I was reading elsewhere about somebody’s recent forays into Skyrim years after everybody else and while they liked it they said the writing sucks. That’s something you get in almost any longer thread about any game that has dialogue or other writing in it. No matter what else eventually somebody will pipe up and say that the writing sucks and usually nobody tries to defend the game. I don’t really get it since I don’t usually play games for the writing and usually I feel most games have more or less good enough writing for a game, though there are some rare exceptions like the MMO Skyforge where I honestly thought the dialogue was written by a bored intern.
Is the video game writing really that bad? And what are the rare and elusive paragons of video game writing? Planescape: Torment, maybe? Some of the modern Telltale games? The new Shadowrun RPGs?