Except for the solicitation stuff, these guys aren’t really trying to get ass. It’s about keeping women in their place, and that women’s appearance is a perfectly legitimate topic for public discourse in a way that men’s are not. Of course, if they got some ass out of it, they probably wouldn’t complain. It’s also often about seeming “cool” or “manly” in front of their guy friends.
I get catcalled all the time, not because I’m super hot but because I walk through Manhattan a lot. Mostly it falls into a few basic categories:
Being told to smile (because women should never look serious!)
Marriage proposals
“Positive” comments on my fatness (ie, “I love big/thick women!”)
Compliments on my hair
Incomprehensible gibberish from speeding cars and/or honking
A few stand out, however.
When I was in college outside LA, I was walking home from the Greyhound station. A guy came up to me on a bike and asked what homeless shelter I lived in (?!), and didn’t believe me when I said went to college there. Then he starts asking me questions about if I drink or do drugs or “party” or “date.” I answer in the negative to all of them, trying to walk faster, but this is a big, kinda scary guy on a bike. Finally, he offers me $45 for a “date,” at which point I tell him to fuck off. Luckily, he just laughs and rides away. I was really fucking shaken, doubly so because he thought I was homeless and therefore even more defenseless than I was. Asshole.
Slightly less unsettling, but still fucked up, I was walking to my office in Manhattan, on a side street. Another guy on a bike decided I looked good or something and decides to YELL at me, repeatedly, as I walked down the street with a bunch of other pedestrians. He just rode his bike back and forth down the street, yelling at me. I don’t think he was even yelling words, just sounds akin to “hubbahubba.” I didn’t think he was going to stop.
And the last story is not technically a catcall, but it made me feel very similarly. I was driving up I-95 in Florida, a very busy stretch of it. Now, I know I kind of stand out. I’m fat, I have a large and visible tattoo, and at the time I was driving a beater and, as I am wont to do when on road trips, probably singing along loudly to some music with the windows down because I didn’t have AC. I notice, out of the corner of my eye, that the car next to me was maintaining speed with me, and when I look over, I see a woman taking pictures of me with her cellphone while the male driver points and laughs at me. This is not an ambiguous “Maybe they like my car, or maybe they’re laughing at a humorous bumper sticker.” This is clearly a “Look, that fatty thought it was acceptable to be in public!” kind of pointing and laughing. I do the only thing that makes sense, and flip them off. This is somehow even more hilarious but also insulting, so I guess they decide that they can’t let me get away. I try switching lanes, driving faster, driving slower, but they keep hounding me. At this point, I’m crying and I really want to just ram their car, the only thing stopping me, really, is that a bunch of innocent bystanders would also get hurt. I’m finally able to get off at an exit where they can’t follow. I sat on the side of the road for a long time, crying and pounding the steering wheel, sure that they were going to hunt me down some more.
So, yeah, not catcalling, but it gave me that same sense of insecurity (this guy could hurt me if I say/do the wrong thing!) and objectification (all I am is tits and ass (or fat) to you!). It can really fuck with your psyche, even if it is just the crazy homeless guy who sits outside the McDonalds next to your office and tells you your a fat bitch one day and asks you to marry him the next. If a random guy says hi to me on the street, do I say hi back? Because some guys see that as an invitation to try and sex me up. But if I ignore it, I can get called nasty names. It’s really a horrible situation to be in, and I know a lot of women who always have headphones on in public so they can’t hear it. And it’s not about the way we dress or the neighborhoods we’re in or the time of night (and, frankly, even if it were, it wouldn’t excuse it). I know women who have gotten catcalled on their way to church Sunday morning wearing conservative clothes; 8 months pregnant women in sweatpants taking a walk on a weekday afternoon. I’ve gotten propositioned walking along a subway platform with my husband in such a way that my husband couldn’t hear it. It really is just constant.