Are you "the marrying kind"?

Gosh, I don’t know!

I was always skittish about the idea of marriage. My husband had to wait until I could hold the panic down long enough to say yes, and then I spent the engagement in a panic too.

And we’ve been happy for 12 years and I want it to continue forever. I love being married and have zero desire to quit, ever.

But if he dies or something, I really can’t see getting married again. I think I would just go to work and raise my kids and do other things besides dating. I don’t think I’d want to do it again, not because it isn’t good but because I can’t imagine finding it twice.

Yes. I’ve been told since a relatively young age that I was the “marrying type”. I almost always look at potential relationships in terms of the possibility of marriage. Guys that can’t get over commitment seem odd to me. Being committed to the wrong person is awful, and should be avoided, but I don’t see the stigma involved with commitment.

I’m not the guy that hits on every woman he sees, nor am I the guy that wears ugly-ass Madden shoes, faded front jeans, and has hair covered in styling chemicals. I’m the guy that smiles politely when greeted by a person I’ve never met, and will only get fully involved in a conversation once I’m comfortable with most of the people involved.

It sucks that I’m usually only able to really impress my friends’ wives. They have had at least a little time to get to know me, and on several occasions their epiphany has been stated out loud “We need to have dnooman over more often!” I’m one of those “always a bridesmaid, never the bride” type people except I’m a dude. I’ve been a best man three times, but never a bridesmaid.

I’m fully prepared to dedicate unparalleled devotion and attention to the woman that catches my eye. It never occurred to me that the three things I held as most important, were the makings of satire. I’ve seen every episode of Futurama, and one that sticks out to me, is the one where they go to the factory where they print candy hearts. There is a test cell where a robot says “My two favorite things are commitment and changing myself.” The human test subject swoons. I could see how that would be funny to some, after all comedians make their livings using similar jokes. Concerning myself, my three top priorities are fidelity, commitment, and self-improvement. How is that weird? There are a ton of things I would do for my potential mate, as there should be, but I just don’t understand selfishness in a relationship. It seems really counter-productive to me.

I had a GF in high school that I was on and off with for almost three years. We had one real argument. Her Dad’s girlfriend showed us a picture of some guys dick once, it was at least a foot long flaccid. I was not amused. I found a close-up photo of a vagina, and gave it to my GF. She brought it to school, and made sure to let everyone know that it was mine. I called her a bitch. The next day everything was fine. That was the worst argument I’ve ever had with an SO.

I’m no pushover by any means, so it’s not like I’ve been avoiding arguments, or being dominated by them. I just prefer to reason things out. It almost always works.

Am I still talking about myself? Over and out.

Not so far, no.

Until recently, I was terrified of motherhood. Not of giving birth or what if the kid’s ill or any of that… just that well, since my grandma sucked at motherhood and my mom sucks at motherhood and it isn’t even in the same way but both have managed to be the worst ghoul in their daughters’ lives, how could I expect to be any better?

And since to me marriage implies a possibility of children, I definitely didn’t want to marry.

Now I’ve come to peace with the motherhood problems I miiiiiight be amenable to marriage - but the notion of each having his own apartment sounds perfectly fine as well, thank you! (I’m 39 and not particularly interested in “wifely” pursuits, although I do be marginally neater than most single men in general and a lot neater in the kitchen)

I guess not. When I give my heart, I give it hard. But I have given it rarely. And as I grow older, I find fewer and fewer women who are viable life-partners. There are still tons of them that I find physically attractive, but fewer that I want to fill my days with.

I’m definitely not. If ever I lost my husband, I wouldn’t marry again - I’m a very self-sufficient person and don’t need anyone to help me run my life. I’d rather not help anyone else run theirs (other than my kids, and only until they are old enough to look after themselves). Once is enough for me…

BTW, female, 42, married 14 years.

Wow, Belrix, I could have written this post myself. While my second divorce isn’t final yet, I, too, have been seeing someone new for nearly 8 months now. Like you said, it’s adult, quirky, loving and just all-around good.
My marriage had been very bad for a while, and I’d been feeling very down and bad about myself, and he has pulled me out of that funk. Yes, I’d say it’s all-around happy-puppy good. :cool:

Exactly. While I’m on my own for the first time, I miss being able to take care of someone else. (I’ve always lived at home or with roommates or a husband) While I really like being on my own, and cherish my alone time, I like being able to take care of someone else.
Am I the marrying kind? Yeah, I think so.
Will I get married again? I dunno, but you guys will be the first to know.

I am not the marrying kind or the moving-in-together kind. I don’t need all that much emotional space, but I need physical space–I don’t even like sharing a bed for a night. I pretty much want to see someone when I want to see them, and I have never met anyone that I wanted to be near more than every so often. I broke an engagement when I realized that not only did I not want to marry him, I didn’t want to marry anyone. If this changes, so be it. I am not exactly happy to be alone, but I am happy that I don’t need to be part of a pair like so many people I know. I have known lots of people who jump into relationships and stay in ones that aren’t good for them just so they won’t be alone. I am not afraid of being alone. I know it too well to fear it.

After two marriages and divorces I can say I am not the marrying kind.

I was only married the first time because I was pregnant.

I am not sure why I got married the second time. I really did not want to and told him no several times. I guess I caved after two years as we were living together anyway so it seemed like the next step. Five years later we were divorced.

I can say with all honesty I will never marry again.

My boyfriend and I live together and neither of us has any desire to get married.

Are you me? No, of course not. But the similarities are eerie.

I have no idea. I’ve met women about which I’ve thought “Hell yeah I’d marry her, love and kisses and forever and growing old together and being one of those cute old couples holding hands on the beach at sunset and everyone saying ‘aww, isn’t that sweet?’ and all that jazz.” But the earlier mention of Home Depot sort of turns me off to the whole idea. Real life is not the beach, it’s arguing at Home Depot.

And I’ve had a few chances. A common pattern in my relationships is that when serious talk of marriage comes up, within a couple of months, I’m breaking a heart.

I’d get married. I’d love to see what that’s like. But it wouldn’t have to be to the right woman, it would have to be to the really really REALLY right woman. And even then, we’d have to occupy seperate residences. And only see each other a few times a week. And have the option to call it off at any time, without all the ugly divorce crap.

I guess I’m with DianaG on this.

So here goes. DianaG, will you not marry me? Forever?

Wow, that was easy. :smiley:

I was married at 15 and again at 20. I had another chance at 27, but thought “What if I have three divorces by the age of 30?”

In the three years I waited while living single I realized how much I like living my own life by myself.

I had a friend (ok, and crush) who was like that all through our teens. The girls he dated were all set on their pre-planned life: get married at 18-20, have two kids by 25, that’s about it. He was trying to figure out what could and did he want to do with himself. He was charming, articulate, a good dancer; the longest-lasting girlfriend I knew him to have managed to lose him after a whole two years, by the same mechanism as every other girl before her and a lot behind. She mentioned curtains.

There they were, sitting on a couch in the bar where he worked, she babbling about curtains and him saying “honey? Uhm, honey… hooooneeeeyyyy!” and she just kept ignoring him. So two days later she got the news that he’d been seen smooching with another girl, which was his usual breakup method.

He finally was able to break up with a girl without any kind of “next!” involved, spent several happy years single.

The next time he dated a girl, he married her.

Nava, that reminds me of an internet buddy I had a few years back, from a different board. She claimed that she would never marry, and never have kids. She wanted a boyfriend, but just for the sex. (Ironically enough, she thought it was wrong to have sex out of wedlock. I don’t know what her thinking was on that.) But definitely NO KIDS, EVAR!

A few older women on the board told her that she’d change her mind some day. Nope, she said, she knew her own mind. Her ways were set.

Another thing about this girl was that she was most definitely pagan, and hated everything to do with religion.

Then she met Rob. He was born again, but totally hawt. He ended up getting a password on a private message board we were both on, and proposed to her.

On the message board! She said yes.

We lost touch after a while. We had a little falling out because we disagreed on creationism. She was all into “Science is just faith, and you know God created us.”

Last I heard, her kids are doing great. Jesus loves them.

I’m not sure if I’m the “marrying type,” but I’m happily married. I couldn’t imagine being married to anyone I dated before I met my husband, but sharing our lives just came naturally to us. We have similar interests and values, and we’re both wired (or trained, however you see it) for monogamy. (So, I guess I am the marrying type!)

We both functioned on our own just fine before–but like other people are saying “I need my space,” we both felt the need for close companionship. We both like the feeling of having someone on your side who you can talk to at the end of the day, who can help you solve problems, or who can kill spiders for you. (that’s me, designated bug squisher)

But that’s why it’s good–the reason I love being married is that I have someone who thinks like me to share these mundane things with. All being married gets you is easy access to another being, which can result in anything that people do together. It can mean snuggles, sex, political discussions, or loud nasty arguments. No one claims to be turned off of friendship because they argue with their friends. I’m glad we have the fights we do, because every time we make up, we honestly try to learn more about each other, and why we took the position we did. Being this close to another person has made me more empathetic towards other people, and I feel like a better person for that.*

Of coure, if you’re fighting with someone because you think they’re stupid and you will never ever agree with them, and they will never ever agree with you, that’s different. But an argument about whether you clean the dining room as often as you said you would–that’s just something that comes with living with another person, whether an SO or a roommate.

*obviously I’m not saying that you’re a bad person if you don’t ever ever ever want to get married. This is just for me, YMMV.

Sorry for the double post–edit window expired.

I just want to be clear that I definitely understand why some people don’t really care one way or the other, or actively dislike the idea.

The appeal for me came from the idea that we were solidifying our commitment to each other. Neither of us are religious, so that wasn’t an element, but I had a very profound response to the idea that we were participating in a traditional ceremony that publicly linked us. We didn’t feel insecure without it, exactly, but it was important to both of us, and mentally cemented our commitment.

Of course, that’s a very idealist sentiment, and marriage doesn’t really get you anything more than that, and tax breaks. Everything else is available in a long term committed relationship–including the arguments in Home Depot. :stuck_out_tongue: Which is probably why so many people don’t care about it–marriage is put up on this fluffy white pedestal, when really, all it is is saying “Yeah, I like you, let’s stick together.”

Oh, I get that. And in a way I’m jealous. I want that. But like I said, I’m extremely picky about who I would share that much intimacy with. A relationship like that just hasn’t happened for me yet.

I did live with someone for a while. It had its nice moments, but there were some painful bits as well. I couldn’t write music, because she was constantly watching the TV, and also because I wasn’t paying attention to her. My apartment (the rent of which she wasn’t conributing to) became her personal decoration project. All of my choices were “lame.” And she was constantly singing “I looooove the boyfriend!” I mean like 30 times a night. And every day when I came home from work, I had to instantly interact with her. There was no space to breathe. Oh, and the constant pestering me for functional sperm.

Maybe the problem wasn’t living together, but her.

What she said.

I know I’m the family type. I want to set up a home, raise a family, have someone to share a life with. The good, the bad, the ugly, the morning breath, the midlife crisis, all that. I can’t say that I understand people who live together for 10 years and don’t ever get married, even though I can respect their decision. For some reason, for me, the “officializing” of it is important.

I would consider myself the marrying type. I would like to be married but after my first marriage, when I was too young and too eager, I am not in a hurry anymore. I am not even looking to date anyone because like the OP I consider the purpose of dating to find someone to marry and since I am not interested in being married right now there’s no point of dating.

I would like to be married again someday and have a couple of chillin’s.

I don’t quite get this. Do you mean that the girl started talking about setting up a home together or hinting about getting married by talking about “how we should decorate our lovenest,” and that’s why he dumped her? Or do you really mean that the very mention of curtains would drive him away? What about, say, ovens? Or sofas? What if she worked in a drapery department and sold curtains on a daily basis? What if she just liked fabric?

I’m sorry, I’m just totally befuddled by this. I’m probably spending too much brain power on it.

I’m the relationship type, at least. I don’t think I’ve ever been single longer than a couple of months.

If you had asked me about marriage when I was about twenty, I’d have told you I didn’t believe in it. Yet, I accepted the first guy who asked me, when I was twenty-five. Looking back with 20/20 hindsight, I guess I just felt that getting married was what you did when you grew up.

When I was 35, I got married again (to the only other guy who’s ever asked). But I’ll tell ya, if he hadn’t asked, we’d just be living together and I’d be fine with that.

I hope that if I am ever single again, I’ll just stay that way. I may have relationships, but I think it would be good to live on my own at some point in my life.