Any advice on how to tell black kittens apart?

Hi everyone,

We recently adopted two black kittens - littermates, both female. They are absolutely lovely little girlies and we’re enjoying them immensely. The problem is that they are both black without any distinguishing markings - even the vet was surprised at how difficult they were to tell apart. We’ve put different coloured collars on these young ladies and they’ve been good sports about it, for the most part (one did ditch the collar a time or two). However, I think we need a failsafe here - does anyone have any suggestions on ways to safely visually differentiate these chickies?

I think you’ll find that as you get to know them better and as they get bigger they won’t seem so identical. One will seem obviously fluffier, or to have larger ears, etc. I’ve owned a pair of unmarked grey cats, and a pair of matched tabbies, and soon came to think they didn’t look that much alike at all (“see, Smokey is larger, and Bandit has a more round face, and Smokey is fluffier, and Bandit has a shorter tail and…”)

We need pictures so we can judge the twinness. Also, it’s the Roolz.

Nail polish (carefully) on some of the little toenails on one.
And, photos!

Trim the end of one tail square… FUR ONLY!!!

Skunk stripe down the back of one of them.

Declaw the one with the longer tail and the notched ear.

It’s Xmas season (still, a bit). I suggest a red stripe on one and green on the other.

Fight the stereotype! Give them the same name and act like you only have one cat.

Red polish on the claws of one, and light blue polish of the claws of the other. It will wear off, which is why they should each have a color. It should probably match their collars, so the colors are just examples.

Obviously, you may have to get close up to see, so squaring the tail of one is a good idea.

You will probably eventually learn to tell them apart, the way parents learn to tell their twins apart. They have differences, it’s just remembering which differences go with which twin. There were twins in my son’s preschool, and after seeing them every day, it became clear that there were small differences, but it was hard to remember which one had the cowlick that was further to the left, and which one had a squint to his right eye when he smiled.

Also, they will learn their names (it takes cats longer than dogs, but they learn them), and you will be able to tell which one is responsive to which name. Don’t give them rhyming, or otherwise sound-alike names.

Seriously, these kiddos do not photograph well - it’s just an undifferentiated mass of black fur when the two of them are together.

Thanks, Lorene89095, I might try this - they only have little pointy rat tails right now, so it would make quite a difference.

I know this will most likely be the case sooner or later ( I hope, anyway!), it’s just right now I’m having issues.

It’s funny, between my husband and me, we’ve had our fair share of cats over the years, but we’re new to this situation. Thanks for all the suggestions!

You could get them microchipped, if you want to be absolutely sure (e.g. for keeping track of their medical history).

You win the thread. Bravo.

Different color collars, red & blue.
Then name one Scarlett and one True.

absolutely NO nail polish. Cats sharpen their claws by drawing them through their teeth.

Shave some fur off one of them in a visible spot.

That’s what I was thinking! Why would you need to tell them apart?

This is also the advice I give to parents who have twins. It would totally be my approach.

Might give us more ideas if we knew what their names were…

Microchip. When they are spayed get your vet to put a drop of tattoo ink in the incision of one.

Photos or you don’t have kittens and are just teasing us.

Dollars to doughnuts if they came from an reputable agency they’re already spayed and chipped.

The chip reader costs about $350 so its kind of an expensive solution…

And what Second Stone said. There are RULES, this isn’t Nam.