I thought Nurse Rocker was pretty good tonight. A nice change from the wonderbread blondes singing elvator songs.
So far 2 mehs, a pretty good, and some jammin’ fun. I hope rocker nurse stays for a long time. She’s not exactly textbook Idol material, but she’s fun and spicy.
Wow, I’ve got to leave the room. That’s terrible!
I hope Amy’s excuse is that she’s sick, because that is some horrific singing. Ouch!
Another fucking meh. She missed on a few notes – hit a real clinker near the end there – other than that she was just as boring and plastic as the rest of them.
I want the word “cabaret” stricken from Simon’s vocabulary.
I wish we could just fire all the Underwoods the first week and move on.
The Aretha version ROCKS.
When Amy Davis started singing, my neighbor’s dogs started barking and howling, seriously.
No wonder they mentioned the flu thing because all the girls sound off to me. She knows it wasn’t that good.
God, Snow White is coming up next. I irrationally despise this chick. I hope Simon succeeds in corrupting her soul.
Turtles again. I would never buy this or listen to it but it’s competent. I can’t be fair to her because I hate her.
I really hate this chick, mostly because of the meltdown last week.
Brooke kept grabbing her own hair and closing her eyes, and it made her look like Meg Ryan in the deli scene of When Harry Met Sally. I want a screencap!
I’m glad that Simon called her on her happy/sunny, plastic mediocrity. I think he should introduce her to weed.
What, you want her to be happier? 
Where have they been hiding this Alex girl? I wish I could have seen her Amy Winehouse in Hollywood. Great song choice.
This one has good stage presence and a pretty good delivery but it’s not a great song choice. If you’re going to do Otis Redding, do “Dock of the Bay,” not “Spinning Wheel.”
1991 TLC had a yard sale and Alexandria went crazy. At least she was in tune.
Otis Redding did Spinning Wheel? Jeez, where have I been? I’m missing all this good stuff.
Seriously. Watching that youtube video reminded me the chasm of difference between idol wannabes and the genuine article.