[QUOTE=storyteller0910]
I think there’s also the fact that living with your parents provides an implicit safety net; sure, you’re theoretically “responsible” for accomplishing certain things, but you are ultimately shielded from the real consequences should you fail.
If you live on your own, and you can’t make the rent, you’re going to be asked to hit the bricks. What? You had car trouble and you can’t both pay for the expensive repairs and make the rent? Wow, sorry to hear that. So you’ll be moving out Friday, then?
[/QUOTE]
But, as long as you have parents who would take you in, doesn’t that safety net still exist? If I couldn’t pay my rent and got evicted, or if I couldn’t pay to fix my car, I might crash on a friend’s couch for a week or two, and I might bum rides or take the bus for a while, but sooner or later I’d end up back at my parents’ house or asking them to cosign on a new car loan.
As far as I can tell, the only thing that makes that safety net really unavailable is living so far away from one’s parents that it’s impractical to return. So, am I shielded from responsibility if I live in the same city as my parents? Am I less independent if I live only an hour or so away, rather than across the state? Even if I lived on the other side of the world, my parents still could (and would, I’m sure) wire me money if I needed it.
The difference is that if you live at home people assume that you’ve already been caught by the safety net.
I agree with Throatwarbler Mangrove that living with one’s parents is a lifestyle choice that can be made without being a loser. It implies certain economic, social, and famillal values that aren’t common in mainstream America, but also aren’t wrong. Many of you seem to be arguing that most people living with their parents are leeches or socially retarded. I agree with you, and I think that Throatwarbler does too. But that fact doesn’t invalidate his point that it’s quite possible to live with one’s parents for good reasons.
I disagree with the idea that one must pay full market rent in order not to be considered a leech. For one, there’s a risk premium included in the market rent cost that doesn’t apply in this case. My parents know and trust me enough that they know I’m not going to be inconsiderate, or steal things, or lawyer up if they ask me to move out, or any of the many other things that renters can do to make life misery for landlords. Frankly, my parents, nearing their 60’s, are unlikely to be willing to take on that risk for an unknown 20-something at any reasonable price, so I’m not competing against the opportunity cost of another renter in my place; that simply wouldn’t happen.
My parents know that I’d help around the house, that I’d be involved in the family. I’d be an asset, not a liability. There’s a lot more to consider than the amount of cash that changes hands monthly.
To anyone who’s claiming that paying a penny less than full market rent qualifies as being a leech or taking advantage: When I go home and help clear the leaves out of the gutters, or run wires under the house, or put a new gate on the fence (all things I’ve done for my parents that are no longer easy for them to do, physically), are my parents taking advantage of me by not paying me full independent contractor rates?