Bacardi? Parrot Bay? Jesus… Anyway, wall of text forthcoming. Sorry, rum is my first love, so I get carried away.
As has been said, Flor de Cana is readily available here in Murica, and I find the younger ones to be decent, no frills rum. I’m not entirely sure of the purpose of Capt. Morgan. It makes an acceptable introduction to spiced rum, I suppose, but once you’re older than 17, you really shouldn’t be drinking it anymore.
Mount Gay is a good standard, Pyrat is very good but also very sweet, and in my old age, my fondness for sweet things has nearly disappeared entirely, and I find my love of rum has been almost entirely overtaken by my love of bourbon. But that’s a different story entirely. Pyrat is fine by me, and I’ll never say a bad thing about it. And I’m drinking Sailor Jerry right now.
These are all different. I’m going to assume when you ask about Cruzan, you’re asking about the dark rums. It’s fine, but is also difficult to compare to Sailor Jerry, which is a spiced rum. I’d put SJ in its own category, then rank the others as Pyrat, Mt. Gay, then Cruzan, which isn’t to say Cruzan isn’t acceptable, it just happens to fall last on the list. It’s still leaps and bounds above whatever swill Bacardi is putting out these days.
Who is this Linus and where did he acquire such fine taste? I feel like I don’t even need to be here, and you all can just listen to him.
It is very, very sweet, and as such, not for everyone. I had this kick for a while where I was drinking the stuff pretty much nonstop, but some people won’t be keen on the molasses/sugar overload. If you’re into Gosling’s though, the Gosling’s Old Rum is outragingly wonderful. Goes for more than most seem to be willing to pay for rum, but it’s just about perfect.