AlahAkbar (NOT about the banning)

Coldfire: Wouldn’t that have been, “Y’all won’t catch me in this place again!”

No repeat business though. :slight_smile:

It’s spelled Jesus in Spanish too, it’s just pronounced hay-SOOSE.

Of course, Joshua, which was Jesus’ actual name in Hebrew and the one which he went by in his own day (Jesus being the Greek form of the name and the one adopted in the Gospels), is quite popular among U.S. anglophones today.

A better transliteration might be “Jehoshua” (Strongs 03091), and it means “Jehova is salvation”.

CarnalK - thanks for the info ! Does that mean it’s not inappropriate to name the restaurant after Buddha?

They’re actually Buddhists. Statues and incense and such make up the only decor.

I thought it was closer “Gandhi’s Roti” (which does exist) than “Christ’s Falafel” (doesn’t).

I have a photo I took in Switzerland of a store named “Christ Schmuck,” schmuck meaning “jewelry” in German, and “Christ” being the name of the proprietors.

The only reason why I posted my remarks - and my explanation for them - on the use of that sentence as membername by that particular member, was to show his complete ignorance of the religion Islam = to expose him as a fraud.

Of course there are - once again - people here who make a lot of nonsense up about what my “intentions” were.
So sorrry, but they were only what I say they were.

I you all want to go through real life or cyberlife calling yourselves AllahAkbar, that is fine with me. I shall only smile with your complete ignorance about the meaning of that sentence for a Muslim.
But the most stupid way to fake that you are a Muslim is using that same sentence as your name. Every single Muslim shall know immediately that you are a fake and even a complete idiotic one.

May I wish you much joy in dissecting and twisting this post in the coming hours. That seems to be such a popular hobby for so many among you that it is even a little bit fascinating to witness.
Salaam. A

Still waiting on citation that no Muslim in all the great wide world would use such a moniker, Aldebaran. In one word:

CITE?

Still waiting on citation that it is you who gets to decide on who is and is not Muslim. In one word:

CITE?

Especially as it’s her real name. :smiley:

BTW, Aldebaran; if it turns out that you’re wrong (which isn’t anywhere at all beyond the realm of likelihood at the moment), can we then say that you’re completely ignorant of Islam?

As much as I like you, Monty, you are, way, way off base in this instance. No Muslim is going to appropriate the name of the Most High because the casual blasphemy we take in stride in our pluralist society is unthinkable in the Muslim world. To them,the Name of God is so sacred that even a scrap of of waste paper bearing a fragment of the Qu’ran must be preserved because it might have borne the Name of God. No sincere, believing Muslim would so thoughtlessly desecrate the most holy name in the universe.

Moreover (and please do not be offended), you are not the Aribter of the LDS on the Dope, let alone of Islam. It is possible to disagree with you and still be knowledgeable about Islam.

Salaam Aleikum.

gobear:

Number 1) I did not say that I’m the arbiter of either LDS-hood or Muslim-hood.

Number 2) I was making a point that the username in question is no different than waving a flag with such an expression on it. I await an authoratative answer–with citations, of course–that NO Muslim would consider it to be no different.

Number 3) I was also making a point that Aldebaran is hoisting himself on his ignorant arrogant petard. That’s what the bit above was about asking if we could then say he’s ignorant of Islam if he can’t prove what he’s asserting.

Number 4) I await an authoratative citation of Aldebaran’s assertion. I mean other than his mere assertion.

If a Christian posted “Christians would find it objectionable to portray Christ as chimpanzee sucking a donkey’s ass”, I, personally wouldn’t step in and demand from them, a cite proving that all Christians of any demonination would find such a thing objectionable.

You may doubt that the poster involved is as learned in his religion as he professes to be, but his original statement (“Muslims would find this objectionable”) is not, IMHO, the sort of thing that would require some one to profer up a researched cite (Unless, of course, the statement was along the lines of “Christians would object to allowing public prayer in schools” - IOW, one that seems wrong, on the face of it, even to some one not of that faith).

[Quote]
You may doubt that the poster involved is as learned in his religion as he professes to be, but his original statement (“Muslims would find this objectionable”) is not, IMHO, the sort of thing that would require some one to profer up a researched cite

[Quote]

Actually, this could all be resolved very simply if at least a couple of other self-professed muslims would step in and comment. Is dear Aldy really the only one we have?

That ain’t his assertion, wring. Go back and read it again. He asserted that NO Muslim would use such a username. That’s quite a bit different from your hypothetical.

well, I’d still give it the latitude of “no Christian would name their child ‘Jesus is a fathead’”. IOW, I don’t think he’s claiming that of the millions of Muslims, there isn’t a single one who would use that as a name, rather that generally some one who is Muslim wouldn’t (probably) do that.

But, in any event, what you’re asking of him is impossible to deliver, as in there would be no definitive source of information polling every single Muslim and asking that question.

tomndeb already posted some piece of data that would tend to support the thesis that generally it would be frowned upon, but if you want to hold him to the letter of “none ever, ever ever ever,” I guess you will.

So that’s why my ornaments didn’t sell at the Christmas Craft Fair.

No, I think you just priced 'em too high.

From this website, we have

(Makrooh here means ‘disliked’.)

That should clear it up, yes?
For the record, I am not a Muslim. From what I know about them, though, gobear does have it right.

A question for those in the know…

Is Allahakbar correct the form of the phrase? I ask because the only version of “God is great” that I’ve ever heard goes Allahu Akbar.