Who wins? You specify whatever criteria you want to judge by.
Natalie, definitely.
Amanda Peet has the crazy eyes, but Natalie Portman seems really full of herself in interviews.
I guess Natalie Portman in a squeaker because she’s had the better career.
Amanda Peet, because of this:
Natalie Portman, because I had to go and look up who Amanda Peet is. And honestly, even after reading the Wikipedia article, my feeling on her is meh. I’ve never seen anything she’s done.
Not even close—Amanda Peet is much, much, MUCH more attractive than Natalie Portman…
(I don’t know too much about what either woman is like in their personal lives, but I have always thought Amanda is one of the most attractive women in Hollywood)
Amanda Peet!
NATALIE PORTMAN!
Ahem.
Natalie Portman.
Assuming we’re judging physical beautiful, Ms. Portman. It’s not even close. I’m a face man, and Ms. Peet’s face is not pleasing to me. I’m sure she’s a nice person, though.
If we’re judging their skill as thespians, also Ms. Portman. Even aside from her beauty, she’s always the most interesting thing on screen. The only performances of hers I have not liked were those from the Star Wars prequels, but she was defeated by her director there. Only Lee, Jackson, and MacGregor were able to overcome Lucas’s incompetence.
I don’t know anything about Amanda Peet except that I think she’s funny-looking and I have recollections of her acting manic, bugging her eyes out, and flailing around awkwardly in every role I’ve seen her act. Natalie wins - she’s pretty and graceful. Although, 2 seconds with Google shows me Amanda has a much better body. But her face is not attractive to me. It’s masculine, and her features are very harsh and exaggerated.
I’ve had a thing for Natalie Portman ever since The Professional. (I am close to her age.)
Peet, for The Whole Nine Yards.
Peet is a treat.
Off to Cafe Society.
Natalie, every day and twice on Sundays. Better actress, prettier. I wouldn’t say that either has the better body, but they’re definitely different.
Amanda Peet’s mouth weirds me out. She looks like she has far too many teeth.
Unless it’s a wookie-sponsored eyebrow contest, Portman wins every time.
- 1Amanda Peet.
When I saw her for the first time in Texas Chainsaw Massacre I waited for the credits to see who that hottie was.
Portman because she’s hotter than anyone I’ve ever seen.
Although she does seem REALLY full of herself.
Not even close. Peete by a mile.