Cageprisoners displays photos of Obama "killing"

Cageprisoners is a “London-based human rights organization with an Islamic focus,” founded by a former Gitmo detainee. It has reacted to the bin Laden shooting by displaying a parody news article depicting the fictional killing of President Obama by Pakistani security forces in 2021, who discovered Obama living in a compound in the UK.

Sample quote:

[QUOTE=Cageprisoners]
Obama is believed to have ordered almost 200 attacks in North and South Waziristan between 2009 and 2011 in which almost 2000 people were killed, when he served as Commander in Chief of the US Armed Forces. Obama is also believed to have ordered the continued bombardment of Afghanistan during the same period in which thousands of others were killed.
[/QUOTE]

Further according to the ‘article,’ “Obama was cremated at the stake after a Christian funeral on board an aircraft carrier.” Also, Michelle Obama was killed during the raid when she was used as a human shield.

The article is here. BE WARNED that it contains a large, fairly graphic “photo” of Barack Obama with a bullet through his head.

Obviously, Cageprisoners is not actually calling for the killing of Obama. They’re arguing that the killing of bin Laden was unlawful and would be seen that way if the parties were reversed. So: setting aside whether one agrees with their position, is this effective parody? Counter-productively over-the-top? OK as text, but too much with the picture?

Personally, I think the picture is so overwhelmingly disturbing that it wrecks the rest of what they’re trying to say. Of course, without the picture, they might not have gotten noticed at all.

Mods, feel free to move this thread as you see fit. I couldn’t decide where it properly belonged, so I figured MPSIMS was the safest choice.

What does that mean?

If the effect was to make me want to kick thier asses then score one for them.

It means that these wingnuts can’t see the difference between someone who masterminded the killing of thousands of innocent people and the guy that ordered him either killed or captured.

In all seriousness, they sound like terrorist sympathizers.

No, it means that the wingnuts don’t think one good deed (killing Osama) excuses the deaths of however many civilians.

The picture is very disturbing. That’s a terrible photoshop job.

No, it’s not effective satire. Satire requires making useful analogies. Obama is not a terrorist, is the leader of a country, and was responding to direct attacks, if even those attacks mentioned are real. You can’t fundamentally change the character of the person to make it work.

They are intentionally creating a mythical group of people who are ordinary citizens under Osama. The only followers the guy had were fellow terrorists. The problems they have with the assassination are not in any way equivalent to what Americans would feel.

They call Obama a neocon–if they wanted a neocon, why didn’t they use Bush? Oh, right, the majority of Britain disliked Bush. Well, the majority of the Islamic world disliked Osama, too. They may have ethical problems with the way it was handled, but I’ve not seen a single one claim that Osama was a good person.

The ridiculousness of it just makes them look stupid. And I say that as one of those people who wasn’t really happy (nor upset) about Osama’s death.

Oh, and I agree with Pixiesnix. Man, that was awful. Plus, it again undermines the satire since Obama did not release the corresponding picture of Osama.

That’s a quote lifted from Wikipedia.

That’s the risk this approach creates, I guess.

So to recap, it may have been like switching Churchill and Hitler but on the plus side it has alerted authorities to future possible tube bombers. An overall win.

I don’t think the picture detracted from the story. But I don’t think the story was funny either. The analogy does not compute. Obama was elected by a majority of voters in a country. Osama was the head of a terrorist organization. I doubt there was an official vote to give him leadership status (I don’t know enough about AQ to say for sure though), and AQ is not a nation.

That’s not obvious at all, and there are people in the world who would not recognize this as parody. It is morally reprehensible.

My, our testosterone poisoning is particularly bad tonight, isn’t it? :slight_smile:

The article is not terribly funny, but I don’t believe satire is always so.