Belated pit for the first season of Last Comic Standing

I like watching stand up. I could never do it as I have a crippling fear of speaking in public, but I appreciate those who can do it and do it well. I often try to catch the Comedy Central specials for guys I know like Jim Gaffigan or the puppet guy, or guys I’ve never heard of. Sure, some of the jokes are kind of recycled, but in general I’m not too critical. I mean, how do you know your joke is the same one that some random comic used sometime in some nightclub years ago? So generally I cut them a little slack

When I caught this series, I was really excited for the possibilities. People bringing their “A” game, trying to win a competition, playing for fame and fortune. No clunkers right? Mostly good comics?

Yeah well that shit went out the window pretty fast

Now I have a pretty forgiving sense of humor as I like to describe it. I don’t hate anything that doesn’t make me roll on the floor laughing. I can chuckle at Jay Leno’s bland, non-offensive jokes, or laugh at Howard Stern making people uncomfortable asking by about their sexual past. But what I cannot laugh at is a comic who I personally detest. Once the comics moved into the shared house, nearly everyone became unbearable

There was a motif throughout that season, one repeated verball often by the host Jay Mohr and repeated in practice by the comics themselves. And that was: Respect the chain of command. Comics who have “been in the business” for a while automatically gets deferred to as leaders, whether or not they are funny. It’s like you pay your dues, then you get promoted, no matter your skill or work ethics. It’s sort of like a disgusting clown version of nepotism. Now I have nothing against that per say, but it interferes with my enjoyment of comedians if someone’s simply getting by with name recognition and nothing else

This bitterness at new comics was reflected in the almost universal hate towards Dat Phan.

Poor Dat Phan, an asian trying to make a name in an industry more famous for making fun of asians than taking them in. The amount of undeserved bile and hate and yes, jealousy, towards Dat completely and utterly turned me off to the show. I wanted to stop watching when they played hide and seek and nobody looked for Dat. I wanted to stop when one after another of the little idiot comedians cult challenged Dat. I didn’t want to see him lose.

The thing that grated me about these people like Tess and Ralphie May and Rich Vos and Dave Mordal is that they are bitter, stupid, and ultimately unfunny people who are delusional in their own skills at comics. Rich and Dave, being the oldest of the comics, tried to lead some sort of revolt against Dat. And for what? Being new? Their humor was forgettable and completely a rehash of every single non-famous, worn-out, middle-aged comics out there. “Oh my kids this, my wife that, blah blah blah”. I don’t remember a single bit they did except for the comment that one of them made about Dat Phan saying “Dat Phan’s afraid of original material.” Hey asshole, you know why? Because each one of your stupid cult challenged him and they fucking lost you stupid shithead!!! Dat Phan was challenged 4 times and won 3, which is 2 more wins than anyone else had and 1 more time than anyone else went up the stage.

And you know what, dickhead Dave or shitfaced Rich? He was smart about it. Voting was done by the audience in the room, not by TV or other comics. That means everytime they go up there to perform, they have a fresh audience. These people never heard him make the same jokes from before! So of course it makes sense to recycle your strongest material! A lot of good your “originality” did for you, huh Rich? What does losing taste like Dave?

I thought at first, when I caught the show, it was all about the comedy. But after the judges left and they comics were herded into the house, it became like Lord of the Flies. Ralphie May was impressive the first time I saw him. Yes, he was a stereotypical fat comic and he made fun of that and we’ve seen a million of those, but so what? Funny is funny. It’s relatable. I’m sure everyone here knows a bunch of fat, funny people who wouldn’t mind telling a pie joke or how marshmellow peeps run like scared Japanese when he descends on their aisle at WalMart during Easter. So I thought this was a guy who could win. But Rich/Dave should have saved his originality comment for Ralphie, because not only was he outed as an unfunny fuck, he was an unfunny, unrelatable fuck. When Ralphie lost his challenge, he did some insane bit about women and equality. What the fuck? He’s neither a woman nor does equality hold much in comedic potential when coming from a guy who’s the literal equivalent of 4 women. He might as well be talking about his childhood growing up in Africa and hunting elephants. It was just an stupid mess of a bit, and he deservedly lost to Dat Phan

Lest you think I have a lot of hate for Ralphie, my most vehement bile is saved for one Tess Cuntface. I don’t know if that’s her real last name, but she went by Tess so I’m allowed to give her a last name fitting her description.

Now I don’t know what it is about black people and asians, but they never seem to get along. They are worlds apart, I guess, in their beliefs and culture. I get that. But what I don’t get is why everything Dat does is, according to Tess, either stupid, weird, or insane. I give credit to Dat and his pages of notes, where he takes stock of just how his timing is, and writes down when a punchline should occur. That works for him and that’s fine. Maybe if Tess put a little more work into her material and less into being a vile bitch from the dimension of the pusbag ass eaters, she’d be the winner. Then again, when you’re and overweight, hairy woman with a punching bag for a face and a voice that peels paint, you shouldn’t be making jokes about wearing your thong backwards. Hey Tess, that laugh you received on that joke? That wasn’t amusement, that was the deaf people in the audience laughing at the face that all of the hearing people suddenly and spontaneously vomited. I hope you drown in a lake of used semen and aborted fetuses.

That was my first and last season of Last Comic Standing. I still see commercials for it, apparently it’s still on, but that hateful waste of a first season turned me off to comedians in general and the show forever. I don’t want to know what comedians are like. Make me laugh, then go away. Because it’s more than likely most of them are bitter, angry, former class-clowns who failed out of college. I don’t know and I don’t care. I’m just happy Dat Phan kicked all their asses

This is hilariously late. But the first season was all I watched of LCS before I decided it was just as crap as all the other “reality” shows, and I love comedians.

I totally agree too, Rich Vos came across as one bitter fuck.

I’ve had a need to cleanse myself of that show for 7 freaking years. Now I can finally go save the penguins or delivery a baby whale or some shit. God, I just hated those people so much

The only one I liked other than Dat was, I think, Rob Cantrell. I looked up his name and a picture of him and I remember the funny quirky guy with the big hair. Rich and Dave tried to draft him into their bitter circlejerk of assholes, but luckily Rob never fully embraced it, maybe because he’s also young and knew this demented group of fuckheads would turn on him. But I’ll always remember Rob for his hilariously odd bit where he pretend to be a semi-colon and said “Nobody knows what I do”. I respect a guy who plays off being punctuation for laughs

I recall the controversy about season 2, where the reduction from 3 dozen to 10 comics was supposedly judged by a celebrity panel.

When the results were revealed, the 4 celebrity judges noticed that the finalists were not the same as the ones they had chosen. It was then explained that besides them, four producers also had votes, and had a sort of veto power over the judges. This peeved Drew Carey and Brett Butler to no end. It was further discovered that some of the contestants were plants, being employees or clients of the producers.

Wow, I’m glad I didn’t keep watching then. It seems self-explanatory, just film a bunch of funny people telling jokes and pick the funniest one. Why it descended into madness when it’s such a simple concept is alien to me

The latest season is frustrating in that they only show clips of the people they are going to put through to Vegas. I want to see some competition, some of the bad comics, and some suspense about who might be picked.

Also, Iliza Shlesinger didn’t get much respect from other older comedians on her season, was was easily the most consistently funny, and deserved to win.

I’ve never seen that show, but that’s partly because i have a deep, abiding dislike of Jay Mohr. I literally do not understand how that guy has been able to make a career as an actor and comic.

OP raises a point seldom acknowledged. Comedy is not just humor - it’s an industry. Unfortunately it doesn’t seem to have much of a professional standard beyond paying your dues and not trash-talking other comics. That’s how big names can get away with not bringing the funni that often.

Also: Iliza Shlesinger. Iliza Shlesinger. Iliza Shlesinger. She deserves her own network late night show. Hell, her own network.

She definitely was the best of that season. And hot! :wink:

Hot?! Hot as the cataclysmic fury of a thousand star-suns.

Chelsea Handler isn’t fit to file her heel callouses. Unfortunately, Chelsea bangs network presidents - Iliza apparently doesn’t.

I only watched the previous season, but that mentality was there when all the other comics ganged up on the women who had the least amount of experience, Iliza Shlesinger. This backfired when she won the show due to getting the most time in front of the audience because the other comics kept choosing her to face off on stage.

Deferring to comics with more experience is understandable if your talking about Bill Cosby or Chris Rock or Jim Gaffigan, but not when you have the people who compete on this show. On the show, that hierarchy is being enforced by comics who getting older while their careers haven’t been progressing and they can’t accept that they are at the same level as someone younger than them.

I understand your distaste for Mohr. Fortunately, he doesn’t host the show any more.

I’ve seen Ralphie May live and he was fucking hilarious. In fact I would rate his show as one of the five best stand-up comedy performances I’d ever attended, and I’ve seen George Carlin and Bill Cosby live.
But 90 percent of the material he did when I went to see him he probably couldn’t get away with on network TV - loud, brash and very raunchy and liberally laced with the F-word - so he probably couldn’t bring his A-game to the TV show.
Otherwise I agree with you. I used to run in stand-up comedy circles (long story), and I can tell you most comics (including some who have actually been on there) hold this show in very low regard. Of course, that doesn’t mean that given the opportunity they wouldn’t jump at the chance to get on there for the exposure, but this is a group of people that by and large will take exposure wherever they can get it.

Not that the other comics weren’t bitter has-been-wannabe haters, but Dat Phan really sucked. Almost his entire shtick centered on imitating his mom’s voice.

As for Ms. Shlesinger, I just watched a couple of YouTube videos and she does little to dispel the “hot female comics aren’t funny” stereotype. Which is fine, because I generally prefer to keep my laughter and masturbation separate.

I thought Dat Phan was terribly unfunny. I was so disappointed when he won. But then again, there have been quite a few over the years that I didn’t think deserved to be on the show at all (hello, Ralphie May, I’m talking to you), and many that should have been there, but weren’t selected. I think the comics that move on should be selected by call-in vote, ala American Idol.

What I don’t like about the current season is that they show clips of certain comics at home, doing stuff with their friends and family, etc… That pretty much gives away the fact that they are moving on past the audition.

Also, I think Craig Robinson (this season’s ‘host’) is waaaay overrated as a comedian. I think he’s great on the Office, but I don’t find him funny in LCS.

Wow, this brings back memories. I was disappointed in the season, too. I actually saw Tess live. People in the audience walked out on her. The first thing out of her mouth was to make fun, not of Dat Phan, but of everybody who voted for him over her. And it wasn’t even remotely funny. She started cursing a lot, in an attempt to actually make her lame jokes we’d already seen on TV funny.

Okay, sorry for the tangent. While I wanted Dat Phan to win (I tried to vote for him, but kept getting a busy signal. And I never even vote for American Idol) I never thought he was that funny. It was more just not liking anyone else. The quality of the comics was so low that, when I found I had missed the start of the second season, I didn’t bother. And since nobody I know talks about it, I didn’t even know it was still ongoing.

Wow, it’s been a while. I only watched the first season but what got to me was just how unfunny every single person on the show was. I LOVE stand-up comedy and I don’t think it’s very hard to make me laugh. I like watching amateur comics on Comedy Central Presents. But I barely cracked a smile during the entirety of this show. Yes, even Dat sucked.

With shows like American Idol, you’re either a talented singer or you’re not. You can’t just open your mouth and start being funny. The only people who are good comedians are people with experience. The people with experience are already professional comics and they don’t need to sign up for piece of shit shows like Last Comic Standing. Them’s the breaks.

Yeah that was weird. I watched that first episode and when they are finally announcing the winners there were all those people on the stage that you had never seen before even for a second and you’re thinking “who the fuck are they?”. And of course all of them are the losers.

Heh heh heh haha ha haha ha!

Singing doesn’t work that way. And my objection applies to both classical singing and pop singing (albeit more the former than the latter.)

Yeah. American Idol just makes it seem that way. The people who are mediocre don’t make for good TV. I have a friend who tried out, and he’s actually pretty good, just now “wow” good. He didn’t appear on TV.

There is a classification of people who can or can’t sing, but the bar is much, much lower than seen on AI. If you can stay on pitch, you are considered capable of singing.