t comment on falun gong? Or against a restaurant owned by a guy who used to work at a place being targeted? Or against a restaurant owned by someone whose sister once said something?
Because “Jewish owned” restaurants like that were just targeted in the account we are discussing.
I’d still say that goes back to whether or not there are Chinese owned businesses openly supporting the Uyghur genocide. You need that first so that there is a reason to boycott. Then you might have the boycott conflate the two.
I think that, in a world where that was the case, you would have the same situation. There would be Chinese-American businesses caught in the crossfire for looking like they might have supported the genocide.
Yeah, there is the antisemitism of believing all Jewish people are pro-Israel and anti-Gaza. But I think that’s fueled at least in part by the existence of certain Zionists who treat being anti-Israel as being antisemitic. They are the ones pushing the idea that the “true Jew” must support Israel.
I would like to at least imagine that in America you can be Jewish (or Muslim, whatever) and be anti-whatever you want to be (let us say on the normal political spectrum, not necessarily an orthodox Nazi) and not be hurt or attacked.