[QUOTE=Jodi]
Then we’ll sure as hell have to disagree as to the basic premise, because these are not the same thing. I don’t care if you want to travel by pogo-stick while wearing tofu shoes, but if you are living at home as an adult, I am entitled to wonder why and to ask you why. If your answer is “it’s cheaper!” I am entitled to ask: (1) Cheaper for whom? and (2) So cheapness is the overriding factor? Because in regards to No. 1, it may be cheaper for you but it’s probably not cheaper for your parents and in regards to No. 2, some of us value things like independence and having our own space more than we do saving money. And if you’re more interested in squirreling away the Benjamins (probably at your parents’ expense) than you are in having a life of your own, I am entitled to conclude we probably aren’t going to be compatible and that dating would be a waste of both our time because our goals and values are clearly inconsistent.
So which of us is the loser in that scenario? It obviously depends on who you’re asking.
[/QUOTE]
I agree with most of your post; however, there are many cases where a working adult child at home allows the parents to keep their house and afford better vacations or save more for retirement. In other words, it would be a mutually beneficial arrangement.
I mentioned two friends earlier. One was nothing but a leech on his family. He contributed nothing but companionship and eventually caretaking.
My other friend stayed home so his widowed Mom and Grandmother could keep the family house. He actually contributed the most to the house. His benefits were many; Grandma loved to cook and did a lot of the cleaning. Having his salary and his Mom’s they both had money left over for frivolous things like reliable cars and computers. He could have lived in a small crappy apartment instead and lived paycheck to paycheck. Of course, his Mom would have had to sell the house and move into a crappy apartment and his Grandma would have ended up in a senior’s “warehousing” center.
My older Brother still lived at home after I moved out. He contributed more than he cost them. He was putting his life back together, but my Father was forcibly early retired and my Mom’s job never paid much. What my brother did contribute allowed them to stay in the house for two extra years before they retired to a senior’s community. They were happy that their one lost child got back on his feet and made himself into an adult. He failed while living alone before moving back home. He is now a successful manager, not bad for a lost loser pothead without any college education.
I have another friend that lived with his grandmother and took care of her and from age twenty, paid the mortgage and taxes on the house. My friend’s father greatly appreciated his Mom being taken care of so well and helped out where possible with career changes my friend made while working.
When my friend finally got married, he and his wife bought a house only two miles away from Grandma so he could continue to take care of her and the house. I guess his wife might be a less judgmental person than you are coming across as.
Personally, I would love to own a very large parcel of land and have a family compound. One house I looked at had a large separate three-car garage with a very convertible attic space that I took one look at and realized that if we bought the house I could convert it into a nice apartment and rent it to my Brother. (This was before he was a manager.) We even looked at Mother-Daughter houses to share with my MIL. I now think this would have driven me insane, but we seriously considered it at the time.
I like my family; I like my wife’s family. While I would not want them in my house all the time, I would be extremely comfortable with them living very nearby or even in an attached apartment. When my kids finish college sometime in the distant future, I plan to ensure they are working, but if they wish to stay home and contribute to the household, they will be welcomed to.
Jim