[QUOTE=CaerieD]
At this point, I think the best way to sum it up is, “And then they all went insane.”
It’s like some sort of social experimental gone horribly, horribly wrong.
[/QUOTE]
Hmm… should I feel very glad that I bailed out? 
(Or guilty that my antics might have helped FUBAR everything?)
[QUOTE=CaerieD]
It’s like some sort of social experimental gone horribly, horribly wrong.
[/QUOTE]
It’s like a car accident. I can’t stop refreshing the thread.
When will this night end???
Hopefully soon, cowgirl! By the time this night does end, though, I think special care packages will be needed for the incoming dead, so that they can nurse themselves back to sanity. I can’t believe this is only the third night. Yeesh. Are any of them going to be able to use full sentences by the end of it, or is it just going to be a lot of monkeyish hoots and keyboard banging?
Night is over.
And… is OAOW dead or not? He was listed dead on the list of REMAINING players, which looks a little weird on the face of it.
Plus NAF fingered a Mason as Mafia if I’m reading the thread correctly–else why’d nesta be leaving the Masonic lodge? Hee.
Eesh. Welcome Winston and nesta. Here, this batch of nachos is fresh from the oven. You’ll need a napkin.
The plot thickens …
Well, that sucked. I guess karma is a bitch, and Gadarene gets to laugh at me now.
I want to know why I was killed. I think I know, but I want to really know. I wish I’d gone out in a lynching so I could face my accusers.
So did anyone following along have me pegged as mafia?
I don’t believe I ever thought you were Mafia for one second, nesta. You did really well. It would appear that our SK is far smarter than the rest of us, though. Congrats on lasting as long as you did.
I’ll share something funny with you. At least it’s funny to me now. Just before the night ended I asked NAF1138 if we were going to like the results of the night votes. He didn’t answer me. I bet he was laughing too hard to reply.
NAF1138, you posted earlier in this thread that some of the mafia were being transparent. Be honest with me, you were talking about my posts, weren’t you. :smack:
It is a lot easier to pick the mafia out when you know who they are. Gadarene especially was easy to spot.
I had your number, Nesta. A day late and a dollar short, though. Great job. My insane flame-out yesterday didn’t hold a candle to my false mason claim last time, but it was still fun.
I left an insanely paranoid epitaph to shake things up a little. I hope somebody reads it.
I don’t believe you had me Winston. 
I did have you, though… I knew you were town the whole time.
A serious question, was your last post a joke? Either way, I think it was bad form to post it after you were dead.
I read it, Winston. Nicely put, though I don’t entirely agree with your logic. Then again, obviously you’ve been following the game much more closely than I’ve been. I haven’t had the best of luck prognosticating on who’s who from over here. I had a couple of good hunches in the beginning (I seem to be good at occasionally spotting townies, at least), but when everything went crazy…well. I don’t know how anyone could make sense of any of that.
So, at this point I’ve given up on trying out any theories. I’m just going to watch the madness and enjoy. 
I still think that Fern Forrest is highly suspect, not sure exactly why. We shall see, uh, shan’t we?
Was my parting post in bad form as well?
[QUOTE=dnooman]
I still think that Fern Forrest is highly suspect, not sure exactly why. We shall see, uh, shan’t we?
[/QUOTE]
No comment.
My understanding of the rules is that dead players are allowed one post to say goodbye, but that it shouldn’t have any game or strategy related information in it. They are dead so they shouldn’t post anything to help the team out in any way.
I think NAF1138 should clarify this in the game thread to remind people of the rule if this is correct.
In this regard, I think your parting post was a little questionable. It was day one, and you were killed before ever being able to post during the day, so I don’t think it was a big deal. Winston’s post, though, is a chalk full of names, strategy, links to posts, etc. Night and day difference.
nesta:
[QUOTE=Gadarene]
nesta:
[/QUOTE]
Sorry, I was joking. Just playing on the fact that I was soooo sure you were mafia, even though I knew you weren’t.
Yeah, hilarious. 
I love how Blaster Master, who’s directly responsible for the deaths of Winston and myself, expresses absolutely no remorse, and even blames us for using bad logic. :dubious: By this point I’m assuming he is the Vigilante, but he’s still an ass.
Hey, I’d like to be given a little credit for your and Winston’s deaths too.
Blaster Master is doing a good job of keeping the town confused… and I think whoever killed me is an ass. I had my strategy all mapped out for the next couple of days, but no.
At least I won’t get fired for trying to keep up with that thread.
[QUOTE=nesta]
and I think whoever killed me is an ass.
[/QUOTE]
Someone that followed the rules of the game, and effectively killed you is “an ass”?
Wow, can one make whine with sour grapes?
[QUOTE=nesta]
A serious question, was your last post a joke? Either way, I think it was bad form to post it after you were dead.
[/QUOTE]
I established last time that I am the Worst Mafia Player Ever™. This was my second (ever) game of Mafia/Werewolf, and I think it’s pretty obvious I haven’t improved since my first game. 
My last post was a draft I was preparing to re-state my case and try to get the town focused. It was drafted Tuesday and yesterday, when my paranioa was at a fever pitch. 
I was under the impression that a parting post was an opportunity to do just what I did - post analysis and any final thoughts as a final contribution to the game, so players could learn as much as possible from your death. If that was out of line, I’m genuinely sorry.
nesta please check your PM.
/w