Bands For Which You Can Rattle Off the Entire Line-up

Not sure that’s 100% clear, what bands can you recite the entire line-up for (this includes the bass player *and *the drummer) without having to stop and ponder?

For me, immediately coming to mind are:

The Beatles
Rolling Stones
Who
Led Zeppelin
Fleetwood Mac
KISS (original line-up)
Van Halen
Rush
The Police
The Doors

and I think that’s about it.

Genesis, Queen, Aerosmith and I have and stop and think for a moment.

My list is somewhat devoid of modern influences. And I guess by “modern” I’m thinking anything after 1985.

Also don’t bother listing groups like Crosby, Stills & Nash, Hall and Oates, Loggins and Messina. Also we’ll go with the original line-up for groups that have gone through many transmutations.

Bonzo Dog Band
The White Stripes
Spirit
Beatles
Stone’s
The Who
Jefferson Airplane
Grateful Dead
The Doors
Traffic. (all incarnations)

Not many, actually.

The Beatles
The Who
Queen
Rush
Led Zepplin
The Stones (maybe, I might leave someone out)
Pink Floyd

The Beatles
The Traveling Wilburys

It never seemed important to me, so very few:

Beatles
Brubeck Quartet (the 60s version)
Fleetwood Mac
The Supremes

The Beatles
Fleetwood Mac
Styx

I’m pretty sure the Beatles are the only one for me.

Simon and Garfunkel
The Beatles

Ha. I guess I know that one, too!

I can also name all five Spice Girls (including their nicknames), but they’re not really a band.

I have to think of the hamsters’ welfare and so will not list every band I can name all the members of just off the top of my head. At the very least it’s several dozen, more likely it’s well over a hundred. Many of them I can even name who played on which album, as lineup changes happen frequently to bands. If these iterations are all separate bands, then my list is easily over one hundred.

The Beatles. That’s it.

There are other bands for whom I own practically the whole catalogue, but damned if I could name the members. Sometimes I’m lucky to know the lead singer.

Ramones
Sex Pistols
Kiss
Beatles
The Who
Nirvana
Led Zeppelin
The Monkees
Pink Floyd

I can play a version of “six degrees of Kevin Bacon” with musicians credits.

The Beatles
The Monkees
ABBA (but just their first names)

Too many to list, but I’m a guitar player and some of us obsess over stuff like that.

Rattling them off without a pause:

Beatles, Monkees, Wilburys, Steely Dan. That’s it. Oh, and the Rutles, though they weren’t a real band.

If I think about it, I can dredge their names from memory inside of a minute:

The Who
The Doors
Young Rascals
Moody Blues
The Police
U2

Bands I once knew all the members of by heart, and you might be able to drag them out of me under hypnosis:

Rolling Stones
Led Zeppelin
Talking Heads
Cars
Association
Turtles
Go-Go’s
Eagles
Fleetwood Mac (mid-70s lineup, of course)

When you’re in your teens, and in college if you went there as most of us did, you’re listening to a lot of music, sharing it with your friends, arguing about which artists/bands are better and which ones suck and why, you look at the CD booklets (back in the day) or album jackets (back in an even more distant day), and absorb a lot of details about the bands without really trying.

That stops happening after awhile. You get into your 30s, and nobody you know is even listening to new stuff anymore. Even if you still are, there’s nobody to talk about it with anymore. So you don’t even bother to learn the names of the two guys in They Might Be Giants, let alone more normal-sized new bands.

And it’s all downhill from there. Moving into the current decade, I love Cage the Elephant, but I can’t tell you the name of a single member of the band. I know who Florence Welch is only because her first name is part of the band name, Florence and the Machine. But when you’re in your early to mid 60s, you really don’t have anyone to shoot the breeze with about new music anymore, because even friends 20 years younger than you aren’t listening to it.

Yeah. My first thought was “all of them?”

A stupid exaggeration - I have no clue about whole genres and more modern stuff - but yeah, when music was more central, I geeked on stuff like this.

Probably over a hundred, but I’ve been a music geek all my life, read hundreds of books about it, even music dictionaries and extensive discographies cover to cover and have a good, but very selective memory that remembers who played bass on album X and who produced album Y, but in real life I’m very bad with names and don’t even know all the names of my coworkers. I only memorize things that interest me, it has always been that way, and my greatest interest is music.

ETA: I also study liner notes religiously.

My roommate in college and I used to do this all the time. I blame the back of the “Best of Uriah Heep” album for getting us started down that road.

(See if this link works…)