Profitable sports betting (and there is such a thing) is partly about math, but it’s mostly about doing the homework. You need to have more information or better insights than the bookies do, and they base their lines on the public, so you have to beat the public by enough to beat the vig. That is not easy, and the best sports bettors in the world might beat the vig by 2-3% over a long period of time.
The profitable sports bettors I know focus on college basketball mostly, because there are a huge number of games and therefore more chances to find a line out of whack with what you think the true odds are.
Betting on hugely traded gams like the superbowl is strictly for suckers and fans. Those games are far too scrutinized by everyone to uncover information the other bettors don’t have. Whereas heavy research into a college team might uncover some things the bookies don’t really have time to research, such as their performance in the rain, or the fact that a key player is hiding an injury, or whatever.
Sports betting is really tricky because of huge variance. You can bet on a team for reasons, and then they win for different reasons, but because you got the win you think your strategy is good when it’s not. It takes a LONG time to prove out whether you are a winner or a loser overall. Remember, your edge might only be 3-4%, so you’re still losing almost 50% of the time, even if you are a genius.
To make real money requires huge bets. Bet $1,000 on a game with a 3% edge, and your expectation is only $30 for risking $1,000. That’s another reason why college basketball is popular - you can make a LOT of bets and get to the long run sooner and make more money if you’re a winner. If you just make a handful of bets a year, you could go a lifetime without knowing whether your strategy was actually working or not.
The sports bettors I’ve known who were serious would bet $10,000-$100,000 on a game. That’s still only an expectation of $300-$3000, with huge risk. Syndicates and teams are popular for that reason.
One subset of sports betting that can be profitable: Instead of betting with bookies, bet with homies who will put money on their team with outrageous odds. But then you have to collect from them after…