I’m not sure why, but NFL coaches and general managers seem to get a hard-on whenever they see a guy who’s over 6 foot 4. It doesn’t matter if you can throw, it doesn’t matter if you can read a defense, it doesn’t matter if you have the IQ of a newt! So long as you’re 6 foot 4, some coach is going to fall in love with you, and some general manager is going to shower money on you.
I’m not exaggerating… much. But here’s a true story: some years ago, the Giants wasted a first round draft pick to take Dave Brown of Duke in the supplemental draft. Now, like most fans, I had NEVER heard of Dave Brown, and I KNOW he’d NEVER accomplished a damn thing in college. So, I was mighty skeptical of the pick.
Still, I tried to be fair. After all, we Giants fans were equally flummoxed when Phil Simms was drafted, and HE turned out pretty darn well, right?
So, when a Giants executive was a guest on a phone-in sports radio show, I had to call and ask, “Listen, I was just wondering, what have you seen in Dave Brown that leads you to believe he’ll be a great quarterback? What do you like about him?”
I SWEAR, the executive’s first words were, “Well, we really like his height.” In the next 60 seconds, he mentioned Brown’s height 3 times! Of course, to be fair, he also mentioned that Brown was very intelligent (very true, and a genuine asset), and that he was a local boy from New JErsey (true but ridiculously irrelevant).
I DON’T mean to ridicule Dave Brown, who seemed like a decent guy and an adequate backup quarterback. And I DON’T completely dismiss the value of height in a quarterback. But over the past twenty years, I’ve seen WAY too many guys who were drafted in the first round and showered with big bucks for no other reason than that they fit a certain mold: 6’4, 225 pounds, immobile, with a cannon for an arm. Anybody remember Dan McGwire, Jack Thompson, Heath Shuler, Ryan Leaf? I could names loads more, but you get the idea.
A few years ago, when Kurt Warner was leading the Rams to the Super Bowl, Doug Flutie was delighted. He told ESPN magazine, “I LOVE seeing a guy come out of arena ball and setting records, because it proves what I’ve known for years. NFL coaches and scouts don’t know what they’re doing. They take us to combines, they weigh us, they measure us, they make us stand around in our underwear, they give us IQ and personality teats, and they think all that stuff MEANS something! But it doesn’t tell you the one thing that really matters- can this guy play football?”
Doug Flutie is just one guy who’s been shafted because he didn’t fit a mold. In 1979, can you believe that scouts DROOLED over Jack Thompson, but dismissed Joe Montana as “too short,” and questioned his arm strength?
I will say ONE bad thing about Flutie: I HATED the way he handled himself in the Bills’ locker room. Even though I fully agreed that he should be the starter, Flutie handled himself abomninably. He became a venomous, cancerous presence on the Bills, and that was uncalled for. I understand why he wanted out, but he had no business behaving like a petuant brat after ROb Johnson was given the starting job.